4 ms·
I just checked my TD Ameritrade account. I'm able to buy GME just fine (though I didn't hit the "confirm" button). I know RobinHood messed up here. But... they
by dragontamer 6y ago
I just checked my TD Ameritrade account. I'm able to buy GME just fine (though I didn't hit the "confirm" button).
I know RobinHood messed up here. But... they never had a good reputation to begin with. Its an open secret that RobinHood's entire setup is kind of crap.
- itake 6y agoI didn't see a failure on Schwab until I hit "confirm" yesterday. My understanding is TD Ameritrade is only blocking the purchase of stock on margin. If you have the cash, you're allowed to make the purchase.
- swiley 6y agoOh well that's reasonable. If I were a brokerage you bet your ass I wouldn't lend you money to buy GME.
- aynyc 6y agoWhy should broker allow margin trading at all? If it's about risk, then who's the decider/calculator of the risk? I think this is the reason why there is a distrust from the next generation.
- swiley 6y agoThis really wouldn't be the first time Robinhood changed their software to prevent it's users from doing exceptionally stupid things with margin.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> who's the decider/calculator of the risk? The lender. As in all loans. As is in every detail described in one’s margin contract.
- aynyc 6y agoI looked at my margin document, other than Federal Reserve requirements and account restriction, there is no provision stating they can block a specific eligible stock as long as I meet their margin requirement.
- kgwgk 6y agoTheir margin requirement may be linked to the name so increasing the margin requirement to 100% would be a way to block the use of margin.
- aynyc 6y agoThat would block all margin trades, no? Not a specific instrument. I understand why they did it, but it leaves a very bad taste in my mouth.
- kgwgk 6y agoThey can set margin requirement separately for each stock. For example, with InteractiveBrokers "long stock positions [of AMC, BB, EXPR, GME, and KOSS] will require 100% margin and short stock positions will require 300% margin until further notice". https://twitter.com/IBKR/status/1354792600004386818 https://twitter.com/IBKR/status/1354792600004386818
- aynyc 6y agoI get that part, but why would 100% margin on buys eliminate the buys? If I have $100K cash, I can still buy $50K of XXX and meet the margin requirement. They are blocking buys, but not sells.
- kgwgk 6y agoWho is blocking buys? The context of this subthread is this message https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25942677 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25942677 about brokers allowing the buying of GME but not on margin (and how they don't have to disallow the use of margin for every stock for that).
- 52-6F-62 6y agoAnd that's pretty normal for highly-volatile stocks, isn't it?
- swiley 6y agoI just bought NOK this morning on TD. I think it's just robinhood.