3 ms·
This isn't some little detail hidden in the TOS. This is what a margin account is. If you do not have your required maintenance margin (and that may be a comp
by amluto 6y ago
This isn't some little detail hidden in the TOS. This is what a margin account is. If you do not have your required maintenance margin (and that may be a complicated calculation), the broker can and will sell things for you to protect themselves.
This is, frankly, common sense. If you deposit $100, buy $300 of stock, and that stock falls below $200, your account's equity will go below zero and your broker is in trouble. If this happens on a large enough scale, the market will be in trouble. The broker will try to protect itself by liquidating your position before this happens, and they may even be required to by market rules.
(The actual calculation of required margin is quite complex for good reason.)
- elihu 6y agoAre all of the forced GME sales in the situation you describe? (Not a rhetorical question, I'm actually wondering if it's the case.) Let's say your scenario is a little different: you deposit $100, buy $300 of stock, and the stock goes up to $600, then drops to $400. Then the broker sells your shares at $400 to "protect themselves". If that's what's going on here, that seems wrong. On the other hand, if it's as you describe that seems reasonable.
- amluto 6y agoI don’t know what Robinhood is actually doing, but I think your scenario isn’t necessarily problematic. Suppose I deposit $100 and Butt $300 of stock. Now I have -$200 of cash. (The UI doesn’t necessarily show it like that, but that’s what’s in my account.). If the stock goes up to $600, I still have -$200 of cash. If the stock drops to $400, I still have -$200 of cash. If the volatility estimates change such that a rapid crash to $199 seems likely, the broker should margin call me, as a crash to $199 would send my account value negative. Contrast this with non-margin trading. If I deposit $400 and buy $300 of stock, I have $100 of cash, and the broker doesn’t particularly care what happens to the stock price, since they are taking no risk. Their clearer may impose requirements on them, but that’s a somewhat separate issue.