11 ms·
After Melvin Capital loses billions with their naked shorts, Citadel and other hedge funds short selling take over to pulls the strings from underneath some tra
by rvz 6y ago
After Melvin Capital loses billions with their naked shorts, Citadel and other hedge funds short selling take over to pulls the strings from underneath some trading apps, including Robinhood.
Will be interesting to see where this lawsuit will go, since it looks like a clear coordinated manipulation of heavily shorted stocks and blocking everyone else from buying them.
Rigged from the beginning. But we'll see what happens with this lawsuit.
I guess someone is only letting the hedge funds trade rather than their own customers. [0]
[0] https://twitter.com/RobinhoodApp/status/712708069369782272 https://twitter.com/RobinhoodApp/status/712708069369782272
- gowld 6y agoWhat naked shorts? Do you have any evidence for these claims?
- mmastrac 6y agoI think the fact that Gamestop is >100% shorted suggests that there is naked short selling happening _somewhere_. Clearly there were shenanigans. EDIT: apparently multiple lending of shares does happen and Overstock sued over this [1] [1] https://www.courthousenews.com/overstock-com-settles-short-sales-litigation/ https://www.courthousenews.com/overstock-com-settles-short-s...
- greenshackle2 6y agoYour link explains what actual naked shorting is, you should read it. It says nothing about re-lending. Naked shorting is not "re-lending", it's a very specific technical thing where you sell the stock without owning or borrowing it at all. Naked shorting results in failure to deliver. Stock trades settle a couple of days after execution, so what it means in practice is that Alice "buys" the stock from Charlie, then 2 days later when settlement should happen and the share and money are supposed to actually change hands, Charlie goes oops I don't actually have the stock. Then the trade is undone. In effect Charlie duped Alice into a fake trade that artificially depressed the market price. It's an egregious market manipulation tactic and has nothing in common with the practice of lending or re-lending shares, in fact there is not a single share involved at all. If you fail-to-deliver enough you'll get booted by other market participants and/or the SEC.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- greenshackle2 6y agoNo, it doesn't mean that. The same share can be borrowed more than once. If A borrows a share from B, who borrowed it from C, the same share is shorted twice without naked shorting.
- mmastrac 6y ago[deleted, misunderstood how this works]
- plouffy 6y agoHow do you short ? You short by borrowing a stock, and selling it. Why would lending it instead of selling it be a naked short ?
- the_pwner224 6y agoYou can recall the shares you lent anytime. So if A borrows shares to short, and lends them out to B so B can short, if A wants to close their position they can tell B to give back the share. Not naked even though A has reloaned the share.
- greenshackle2 6y agoNo. Re-lending and naked shorting are nothing alike. Actually my example kinda sucked. What's more likely to happen is that B borrows the stock from A, then sells it to C. C then lends the share to D. C doesn't know or care that the share was already borrowed once, and the only way to prevent re-lending it that way would be to make shares non-fungible, which would break more-or-less everything (then again maybe that's your goal).
- grapehut 6y agoNo, it doesn't. Imagine there is 1 share, owned by A. He lends it to B. B now (short) sells it to C. Now from C's point of view, he owns a share. So he lends it to someone. That person then short sells it. So you have 1 share, that's shorted twice. But it's impossible for A and C to both have their loan repaid, because there's only 1 physical share.
- jfengel 6y agoDoesn't it unwind by just reversing the process? D buys the stock back from E and returns it to C. Then B buys the stock back from C and gives it to A. That all sounds perfectly ordinary, as long as it doesn't happen on a deadline. If you tell D or B that they have to buy that stock right now at any price, they're going to take it in the (ahem) shorts. But if they were permitted to take their time, they'd buy it up at the market price, which would on average be pretty near the price they sold it. It just so happens that there is a mechanism by which they can be forced to buy that stock right now, which is when F decides just on a whim to pay 100x the market price, and protection measures kick in. That's a screw-up on the part of B and D; they got sloppy and deserve to get raked over the coals for it. Everybody who wants to play that game needs to be aware of that scenario, and now they are. But I don't think it's because there's anything impossible about having more shorts than stocks. It just takes an already risky thing and makes it super subject to manipulation.
- plouffy 6y agoNo. Person A has 100 stocks. Person B wants to short the stock. So Person B, borrows 50 stocks from person A and sells it to person C. The float is now > 100%.
- mox1 6y agohttps://www.nyse.com/regulation/threshold-securities https://www.nyse.com/regulation/threshold-securities This is a list of stocks that have been sold, but the seller failed to deliver those shares. AKA naked shorting. GME has been on this list for a month now. SEC call this "Reg SHO". https://www.sec.gov/investor/pubs/regsho.htm https://www.sec.gov/investor/pubs/regsho.htm
- tomp 6y agoWow, I though it was impossible to do "naked shorts" (i.e. why "short borrow" exists) and that people screaming "naked short" were just spreading FUD, but this proves me wrong! Of course, this list isn't indicative of the amount (i.e. coud literally be one share undelivered) but the mere existence of it is mindblowing! Someone should be paying massive penalties and/or be in jail (as I'm sure would happen to "retail investors" if they were unable to deliver...)
