4 ms·
A slippery slope argument assumes the maximum degenerate outcome of sliding down the slope as a certainty, that no one will be able to correct for, mitigate or
by krapp 6y ago
A slippery slope argument assumes the maximum degenerate outcome of sliding down the slope as a certainty, that no one will be able to correct for, mitigate or reverse the slide when it starts. That's what makes it a fallacy - it's a thought terminating cliche meant to eliminate the possibility of nuance, as any middle ground is implicitly part of the slope.
Otherwise, it's just an argument that risk exists, which is obvious and uninteresting.
- ttt0 6y agoSlippery slope is a valid political tactic for those outside the Overton window.
- krapp 6y agoIt's effective, because markets (including the marketplace of ideas) are irrational and bad faith tactics are often more effective at influencing people (at least in the short term) than reason and verifiable fact. I wouldn't consider it valid, though.
- ttt0 6y ago"Valid", as in, "it works".
- neltnerb 6y agoOr if it's really bad, they make up entirely fanciful slopes that you could fall down. Does it count as a slippery slope fallacy if the government argues that not stopping encrypted communications will result in terrorists killing your grandma? Because I heard that one a lot when Bush was president and they haven't really ever stopped using it. Is there a better fallacy for that example?