4 ms·
>Apparently the dividing line between pro- and anti-gun isn't left versus right, but pro- versus anti- state-monopoly-on-force. And yet the traditionally pro-g
by krapp 6y ago
>Apparently the dividing line between pro- and anti-gun isn't left versus right, but pro- versus anti- state-monopoly-on-force.
And yet the traditionally pro-gun camp supports the Second Amendment of the US Constitution which, like all laws, is only legitimized by a government's monopoly on force. Also the traditionally pro-gun camp tends to be strongly pro military and pro law enforcement -- in other words, supporting of the apparatus by which the government executes on its monopoly on force.
If they were truly against the government's monopoly on force, they would be anarchists, but they aren't, they're statists by a wide margin.
- readflaggedcomm 6y agoYou argue that an inconsistency in armament would be more consistent with equal armament. I do not see the logic.
- krapp 6y agoNo, I argue that opposing the unjust application of the monopoly on force is not the same as opposing the monopoly itself, both the pro and anti-gun camps believe in the monopoly on force as a principle.
- Ancapistani 6y ago> If they were truly against the government's monopoly on force, they would be anarchists, but they aren't, they're statists by a wide margin. I’m an Anarcho-Capitalist, and there are a significant number of us in what is seen from the outside as the “Second Amendment” community. I would consider the healthy majority of people in that community as either “conservative” or “moderate libertarian”, but there is a lot more political diversity than you would expect.