4 ms·
"I always hear people beg off trying medication for mental health because they 'don't want to rely on a drug for the rest of their life.' I never hear that stat
by Alex3917 15y ago
"I always hear people beg off trying medication for mental health because they 'don't want to rely on a drug for the rest of their life.' I never hear that statement when someone is talking about blood pressure medication or cholesterol pills."
Then I take it you haven't been paying any attention to the news this past week.[1]
There are literally thousands of academic studies on depression. Is it really too much to ask that people learn something about the major findings in the field before giving others advice? Sorry, but it's extremely irresponsible to start taking drugs (or recommending them to others) without reading up on the academic research on what they do, whether we're talking about smoking crack or taking something your doctor prescribed.
[1] http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/health/jan-june11/cholesterol_05-27.html http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/health/jan-june11/cholesterol...
- georgieporgie 15y agoThen I take it you haven't been paying any attention to the news this past week. Huh? That only reinforces his point. Millions of people are on cholesterol medication. People have an irrational, negative reaction to medication related to mental health, yet cholesterol medication is socially acceptable. He wasn't discussing efficacy, he was discussing willingness to use medication.
- Alex3917 15y ago"That only reinforces his point. [...] He wasn't discussing efficacy, he was discussing willingness to use medication." Whether or not it reinforces his point is irrelevant if his advice is wrong to begin with.
- georgieporgie 15y agoBut you posted a link about a single study showing a specific cholesterol drug being ineffective. How does that show his advice to be wrong?
- Alex3917 15y ago"How does that show his advice to be wrong?" It doesn't. But people should be questioning whether the longterm use of HDL-raising drugs is a good idea, because it's highly uncertain whether this is actually the case. The reason why I quoted it is that this common mistake is symptomatic of the same kind of sloppy thinking throughout the rest of the piece.
- gfunk911 15y agoThere's a growing body of evidence that statins are actually net harmful to the body. Millions of people are on medications that are helping them, and other millions of people are overmedicated.
- georgieporgie 15y ago...which still has nothing to do with the author's original statements regarding the social bias against medication for mental issues.
- cwzwarich 15y agoMillions of people are on antidepressants too.
- georgieporgie 15y agoAnd one of these groups is more reluctant than the other to use medication for their condition due to social bias. Which was the point.
- cwzwarich 15y agoIs that really true? How does reluctance to take antidepressants compare with reluctance to take medications with similar side effect profiles?
- brianleb 15y agoIf you think that the side effect profile is what keeps people from taking about their personal mental health issues with their doctor, you're mistaken. There is a long-standing social stigma against people with mental disorders, and you can find it in our media throughout the past decades. Depression, for example, has been looked at as a weakness, because people that don't have it don't understand it. They look at someone and just tell them to 'snap out of it' or 'exercise more' or 'get more sunlight.' They see depression as a weakness of character, they do not see it as a disease.
- Poiesis 15y agoSame with ADD/ADHD.
- SoftwareMaven 15y agoIt is comments like these that make it so difficult for some people to get treatment. Drugs should almost never be a first choice for any disease, but just like you wouldn't tell a cancer patient to forgo drugs, depression can become a fight for your life, and sometimes drugs are appropriate in that fight. That is not hyperbole. Suicide is a very real potential side effect of depression. Notwithstanding that, life is so gray and dingy when depressed that it feels like one isn't living in any meaningful way.
- Alex3917 15y ago"just like you wouldn't tell a cancer patient to forgo drugs, depression can become a fight for your life, and sometimes drugs are appropriate in that fight." No argument, did I ever say or imply otherwise? There's no doubt that drugs are sometimes the right choice, but the author was basically saying that drugs are always the right choice, which is moronic. People should make intelligent and informed decisions, it's part of being an adult.
- SoftwareMaven 15y agoI didn't read the author that way. I read the author saying drugs are a viable choice. Don't discard them simply because there is a social stigma against them.
- MaxGabriel 15y agoI think this is one of the most dangerous lines of thinking, because it is used to (and if not, has the effect of) stifling legitimate criticism of drugs. This is ESPECIALLY true when the person, like Alex, was approaching the issue in an academic way. If there's a risk that antidepressants worsen the course of depression and have dangerous side effects (suicide being the most prominent), a well-reasoned approach that reviews academic studies is certainly called for. The other problem with this position is that it presumes the correctness of your view. Let's presume the opposite--that for the majority of people the drugs worsen the course of the illness, as per my post before. If this is the case, then your comment is the one that's doing all the harm.
- ignifero 15y agoDepression is as physiological as any other disease. And it's chronic. Drugs are probably the most effective way to fight it and they can help the depressed person energize themselves towards tackling their problem in other ways. Of course it goes without saying that nobody should be taking drugs unless they 've been prescribed by a doctor.
- Alex3917 15y ago"Drugs are probably the most effective way to fight it and they can help the depressed person energize themselves towards tackling their problem in other ways." It's not an opinion question, there is actual research that's been done on this.
- Tichy 15y agoMaybe some forms of depressions are, but certainly not all of them. Sometimes circumstances are actually depressing, and people become depressed as a result. Sure, the actual depression is something physiological (neurons firing, hormones, whatever). That doesn't imply that it is caused by physiological malfunctioning.
- ignifero 15y agoThe article refers to some form of clinical depression. Having the blues is not depression. Although we dont know the exact correlates of depression, we know it has something to do with neurotransmitters and is most definately physiological (note how hormonal changes such as birth can cause depression, or how SSRIs are used to treat depression). It's the denial of this fact that usually leads to drug aversion.