7 ms·
I'm just not really sure I understand the narratives being thrown around right now, and I'd like to think I understand the economy somewhat Melvin Capital clos
by whimsicalism 6y ago
I'm just not really sure I understand the narratives being thrown around right now, and I'd like to think I understand the economy somewhat
Melvin Capital closed out their short position yesterday with a large loss - and Citadel helped cover that loss.
As far as I know, Citadel and Melvin Capital no longer are holding any short positions in Gamestop. So what do they have to gain, by your narrative, from suppressing the price?
Citadel is probably making bank off of this actually, like a lot of other sell-side firms.
- warkdarrior 6y agoIf SEC decides at some point that this was pump-and-dump scheme (even crowdsourced), the Citadel may become liable for enabling that scheme, even if they do not run it themselves.
- whimsicalism 6y agoI think it is much more likely that Robinhood is liable than the liquidity provider for Robinhood.
- cameldrv 6y agoIt seems unlikely to me that Citadel would be liable. They're just processing bulk transactions -- they have no direct contact with customers. You could just as well blame the NYSE.
- ethbr0 6y agoThey were just processing bulk transactions. If it's true they refused to process for certain securities for their downstream clients, then I believe "When?" and "Why?", specifically in relation to other actions, become legally relevant questions.
- tsdlts 6y agoThey didn't tell you how much of the position they closed out on. They can say "they closed their position" even if they only closed out on 1% of it.
- tartoran 6y agoHow likely is it for them to close their position when the price hit so high? That would be a huge loss. Why not wait a bit, make a few desperate phone calls and leverage their power before that?
- whimsicalism 6y agoBecause of the expiration date of the short they sold and uncertainty over whether the price would continue to increase. If you have to buy by EOD Friday and the price starts skyrocketing Thursday, you might want to buy a little earlier even if it means eating a huge loss, because you don't know if that skyrocket will continue into the next day. e: Why is that downvoted?
- desertrider12 6y agoShorts aren't options, they don't have expiration dates. You can hold a short indefinitely just by paying interest on the borrowed share value when you entered the position. You can even keep the short from being forcibly closed during a squeeze by providing more collateral. Put options do expire, but the worst case for puts is that they expire worthless. Regular shorts can have unbounded losses. https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/05/shortmarginrequirements.asp https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/05/shortmarginrequi...
- whimsicalism 6y agoSorry I misspoke. Melvin Capital's short position was in the form of puts, I think. Since they would expire worthless, better to sell them when it is skyrocketing than to wait and see it skyrocket further and lose all of your money.
- harambae 6y ago>Melvin Capital's short position was in the form of puts, I think. This is incorrect.
- tartoran 6y ago> As far as I know, Citadel and Melvin Capital no longer are holding any short positions in Gamestop. So what do they have to gain, by your narrative, from suppressing the price? If this is accurate then your question makes sense. Why? But how do we know this is real though? They could play games as well and I'm sure they do. Stock trading is gambling.
- whimsicalism 6y agoCitadel securities does not "play games", they aren't YOLO-ing on a GME short. They are happy to model the market so they can hedge better than their competitors and make money off of the bid-ask spread. Melvin Capital has already stated they have closed out their position, think it would probably be fraud if they hadn't.
- cryptonym 6y agoYou may work on some fancy model but at the end of the day you are taking a risk and there is a possibility to lose in the worst possible way. Call it games, YOLO or hedge better than competitors. Maybe, the problem was just transferred to someone else so they can remove it from their statements. And now that someone is trying to deal with this. Unless we have trustable source with all the details on how that position has been closed, I don't think it's safe to assume anything.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> you are taking a risk and there is a possibility to lose in the worst possible way. Call it games, YOLO or hedge better than competitors. Sure, there is some risk in liquidity provisioning, but I think you are really not understanding what market makers do and conflating it with hedge funds.
- TuringNYC 6y ago>> Melvin Capital has already stated they have closed out their position, think it would probably be fraud if they hadn't. IANAL but I doubt this would be fraud -- they arent a public corporation making statements about themselves. They did have LPs, but i'm not sure what restrictions there are around speaking -- would anyone know?
- qwerty12345678 6y agoBS they closed their shorts....they shifted them to shell companies or to complicit 3rd parties so they could claim they unloaded the shorts publicly.
- djeiasbsbo 6y agoIf Melvin Capital got out, then why was the stock still 140% shorted after that announcement? I thought that 11% of the shorted stock was from Melvin Capital, it doesn't make sense that there was no significant change in that figure. I am not trying to conspire, genuinely curious.
- __al__ 6y agowith the stock price through the roof other funds (and retail investors) see it as a good opportunity to short.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> If Melvin Capital got out, then why was the stock still 140% shorted after that announcement? I thought that 11% of the shorted stock was from Melvin Capital, it doesn't make sense that there was no significant change in that figure. Source? Also potentially new shorters getting in? I shorted AMC yesterday and have made quite a bit today.
- beachwood23 6y agoYesterday, there was a 140% short position on Gamestop. Today, there is still a 122% short position on Gamestop. There are still many funds hedged against GME. Melvin might have had one of the larger positions, but there are many more funds with this position. Source: https://finviz.com/quote.ashx?t=GME https://finviz.com/quote.ashx?t=GME As you say, they would make money by running the orders, regardless if GME goes up or down. So - why would they stop? It is most likely that Citadel is still exposed to other funds holding short positions in GME.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> So - why would they stop? There is literally no evidence that Citadel has stopped serving GME orders. That is entirely the conjecture of this thread and ignores the much more likelier option that it was Robinhood that limited the stocks. Why wouldn't you short GME after the price has risen so high? I'm sure there are plenty of hedge funds shorting now at a much higher price. Hell, I shorted AMC yesterday and have made quite a bit off of that already.
- matthewrobertso 6y ago>Why wouldn't you short GME after the price has risen so high? Because the stock is already over 100% short and an army of retail investors is purchasing it
- whimsicalism 6y agoSo? If you had shorted GME yesterday, you would make a bunch now that the price has collapsed.
- matthewrobertso 6y agoWhat if the price goes up further? It's already rebounded 50% from the short ladder/blatant robinhood manipulation. Why put yourself on the hook for something during a black swan event?
- alasdair_ 6y ago>Melvin Capital closed out their short position yesterday with a large loss This is something many people are claiming is false. As far as I can find, Melvin have not issues any formal statement on the matter - this claim is purely based on a CNBC "source".