4 ms·
I love that quote about "temporarily embarrassed millionaires" because it's so true. Sometimes I see people who refuse to use coupons in stores because they th
by ck2 15y ago
I love that quote about "temporarily embarrassed millionaires" because it's so true.
Sometimes I see people who refuse to use coupons in stores because they think it's beneath them (even if the coupon is right in front of them in a display for what they are buying).
- sliverstorm 15y agoThe people I've known who were eligible to but refused to use food stamps did not feel it was "beneath them"- I'm pretty sure they felt that they didn't truly need them, and that there was someone worse off who needed them more than they did.
- Jach 15y agoOn the other hand, I had a roommate who spent his time criticizing "government handouts" while at the same time using food stamps himself.
- hoprocker 15y agoSounds similar to the 65+ year-olds out in the rural US where I grew up that complain about big government while defending their Medicare payments, sometimes in adjacent sentences.
- crocowhile 15y agoare the food stamps really limited in number??
- sliverstorm 15y agoI do not believe the stamps themselves are, but government resources are certainly finite.
- ck2 15y agoYup, there is a limited budget and if things get bad enough in a state they will even limit them to only people who have disabilities. It's rare but has happened. Then there is the craziness that you are immediately ineligible for foodstamps the very day you get a job, regardless if you do not get a paycheck for a couple more weeks.
- crasshopper 15y agoYou get so much per month - based on your income and fixed expenses. In my state, income must be below $1500/mo period, and then there is a secret formula that says f(income, expenses) = food stamp amount. Every six months they ask if your situation has changed.
- SwellJoe 15y agoThe money has to come from somewhere. Food stamps purchase real goods, and the government pays the stores for them. So, like the money they are a mostly direct proxy for, they are limited in number.
- ck2 15y agoActually, the amount of paperwork and hassle to apply for foodstamps is crazy. It can be embarrassing because you have to provide so many details about your life and give them legal permission to dig into all kinds of records. I realize the need to prevent fraud but there has to be some kind of balance to allowing someone in a bad situation to keep a little dignity. Then there is the craziness that you can buy things like candy with foodstamps but not vitamins.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoI realize the need to prevent fraud but there has to be some kind of balance to allowing someone in a bad situation to keep a little dignity. On the contrary, that would be counterproductive. At low levels of income, there is virtually no relationship between earnings and consumption. So if a person's utility function is proportional to consumption, with a slight disutility for working, they will choose not to work. This happens in the US up to the $30k/year level - i.e., a person earning $0k/year and a person earning $30k/year will consume roughly the same amount of goods and services. http://crazybear.posterous.com/why-the-poor-dont-work http://crazybear.posterous.com/why-the-poor-dont-work However, if you make receiving food stamps/welfare/etc unpleasant (i.e., more unpleasant than actually having a job), you would encourage some people to work for a living instead.
- ck2 15y agoWhat you are saying (and that link) sounds exactly like a person that has never been poor without a support network of family and friends. It's just a mental exercise with no basis in reality and no "hands-on" experience. The modern welfare system does not allow non-disabled people to draw an infinite amount of assistance - it's very restricted and for a finite amount of time. They must constantly show real proof they are looking for work and even with part-time jobs their assistance is immediately scaled back. Assistance shouldn't be a punishment, it should be care and kindness while someone gets back on their feet. You aren't going to make assistance less attractive than a minimum wage job, it's impossible.
- 15y ago