- toomuchtodo 6y agohttp://investors.overstock.com/news-releases/news-release-details/overstock-ceo-comments-secs-new-rules-against-naked-short http://investors.overstock.com/news-releases/news-release-de...
- cldellow 6y agoCaveat: I don't know anything about short selling, so I may be misinterpreting this. That said, https://www.investor.gov/introduction-investing/investing-basics/glossary/threshold-securities https://www.investor.gov/introduction-investing/investing-ba... notes you only get listed as a threshold security if a few criteria are met, one of which is that the amount failed to deliver must be: > equal to at least 0.5% of the issuer's total shares outstanding Based on 70M outstanding shares, that means at least 350,000 undelivered shares. We don't know _why_ there was a failure to deliver, though. Not all failures may be related to short selling - someone's system screwing up for mundane reasons could cause such a thing, with no malice required.
- natrik 6y agoCitadel, Point72 to Invest $2.75 Billion Into Melvin Capital Management - 3 days ago [0] [0] https://www.wsj.com/articles/citadel-point72-to-invest-2-75-billion-into-melvin-capital-management-11611604340 https://www.wsj.com/articles/citadel-point72-to-invest-2-75-...
- cma 6y agoWith Citadel as a large market maker I would think Robinhood likely has a financial conflict of interest with them with respect to their customers, selling Citadel "dumb flow" (and now, depending on how you look at it, lobotomizing the flow).
- exhilaration 6y agoIt's a different Citadel, from here: https://www.theverge.com/22251427/reddit-gamestop-stock-short-wallstreetbets-robinhood-wall-street https://www.theverge.com/22251427/reddit-gamestop-stock-shor... At least one Wall Street firm has taken heavy losses — Melvin Capital Management, which was shorting GameStop, among other bets. It’s been bailed out by Citadel, which, confusingly, is not the same thing as Citadel Securities. (Citadel is a hedge fund, not a market maker.)
- whitepoplar 6y agoIt's the same Citadel, just different legal entities.
- stretchcat 6y agoIt's a ""different"" Citadel only in the twisted sort of logic lawyers are hated for. They're operated by the same people and have the same name.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 0x426577617265 6y agoIt's probably purely a math question -- what's cheaper impending lawsuit (we can settle) or losing our trade?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Miner49er 6y agoTrue, there needs to be an SEC investigation and jail time.
- HenryKissinger 6y agoJail time. I'm laughing. No one will go to prison over RH temporarily prohibiting its users from placing buy orders on a few particular stocks due to collective market manipulation through social media. There is nothing illegal about RH's actions, despite the faux outrage.
- sfennell 6y ago"Collective Market Manipulation" so ... that is what we are calling buying stocks now?
- HenryKissinger 6y agoNo... Collective market manipulation is what we are calling thousands of people reading the threads on wallstreetbets and hyping stocks with one another.
- speeder 6y agoIf the claims of this guy: https://twitter.com/justinkan/status/1354853920762253315 https://twitter.com/justinkan/status/1354853920762253315 are true, I find this might be quite possible.
- Someone1234 6y agoWhy are you contrasting those two things? Don't they BOTH get sued AND lose retail trade volume by restricting these tickets?
- jorblumesea 6y agoIt's a simple math question. SEC fine will not be close to the billions they stand to lose. Nakedly illegal, and everyone knows it.
- fossuser 6y agoI'm pretty sure you're wrong about this and this isn't 'naked shorting'. I have pretty low confidence in the detailed specifics here, but I saw some discussion on Twitter that naked shorting being legal could have actually prevented the squeeze we're seeing. [0] The reason for the extra >100% has to do with how the stock lending works (Matt Levine wrote a bit about this recently). [1] Quoted below. -- "This does not necessarily mean a lot of people are doing evil illegal nefarious naked shorting! Really, I promise! There is no special limit on shorting at 100% of shares outstanding! Here is an explanation of how options market makers (discussed below) are allowed to short without a locate, but I want to offer an even simpler explanation. There are 100 shares. A owns 90 of them, B owns 10. A lends her 90 shares to C, who shorts them all to D. Now A owns 90 shares, B owns 10 and D owns 90—there are 100 shares outstanding, but 190 shares show up on ownership lists. (The accounts balance because C owes 90 shares to A, giving C, in a sense, negative 90 shares.) Short interest is 90 shares out of 100 outstanding. Now D lends her 90 shares to E, who shorts them all to F. Now A owns 90, B 10, D 90 and F 90, for a total of 280 shares. Short interest is 180 shares out of 100 outstanding. No problem! No big deal! You can just keep re-borrowing the shares. F can lend them to G! It's fine." -- I still think what Robinhood did here is both wrong and a stupidly short-sighted that will damage their brand, but there's so much over confident misinformation about what's happening surrounding this that it makes it harder to understand. The NYT is no better - another dumb Taylor Lorenz article got less right than most random Twitter threads. [0]: https://twitter.com/simoj_/status/1354664677364609026 https://twitter.com/simoj_/status/1354664677364609026 [1]: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2021-01-25/money-stuff-the-game-never-stops https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2021-01-25/money-...
