5 ms·
I've scanned the lawsuit (https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.553175/gov.uscourts.nysd.553175.1.0.pdf https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.
by jcranmer 6y ago
I've scanned the lawsuit (https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.553175/gov.uscourts.nysd.553175.1.0.pdf https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.553175...). I'm not a lawyer, but my first reading of it is that this is not a strong lawsuit.
The complaint is largely framed around "Robinhood prevented us from executing trades against GME, and it is contractually required to execute all trades." However, the actual contract explicitly says the opposite: Robinhood can choose to limit execution at its own discretion. So in order to win, plaintiffs basically have to get the relevant clauses of the contract to be ruled illegal. The extent to which this is possible is dependent on securities law which I am very unqualified to comment on, although I will note that the complaint does at least include some relevant allegations to what they need to do, which is better than other lawsuits I've seen (oh hi Parler).
- f430 6y agoMarket manipulation is still manipulation whether you've written it in your Terms of Service (which isn't the law btw like Craigslist do-not-scrape "law"). The basic spirit of the contract between a trade executor and the client does not allow for interference barring regulatory or SEC enforcement. Meaning RH took it on themselves to enforce a rule that its users had no idea of, hence the outrage. If it was well known (with clear warnings on the splash screen of RH highlighting their "special" rule) then the case might be different. If it gets rejected at this level then almost certainly SEC will be involved. If they side with RH then it would certainly destroy the trust of the retail trading industry. We also now seem to be witnessing a political opportunity for the Biden administration (ex. AOC's tweet throwing support for WSB). Essentially what we are seeing is a payback by the people who got outsmarted by a bunch of redditors and arguing that they cannot be allowed to fail for their own stupid trades (like shorting over 100% of the stock available), so they pulled all the tricks in the book to once again bend the market to their will like they always have. Anybody who thinks things will go as they have before are mistaken; We are in a very different political environment and stuff like this is the perfect opportunity for the Biden administration.
- enraged_camel 6y ago>> Market manipulation is still manipulation whether you've written it in your Terms of Service (which isn't the law btw like Craigslist do-not-scrape "law"). Yes. And intentionally interfering with supply and demand is the textbook definition of market manipulation — it appears in SEC powerpoints and everything! https://www.sec.gov/files/Market%20Manipulations%20and%20Case%20Studies.pdf https://www.sec.gov/files/Market%20Manipulations%20and%20Cas...
- beezle 6y agoI'm sure this will all be downvoted because it will hurt peoples feelings. 1- RH, Etrade, etc are not manipulating anything. The ones who manipulated were the reddit and other chat rooms. If Costco doesn't want to stock your favorite item any more do you get to sue because you still want to buy it? 2- If the customers had no idea of the legal documents they signed when they opened their accounts, their bad, not the broker. 3- 'the trust of the retail trading industry' Certainly not retail investors (who are not the people doing this stuff). And I doubt also retail traders who are not engaged in mob trades based on what is coming out of internet chat rooms/boards. There was day trading prior to the advent of Robinhood and Covid-19, right? 4- First off, the shorts are done. That is a large part of why the price went to where it did. Second, the brokers are protecting themselves from default on margin loans as well as the headache and aggravation of closeouts when 'traders' moan about the fills. 5- Why on earth should the Biden administration go to bat for a retail trading mob? Many of whom are on record in the press as having used their stimulus and unemployment checks as capital? 6- Shorts are not only necessary for a market to function well, they are a common part of the market having nothing at all to do with a view on a company. The largest example of that are fund managers selling the stock of an aquiring company against a position they own in the company being purchased. Fund manager could mean pension fund manager, mutual fund manager, or, gasp, a hedge fund manager.
