7 ms·
An Elegant Revolution Followed by Slaughter
- deelowe 6y ago> Did you see that the Reddit message board is no longer accessible... It’s eerily familiar, like we’re relying on Reddit to be a corrective force the way we relied on Twitter or Facebook to shut down Trump. This is completely fabricated. I have no confidence in the article at this point. The sub was back up within an hour or so and the stated reason for taking the sub private (it was never "offline") from the mods was that there was a lot of spam/bot traffic they needed to deal with.
- swiley 6y agoYeah, I use that sub occasionally to inform trading and didn't even notice it went down.
- tester756 6y agoI did notice
- epistasis 6y agoSo much media is already spinning this to slot it into their preferred narratives. This type of topic, stock market strategies that not many people understand, is easy enough of a narrative to manipulate. Manipulating more easily understood facts, like a subreddit going private to stop bots, seems lazy!
- BoorishBears 6y agoWhat's ironic is in previous times WSB would have gone private long ago... Pre "WSBGod" the sub hated sudden influxes of new users who'd ask dumb questions and make lazy attempts at humor. GME is the perfect example of a time when the sub would normally go straight to private with flaired users only allowed to enter Now post that the community has gotten even noiser and less coherent so I think they've given up and just decided to roll with it.
- scruple 6y agoYes, exactly. I moved on from r/WSB around 2017. The problem today is that the GME/WSB effect is bleeding outside of the containment board. It's infested every online space that I frequent and as of this week has also moved into meat space.
- NDizzle 6y agoI'm glad the media is consistently showing their true colors. More and more people will begin to realize that Trump was exactly right about the media.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- GizmoSwan 6y agoThat board has gone private multiple times and many times it has been before or after big events. One of the mods resigned few weeks ago stating that the board was being overrun to pump certain stocks and that he was powerless to prevent it for various reasons. This was coming and expected because a good pump and dump needs pawns. It this case many of the pawns are not dumb anymore.
- pjc50 6y ago> Income inequality self corrects through one of three mechanisms: war, revolution, or famine. Wealth of people under the age of 40 as a percentage of total wealth has gone from 19 percent to 9 percent in the last 30 years and this is effectively a form of revolution. People are fed up with the financial industrial complex, which favors the already-rich and people over the age of 40. There's a lot to be said for this. It may be the one thing the QAnons and the AOC wing of the Democrats actually agree on, although the Q lot pick the wrong targets. Conversely, it's the one thing that "centrists" (if there are any true centrists left) refuse to acknowledge or plan for. It's not going to be solved by a shaman storming the capitol. It's not going to be solved by memeing stocks, that's obviously going to get slapped down. But the people aggrieved are going to keep .. testing the fences, like the raptors in Jurassic Park.
- thepasswordis 6y agoThere is a version of centrists that see the people on both sides of them as corrupt and hate them equally.
- happytoexplain 6y ago>the QAnons and the AOC wing of the Democrats I haven't seen this definition of a subset of Democrats before. Are you using support for AOC to imply "farther out than most Democrats"? I thought the vast majority, if not all, Democrats liked her, but I rarely read social media.
- valuearb 6y agoGME is doomed... ... when options expire Friday.
- sybercecurity 6y ago"I don’t think this is like the French Revolution." Did the French Revolution feel like a revolution when the Bastille was stormed? I'm NOT equating the the two, but theorizing that revolutions aren't always fully planned at first. This (and similar mob actions over the last few years) feel more like peasant uprisings: local and lack cohesiveness to do more than a single action.
- michaelbrave 6y agoThat's a fair point, that most is local and lacking cohesiveness. This was part of why occupy wall-street failed so spectacularly, because there was no proper leadership to represent their demands, in fact there wasn't really clear demands either. I don't think those people stopped being discontented though, they just quit showing up to voice it.
- mam2 6y agoThere is too many people trying to build narratives above the randomness of 1M people buying and selling as the wind blows in some random directions. Overall somme will have make money, other will have lost some.. it's a zero sum game except for brokers and HFT firms.
- anewaccount2021 6y agoHow? The war is basically over. Hedge funds covered at a huge loss. Many WSB members have already booked huge gains.
- imustbeevil 6y agoHasn't been remotely enough volume for this to be true. Really weird that people are trying to manipulate the narrative like this.
- derivagral 6y agoVolume as measured... on an exchange? Funds that are short likely covered this in off-exchange transactions like dark pools or similar services; I don't believe that'll show up in most common liquidity figures on retail exchanges.
- _jjkk 6y agoThe narrative-pushing has been very strange. I have Reddit-addicted friends who told me the ONLY people who would lose money after all this would be the evil hedge funds, and every retail investor was bound to make a killing if they just HODL I tried to explain that all those people have to actually SELL, hopefully near the top, to a willing buyer... Most people are not putting much thought into this beyond the fact that it aligns with their exiting emotions toward The Man and sticking it to him somehow.
- imustbeevil 6y agoYeah, it's very odd because of how transparent the process is. Step 1: Buy the stock with 140% short interest. -> Price goes up. Step 2: Shorts cover (This is the "Sell" phase for retail investors). -> Price goes up. Step 3: Shorts are finished covering (This is the "you missed it" phase for retail investors). -> Price tanks back to $15. I personally think we're either at the end of step 1 or the beginning of step 2, because we haven't seen the volume necessary for step 3 to be possible, unless you believe without evidence that all of the shorts covered outside of the exchanges. Which would be a claim I'm not comfortable making without evidence.