- kevmo 6y agoIt isn't going to just damage their brand -- Robin Hood the blockbuster business is basically over. They will never recover from this. Amusingly, them blowing up Robin Hood made me put up an order for $GME. If their position is so valuable that Citadel would destroy a business worth billions, then I am convinced this is an amazing speculative play.
- fossuser 6y ago
- mrtksn 6y agoI wouldn’t know where it goes legally but what I hope that it leads to the understanding that the stock market is not the economy and even is not a market. I would love to have a free investment market where the money is made when the companies succeed, not a casino that kicks you out for counting cards.
- Geminidog 6y agoWhen you divvy up shares in an investment to meaningless portions like 0.00001% of a company there's no utility in the investment period. It then becomes the same thing as buying and selling useless paper. In order to make the system truly a market you have to restrict the size of the portions. Something like 1% is the smallest cut someone can own. But then that would stop the huge amount of cash companies tend to receive during an IPO thereby restricting the growth of the actual business.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> Melvin Capital loses billions with their naked shorts, Citadel and other hedge funds short selling Citadel has no short positions to speak of in GameStop. They bailed out Melvin, which means they made money, not Melvin's positions per se. Also, by the time that happened Melvin had already closed out its short [1]. The conspiracy hypothesis might have legs if Citadel's asset management and market making arms colluded. Absent evidence, however, it's a suspicion at best. Robinhood is between a rock and a hard place of its own making. Market makers stopped making markets in an increasingly-volatile stock. Robinhood, having relied on market makers for execution, likely has sub-par exchange connections, so their execution quality started degrading. They're also staring down almost-guaranteed lawsuits regardless of what they do. If they badly execute, lawsuit. When the bubble pops, lawsuit for having been induced to trade through their gameified UI. If they block, lawsuit for interfering with trading. [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2021/01/27/hedge-fund-targeted-by-reddit-board-melvin-capital-closed-out-of-gamestop-short-position-tuesday.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/01/27/hedge-fund-targeted-by-reddi...
- scythe 6y ago>Citadel has no short positions to speak of in GameStop. They bailed out Melvin, which means they made money, not Melvin's positions per se. Also, by the time that happened Melvin had already closed out its short. You have made these claims dozens of times today without citing sources. Are you spreading insider information, lying, or just incredibly lazy and don't care if people believe you?
- JumpCrisscross 6y agoLazy and don't care if people believe me. I'm commenting on HN. I have zero horses in this race beyond entertainment. Added source for Melvin Capital making public statements on its short position. They could be lying. But then that's securities fraud.
- nikisweeting 6y agoThe SEC fine / lawsuits for that lie are very low relative to what they'd lose on those short positions.
- dcolkitt 6y agoI don’t think people really understand how Citadel’s internal structure works. It’s not just one mustache twirling villain, deciding what to do. The market making unit is in a totally different part of the org chart, with its own PnL lines, than the hedge fund. In fact Citadel Securities is a separate company than Citadel Investments. But most importantly there’s a legally mandated Chinese firewall between the two. Employees on one side are not allowed to discuss operations with employees on the other. This is enforced to the extent, that an employees access card won’t let them enter the other side of the division. Citadel makes a shit ton of money as it is. Nobody there is going to risk major jail time with an easy to unravel scheme involving dozens of co-conspirators, just to make a few extra bucks on a tiny short position.
- stonogo 6y agoThis is weasel crap, and pretending that separation is meaningful is one of the reasons people hate legalese smoke and mirrors. All it takes is someone near the top of the org to send some messages, and you don't have to be in the same room to do it. The financial world pretends this crap works because otherwise they'd be rightfully pilloried for exactly the kind of shit that is happening right now.
- imcoconut 6y agoI don't know for sure but I don't think there needs to be a chinese firewall between the two like at banks. Banks investment banking and advisory divsiions have access to insider information by the nature of their work, which is why the chinese firewall exists between them and the sales and trading desk. Citadel is a hedge fund, however that uses only public information (presumptively, as otherwise would be illegal) so i don't think there's a reason why they would need to be firewalled off. Also Citadel does use Citadel Securities for execution. Additionally, they're both owned (mostly) by Ken, who is know for being a bit "detailed" (to put it nicely) when it comes to his businesses. He almost certainly has live second by second pnl updates for all parts of all of his business, he almost certainly was the one who made the decision to invest 1.4+ bn into Melvin, and he almost certainly knows that retail flow (esp robhinood) is a huge part of citadel securities business. Honestly I think reddit has some grounds for a case here, but IANAL.
- vmchale 6y ago> Citadel and other hedge funds short selling take over to pulls the strings from underneath some trading apps, including Robinhood. Webull's clearing firm forced their hand.