3 ms·
People manage permissions just fine in the real world... if you have money in your pocket, you can pick and choose what portion of it to hand to the cashier whe
by mikewarot 6y ago
People manage permissions just fine in the real world... if you have money in your pocket, you can pick and choose what portion of it to hand to the cashier when you're purchasing something.
When you had someone $3.50... you're giving them $3.50 of capability, and no matter how clever the Loch Ness Monster is, they'll never get more than that $3.50.
If on the other hand, you have to give them the entire wallet... like you do in Windows, Linux, etc... the game is over.
Capability Based Security is NOT the same as "Global Permission to do X"
PayPal exists because it is an instantiation of capabilities for finance on the internet.
- contingencies 6y agoyou can pick and choose what portion... That was the old way. The new way is you give them your credit card or WeChat 'bill me' code. You get billed whatever the merchant wants to bill. Any post-facto complaint will be at the cost of your own time. Your further analogy is factually inaccurate. Under Windows, AFAIK most programs have a partially restricted permission set, hence Run as administrator. In Linux, under modern distributions, most programs run in both a user and a cgroup context, and some under further restrictions such as chroot and caps.
- ryukafalz 6y ago>The new way is you give them your credit card or WeChat 'bill me' code. You get billed whatever the merchant wants to bill. Any post-facto complaint will be at the cost of your own time. Sure, that may be the "new" way, but that doesn't mean it's better! Much of the payment fraud online couldn't exist if customers were in control of how much money to send and when rather than the merchant. >Under Windows, AFAIK most programs have a partially restricted permission set, hence Run as administrator. In Linux, under modern distributions, most programs run in both a user and a cgroup context, and some under further restrictions such as chroot and caps. Under normal circumstances, they're restricted only to the extent that your user is restricted. That's far from the level of granularity that GP is talking about.