- GizmoSwan 6y agoThere is no revolution in my opinion. It is the time tested pump and dump OR dump and pump and the street is behind it all in my opinion. Sometime in Sept 2020 GME had purchased sum of shares reducing float or outstanding shares. Such purchases would create the current imbalance and the war between various parties involved. I can not believe that the whole scheme has not been by design. I recall seeing GME pump starting right about then in Sept. I am also convinced that the shorting hedge funds could have been playing it on the up side via options. They could have sold puts; bought calls. There are a lot of dark pools and each party can have multiple arms. It is pretty naive to believe that all these hedge funds dabbling in these type of games are the sheep and not the wolves and have been silent through it all . Both the new shareholders who are now the insiders and the hedge funds are likely to be aware of the small float that would have kick started the short covering pyramiding scheme and reddit would have provided the pawns to spawn it really fast by pumping the forums. Don't be naive. They fundies have been hitting all the high volatility stocks with small floats + high short ratios.
- metalliqaz 6y agoThe biggest tragedy of this is the mistaken belief that a bunch of little guys is actually profiting off Wall Street. The big boys are mostly the ones playing this game, and the little guys are mostly just chasing the ball around.
- GizmoSwan 6y agoThe little guys are also playing the pyramiding scheme by buying the OTM calls and puts like the big boys and cooperate with their schemes. That is the only difference. The OTM options are now low hanging fruits that can be grabbed with pump and dump given sufficient/willing and educated audience.
- kristopolous 6y agoThe HFTs are making a killing from the volitility. Slippage like this is their dream. It's the best possible scenario for HFT
- DiabloD3 6y agoThis is no different than the hit Financial Times ran on this whole thing, and then had to retract it. Original text: https://i.redd.it/nvp1vde7g1e61.jpg https://i.redd.it/nvp1vde7g1e61.jpg New text: https://i.redd.it/o0hpei8ic2e61.jpg https://i.redd.it/o0hpei8ic2e61.jpg
- azangru 6y agoThe "some of them alt-right supporters" line is so jarring — it's effectively the media telling you what you should feel (resentment?) towards those redditors. Substitute this with "some of them Biden supporters", "some of them BLM supporters", "some of them Jews", "some of them vegans" or whatever, to see how insane it sounds.
- trianglem 6y agoIt doesn’t work the same because the alt-right is just vile. Given that, conflating wsb with the alt-right is ridiculous.
- david422 6y agoWell that's his point - the article is correlating two (uncorrelated) groups to trigger an emotional response in order to sway your opinion. By contrasting it with correlating two (uncorrelated) groups that didn't trigger an emotional response, it becomes much more obvious that the article is pushing a narrative and not just reporting facts.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- scruple 6y agoI missed that FT piece yesterday. So someone is trying to draw a line from GamerGate to GMErGate.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nimbius 6y ago>Reddit's Elegant GameStop Revolution Will Be Crushed the best most analysts predict is an SEC or federal bailout for some hedges, but theres no way either institution can cover them all... the fact that we keep seeing public investment firms lock out these trades and hourly hit pieces from talking heads seems to suggest hedges are all out of ideas. This is the financial equivalent of asymmetric guerilla warfare. These players don't care about losses because Their losses are the price of admission to watch your curated hedge fund burn. The truly scary part is this is not only working, but is a repeatable strategy that will work over and over. The next internet board to lead after wsb will be just as successful at bankrupting casino firms using their own casino tactics.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoThe casino owners will change the rules of the game.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoI don't think it's a repeatable strategy. Institutions that didn't knew that already just learned that it's wise to monitor places like /r/WSB and possibly to hire someone to run interference and prevent the next pileup (unless one is desired, that is).
- nimbius 6y agoThis type of interference had almost zero effect on wsb, so its hard to see it effective in the future on a platform that could most likely be decentralized.. Wsb moderators were quick to identify and remove rogue actors and go private to protect their objective. Fud was openly ridiculed and debunked on wsb.
- vsareto 6y agoBoiler rooms have been a thing before reddit. It's repeatable, just not likely in the near future.
- katbyte 6y agoProbably not, but neither is the manipulation and huge profits the hedge funds where making doing this sort of shorting as the moment it’s noticed you’ll get another GameStop. End of that era for hedge funds I imagien
- nix23 6y ago>But I also think young, bored men are the most dangerous people in the world and a lot of young men are at home and, quite frankly, not having sex Scott Galloway, you should read some history to understand that nearly every war was started by men in YOUR age plus a simple but extreme mindset like yours. Lets talk about bored old men like you, who "hopefully" sit at home but write bullshit like that. I hope you try not to start a painting career in Vienna.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fortran77 6y agoFrom TFA: > People are fed up with the financial industrial complex, which favors the already-rich and people over the age of 40. This I'm scratching my head over. Do people on wsb think that "people over 40" are conspiring against them just because they've been able to have longer positions than a 20 year old? Do they not realize that someday (if they're lucky), they too will be over 40?
- jfengel 6y agoAh, I've been waiting for this. "Boomers" get blamed, but we in Generation X are only marginally less guilty. Most of the biggest villains are indeed Boomers, simply because they've been at it longer and are the biggest players, but GenX behaves a lot like its parents do. Not entirely. I like to think we're a little better. But we did get away with comparatively cheap college, used it to get reasonable jobs, and put that in retirement funds where exponential growth is starting to happen. We're still sitting in those jobs, and will be for a while. I'm pretty sure that people blaming "Boomers" really meant Anybody Over 40 all along. So I've been kinda waiting for it to be my turn.
- fortran77 6y agoThe one thing I'm trying to understand is how someone with a billion dollars in a short position can be undone with just a million dollars or so of market trades. If that's so, then large short positions are insanely risky.
- tartrate 6y agoIsn't there around 50-100M _shares_ being traded per day now?