3 ms·
This discussion is tiring. That initial resolution was overblown as well. > However, the resolution makes a fundamental misunderstanding: encryption is an abso
by raverbashing 6y ago
This discussion is tiring. That initial resolution was overblown as well.
> However, the resolution makes a fundamental misunderstanding: encryption is an absolute. Data is either encrypted or it isn’t; users have privacy, or they don’t.
Well, but as always, it isn't. Or are they encrypting all customer data with the same key?
Are provisions in the US good enough? But then you have the NSA, etc.
Privacy is a right on the legal sense. Should anything be unaccesible to law? (in the legal and in the technological sense, but they're two separate issues). This is more of an ethical question than a legal/technological one.
But back to the initial statement: no phone or system is 100% secure.
A "backdoor" implies a secret (to both user and provider) extraction of the data. Now, a judicially authorized/vetted extraction of data of a specific customer/timeframe is a different thing (even better, make it forward/backward secret). Sure, it is alarming and certainly ethically debatable. But it is not "a backdoor"
- MauranKilom 6y ago> A "backdoor" implies a secret (to both user and provider) extraction of the data. Now, a judicially authorized/vetted extraction of data of a specific customer/timeframe is a different thing (even better, make it forward/backward secret). Sure, it is alarming and certainly ethically debatable. But it is not "a backdoor" And how do you implement one without the other?
- raverbashing 6y agoI don't see what you mean. The first one is much easier than the second one (and the second one does not need to be implemented like the first one). Remember, if you have access to the server or the end client you can do either one. That's why the legality supersedes the technology, because the technology is not perfect.