3 ms·
Interesting. Does it actually delegate the authentication to your phone, or does it send the password? My Android allows to share the password with a QR code,
by remram 6y ago
Interesting. Does it actually delegate the authentication to your phone, or does it send the password?
My Android allows to share the password with a QR code, which is certainly not as ergonomic... in fact it's slower than spelling it out, even to 1 friend.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoIt sends the password, not really reasonable for it to only be able to authenticate one Wi-Fi device if another Wi-Fi device is still present. Wi-Fi passwords aren't really that secure a thing these days, anyways. If you need your Wi-Fi to be secure, you need to be doing RADIUS authentication or similar. It's just from a UI standpoint that it's very seamless. You don't have to see the password, you don't have to enter it anywhere, one device just shares the Wi-Fi password with another device nearby.
- SEJeff 6y agoWith an access point that supports really good beam forming.
- arghwhat 6y agoWPA PSK unfortunately couples encryption and authentication, so users require the key at all times. Your key is too simple if it's easier to spell out. :)
- dingaling 6y ago> My Android allows to share the password with a QR code Seems eminently sensible, no dependency on WiFi or Bluetooth stacks and works cross-platform. A QR also lets you force the recipient onto a guest SSID instead of your LAN
- zaroth 6y agoI wonder if there’s a standardized URL to encode SSID and Password or if they just had to make one up. Presumably Apple doesn’t support this QR method? QR of course requires a screen and a camera, whereas Bluetooth can work on, for example, an Apple TV type device, or a smart speaker. EDIT: So then the trick is being able to generate the QR code easily and securely (without having to send your WiFi password to the cloud). Presumably free apps exist to do this.
- jeromegv 6y agoIt sends the password, if you have your Apple Keychain synced in iCloud, you can then go on your Mac and access the password in the list of saved wifi password.
- jorvi 6y agoYou can't, because it's hashed. Check it right now, all the shared passwords are just hashes.
- Nextgrid 6y agoSorry but this is incorrect - they can't be hashed because the password needs to be used as-is for the wireless authentication procedure, at least for PSK-based auth (EAP can indeed use certificates and the private key is never revealed). The key is probably stored in some hex format (I think wpa_supplicant in Linux also supports this format) but it's not hashing per-se as it's reversible.
- nathancahill 6y agoIt's encrypted. Not sure what with which key, but it's not plaintext, which is what they were responding too: > you can then go on your Mac and access the password in the list of saved wifi password Not true.
- Nextgrid 6y agoIn my case, searching for my network name in Keychain Access brings up 2 items, one in my System keychain and one in the iCloud one. Both of them end up displaying the raw password on the detail view now, though I do indeed remember that a year ago I saw some wireless passwords being in hex instead. I'm not denying they might be reversibly-encrypted (although this doesn't happen to me anymore for some reason), but in any case for a WPA(2)-PSK network the key cannot be hashed using a one-way irreversible hash because it is needed as-is to actually complete the authentication. What you're seeing is encryption and not hashing.