- Sohcahtoa82 6y ago> RH, Etrade, etc are not manipulating anything. I don't know how you could possibly argue that when RH is preventing the purchase of a stock, but not the selling (Which pushes the stock price down), and trying to use the argument of "we're trying to protect you from volatility!" > If Costco doesn't want to stock your favorite item any more do you get to sue because you still want to buy it? This is such an apples-to-oranges comparison here that I really don't feel you're arguing in good faith. > 2- If the customers had no idea of the legal documents they signed when they opened their accounts, their bad, not the broker. As others have said, EULA doesn't trump the law. > 3- Certainly not retail investors (who are not the people doing this stuff). Either I'm misunderstanding what you're saying here, or you are 100% incorrect. It is absolutely the retail investors that are buying the GME stock and doing this. > 4- First off, the shorts are done We don't know this yet. > Second, the brokers are protecting themselves from default on margin loans as well as the headache and aggravation of closeouts when 'traders' moan about the fills. Defaulting on margin loans is prevented by issuing a margin call. Some traders are moaning about their GME being liquidated because they bought on margin while going all-in on GME, but even on WSB, most traders understand that's how margin works. > 5- Why on earth should the Biden administration go to bat for a retail trading mob? For the same reason Ted Cruz is. RH is impeding the free market. It's pretty crazy right now. Ted Cruz, AOC, Ben Shapiro, and Donald Trump Jr are all upset with RH right now, though for different reasons. The leftists are upset that the hedge fund managers are pissed that the poors are beating them at their game, while the right is upset that RH is interfering with the free market. > 6- Shorts are not only necessary for a market to function well If it was merely a matter of investors being able to say "I think this company is going to fail, so I'm going to short it", then yes. But then that quickly creates extremely perverse incentives. Now, it becomes "I have invested my money into the failure of this company, so I'm going to short it even more and publish articles about how this company has no future." GameStop got a new CEO and had a path to recovery, and the hedge funds didn't like that since they were already shorting, so they doubled-down on the shorting. The funds are using their money to kill a company. While this is technically legal, I think it's incredibly immoral and unethical.
- beezle 6y agoPersonally, in hindsight, I think the better course of action would have been to raise the margin requirement on those holdings to 100%. However, I imagine the SEC requires notice of more than overnight on such action which is probably why they have simply stopped trading those issues. The failure on the brokers then was in not gradually raising the margin requirements the past two weeks when it became obvious that this was a volatility disaster in the making. The failure of the regulators was, if correct, allowing shorts to be > 100% of the float. They were asleep and should have had a hammer on any dealers who were lending fictious shares.
- yaur 6y agoThey did that too
- banachtarski 6y agoYou're not a lawyer, which is why you don't understand that ToS writing never protects you from actual criminality, which in this case appears to be a clear case of market manipulation (restricting trades to only sales and not buys? how much more blatant can you get).
- jcranmer 6y agoWhich is why the complaint spends all of (checks document) 1 sentence alleging market manipulation: > Upon information and belief, Robinhood’s actions were done purposefully and knowingly to manipulate the market for the benefit of people and financial intuitions who were not Robinhood’s customers. And even then, there aren't enough other facts in the complaint itself for me to feel comfortable justifying discovery. For example, they never mention that Robinhood allowed only sales, instead alleging that Robinhood disallowed all trades with GME. The best route plaintiffs have to win the lawsuit is to argue Robinhood's illegality here. They don't do that effectively in the complaint, which hurts their case (though they could, and probably should, amend their complaint accordingly).
- TristanBall 6y agoSurely its a response to market manipulation? Which, almost by definition is going to require some level of intervention. My understanding is the forum members were colluding to drive up the price of particular securities? How is that not manipulation? Although I guess I would have preferred the relevent stock markets to step in with a complete trading halt on those securities if intervention was required.
- banachtarski 6y agoYour understanding is a bit oversimplified. What the members of WSB are trying to execute is a forced short squeeze to take advantage of naked short positions, which are themselves of questionable morality. However, this is not market manipulation, nor is it a pump and dump. If you read the rhetoric carefully, they are "holding because they like the stock." If this qualifies as market manipulation, the argument is that virtually any strategy employed by any hedge fund or investment firm anywhere would classify as "market manipulation," probably to an even greater degree.
- sandworm101 6y agoFor any contract with vague or difficult language, one has to read in a degree of reasonableness. The intention of that language was most likely to protect Robinhood if it took emergency actions, such as the circuit breakers on stock exchanges that will halt trading if it looks like the computers are doing something crazy (e.g. irrational sub-second runs/crashes of listed stocks). A court could reasonably say that what is happening with Gamestop today is similar to such situations, that Robinhood can protect itself and investors by not executing trades for the period of the crisis. What Robinhood definitely could not do under that language is, for example, halt all trading except on Gamestop. That would definitely not be a reasonable emergency action.