10 ms·
I strongly advise everyone against ever giving their smart tv the wifi password. I have about a thousand times more confidence, that if I use my smart TV as a
by walrus01 6y ago
I strongly advise everyone against ever giving their smart tv the wifi password.
I have about a thousand times more confidence, that if I use my smart TV as a dumb screen connected to an Xbox one or PlayStation 4, that over a multi-year period of time, Microsoft and Sony will successfully keep their operating systems automatically patched, updated, and secure. As compared to any tv manufacturer.
I have seen people resort to things like installing pihole on their home LAN so that their smart tv will stop showing ads covering 1/3 of the screen whenever they use the menus. At least the advertisements that one will see on the home screen of an Xbox or Playstation are relatively small, unobtrusive, and can be ignored without bother.
In the future I think we will have problems with the fact that hdmi can also carry 100Mbps ethernet. Imagine if you plug your smart tv into some other device, intending just to send video to it, that gives it a dhcp lease and default route out to the internet. All in the name of consumer friendly "just plug it in and it works!" type functionality.
- gregmac 6y agoOf course, leaving it unconfigured with the open access point has its own risks, given the password is hard-coded to 1111122222: https://twitter.com/silascutler/status/1354521609692995585 https://twitter.com/silascutler/status/1354521609692995585
- walrus01 6y agoI have a Samsung smart TV from mid-2017 and it does not appear to be broadcasting a visible SSID, nor a hidden one. Presumably that has changed in the past couple of years? if it remains in that terribly insecure state by default until you give it a connection to a network, unfortunately the only thing to do might be to give it the password to a $20 mikrotik wifi router (in a 20MHz 2.4GHz channel) as an AP, so as to not pollute the empty radio channel spectrum in your house, that has no connection to the outside world. What an ugly hack. Or give it the password to a secondary ssid set up on your main wifi, that goes to a dead end VLAN with no route to anywhere.
- krastanov 6y agoOr desolder the (chip) antena which is usually easy notice on the board.
- foepys 6y agoAren't Samsung's QLED TV remotes Bluetooth only? Cutting the antenna would then also disable the remote and a modern TV without a remote is pretty useless.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoIt's clear that the only solution is not to buy a TV.
- kawsper 6y agoCouldn't desoldering the antenna lead to it overheating and damaging components?
- krastanov 6y agoNot really. 10 minutes of practice with some scrap wires would give enough soldering skills to remove it safely. The sibling comment about the Bluetooth remote worries me more
- 29athrowaway 6y agoI treat those devices and untrusted by putting them in a separate subnet that cannot talk to the subnet where I have my other devices (computer, printer, smartphones, etc).
- anonymousab 6y agoThey could eventually use ethernet over HDMI or simply include a cellular modem of some sort. The profit is there. But a simpler solution that we are already seeing a bit is to simply require a network connection to function at all; for now, it's just a periodic check, but a persistent connection requirement is all but inevitable in the medium term.
- est31 6y agoDevices having cellular modems isn't something new. Many cars already ship with them, for various purposes. WiFi will likely remain in use with smart TVs for a while as video content is data intensive so not really well suited for cellular, but likely stuff like your dishwasher or your stove might include cellular modems in the near future. The data they transmit is limited and you make setup easier as you don't have to type in a WiFi password any more.
- ignoramous 6y agoBaseband not for video streaming, but just for telemetry. I mean, this is a thing: https://www.twilio.com/docs/iot/supersim/getting-started-super-sim-raspberry-pi-sixfab-cellular-iot-hat https://www.twilio.com/docs/iot/supersim/getting-started-sup...
- SifJar 6y agoDifference between a car & a dishwasher is that a car is typically outside (at least during use) which would help it to get a signal. Anecdotally inside my house, phones generally get no/weak cell service but WiFi is accessible anywhere in the house. Obviously they could include both, but if it were relying only on cellular, my washing machine quite possibly couldn't get a connection
- cosmie 6y agoCarriers run IoT-specific networks[1], which are optimized for use cases such as telematics (low power consumption, low bandwidth usage, but high penetration and coverage). So it's entirely likely that your washing machine would be able to happily send along telematic data via the same carrier your cell phone can't even establish a connection to. [1] https://www.business.att.com/products/lpwa.html https://www.business.att.com/products/lpwa.html
- Jonnax 6y agoMy perspective is that I don't really care. If my smart TV gets hacked, what are they going to do? Take my Netflix and YouTube credentials? I've got an LG TV, there aren't huge adverts. It's faster than switching on my PS5 to watch something. It even has DLNA so I can listen to my music collection off my NAS. If it starts hacking my network, what's it going to do? Public key SSH is pretty strong. And anything sensitive that could be snooped on would be HTTPS. So this smart TV hack is going to require a second exploit to get into my windows PC? or Linux boxes?
- netc 6y agojust wait for smart TVs which are Zoom friendly and come with a camera and microphone built-in.
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> If my smart TV gets hacked, what are they going to do? Take my Netflix and YouTube credentials? Leverage access to pwn everything else on your network?
- jychang 6y agoPut the TV on its own NAT
- frongpik 6y agoIirc, 5G is going to solve this problem: TVs will directly connect to a 5G network, without bothering the user with WiFi matters.
- grishka 6y agoBut who's gonna pay for the data? And what if you disconnect the antenna?
- frongpik 6y agoTVs will sign a deal with telcos that the latter give access to 5G to certain GUIDs hardcoded in TVs.
- grishka 6y agoYeah but it's a potentially perpetual ongoing per-unit cost that the manufacturers will incur for something they sell for a one-time payment. At some point it has to become unprofitable. There are connected cars but iirc you have to buy a subscription or supply your own sim card to use the online features.
- labawi 6y agoThe connection is there so that they can have a long-lasting income from ads/snooping etc. They can share a bit of the spoils to get the meat. If specific units are costing them beyond income, they can probably have telcos disconnect them, or just remote-disable the communication.
- hnburnsy 6y agoAmazon Sidewalk will solve this problem.
- joubert 6y ago> I have about a thousand times more confidence, that if I use my smart TV as a dumb screen connected to an Xbox one or PlayStation 4, that over a multi-year period of time, Microsoft and Sony will successfully keep their operating systems automatically patched, updated, and secure. As compared to any tv manufacturer. How do you feel about a Sony smart TV?
- iagovar 6y agoI have a dumb Toshiba TV, it's snappy, just plug in HDMI and it works. No loading times, no bloat, no ads, no Automated Content Recognition), not using my network when I don't want to... I invite everyone to buy dumb stuff, because if we don't, there won't be any market signal, and there all be smart TV, Fridges and so on. I don't have to explain to HN audience why this poses risks, problems, and the probability of intrusive ad ecosystem causing problems with stuff that should just work. It's important that tech communities like this one push for it.
- hnburnsy 6y agoI fear that when Amazon Sidewalk opens up to third parties, there will be no stopping devices, in fact I would imagine that Amazon could share the wifi passwords it collects with all Sidewalk devices.