5 ms·
I stopped talking about "socialism" online the day I understood the US and European definitions are completely different Most people in Europe associate social
by lm28469 6y ago
I stopped talking about "socialism" online the day I understood the US and European definitions are completely different
Most people in Europe associate socialism with things like healthcare, paid vacations, &c.
Americans associate socialism with china, cuba, no freedom, gulags and famines...
Just the fact that Biden is called a "socialist" or part of the "radical left" (or even close to the left) by a non negligible portion of Americans tells you all you have to know. America/Biden's socialism is the equivalent of progressive conservatism in Europe
- flohofwoe 6y agoI'd say that most people in Europe (especially in Eastern Europe) associate "socialism" with the failed Eastern Bloc socialist countries. "Social democracy" or "social market economy" would be more correct terms. All current European countries have capitalist economies, they're just more regulated in favour of the people than in other parts of the world. There's a lot of wiggle room between a state-controlled planned economy (traditionally called "socialism") and 18th century style capitalism.
- lebuffon 6y agoEven "Communist" China now has a capitalist economy. :) But they don't have a Democratic government. What should we call that? Totalitarian Capitalism? "wiggle room" Exactly right. I liken it to a control that you can turn to the left or the right. There are an infinite number of degrees in between. My life experience seems to indicate that the control must be continuously tweaked, like a servo control, to keep a country working. Lock it one place and the system runs out of control. Side bar hypothesis: Perhaps democracy works merely by chance in that it jerks the control back and forth never allowing a stationary position. (?)
- flohofwoe 6y agoIn Germany I've seen the term "Staatskapitalismus" used for the Chinese system (== state capitalism).
- ModernMech 6y ago> What should we call that? Totalitarian Capitalism? It's typically referred to as "state capitalism" https://asiatimes.com/2020/08/socialist-or-capitalist-what-is-chinas-model-exactly/ https://asiatimes.com/2020/08/socialist-or-capitalist-what-i...
- kebman 6y agoThe Socialists and Leftists of the Nordics call it a Social Democracy. The Conservatives and Right Wing of these countries call it a Capitalist Welfare State. Most people over here agree that none of these countries are under Socialist Rule however. Instead they are democracies that are run mostly under capitalism, but with more state-run regulation and taxation than that of the USA. However, as the keen-eyed will see, what you guys pay extra in medical insurance, is kind of like a tax too, so when you add that in, Americans sometimes end up paying more in "tax" than many Europeans.
- koonsolo 6y agoIn Belgium, state-controlled planned economy is called "Communism". "Socialism" is all social security etc. So I actually agree with the parent comment. So in US, "Communism"=="Socialism", in Western EU !=.
- flohofwoe 6y agoSo by that definition I live in a "socialist country" (Germany) because it has a social safety net? And there I thought I had successfully escaped socialism in 1990 when the wall came down. Crap ;) (the GDR didn't call itself a "communist country", because the party realized that the poor condition of the economy doesn't quite fit the utopian ideals of "communism", so they invented the term "real socialism" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_socialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_socialism) as one of multiple steps towards a glorious communist future, which would be realized "really soon now, just work a bit harder and one day we'll be rewarded with communism" - or something like that at least, of course nobody believed this bullshit, not even the diehard communists themselves).
- koonsolo 6y ago> So by that definition I live in a "socialist country" Not really the country like that, but the parties Christian Social Union and Social Democratic Party, we would name it "socialistic". Anyone in that party would be a "socialist", but not a "communist". So if they would deliver the Chancellor, we would say the country is run by a socialist. I didn't know about "real socialism". So glad you're all part of EU now :).
- lm28469 6y ago> So by that definition I live in a "socialist country" Depending on the definition you want to use. If you want to use "socialism" as the opposite of "capitalism" then of course no, Germany isn't a "socialist country". The being said Germany is a fairly "social" country in my book, very similar to France. They very often put the emphasis on the group rather than the individual (taxes, education, public infrastructures, health care, work/life balance, &c.) But again we're mostly talking semantics and local usage of words here, the underlying principles are very easy to tell apart (I doubt anyone could tell with a straight face that Germany and the US are running on the same principles for example.) now some people use the word "socialism" to describe that or part of it In France 20th century socialists fought a lot for workers rights, abolishing the death penalty, depenalizing homosexuality, warranting liveable minimum wages, earlier retirement age, paid vacations, paid parental leaves, &c, many of the rights we take for granted nowadays are direct or indirect achievements of socialists, which is logical since Europe (mostly invented and) soaked in socialism for the last 150+ years. That being said, yes modern France or Germany "socialism" evolved from their early definition but I still believe they're indefinitely more socialist than the US. I feel like many people get trapped in the socialism = communism, communism = never worked, hence communism = bad, hence socialism = bad, as if it was a binary thing. I guess we could argue about the exact meaning of "socialism" in 2020 but I doubt we can argue that "socialism" deeply marked a lot of European countries
- adwn 6y ago> Most people in Europe associate socialism with things like healthcare, paid vacations, &c. What? No they don't, at least not in Germany. Here, "socialism" is primarily associated with the Soviet Union and the GDR (East Germany). "healthcare, paid vacations", in contrast, is not associated with any particular political system, because it's understood to be the baseline, or taken for granted. At best, it's associated with the "Sozialstaat". Note that the term "sozial" in German does not mean "socialism", but rather "caring for others"; it's an antonym to "anti-social", not to "capitalistic".
- DyslexicAtheist 6y ago> No they don't, at least not in Germany. my experience is very different. maybe an indicator that the info-bubble is stronger than we believe and it all depends on where and _what_ we are. The "Sozialdemokratische Partei Deutschlands" (SPD) literally has "socialist" in its name. Not once have I heard anyone claiming that they're linked to communism or Soviet Russia.
- flohofwoe 6y agoI wouldn't associate "social" and "social democracy" with "socialism" though (maybe that's because I've grown up in a socalist country - the GDR), and I wouldn't call SPD members "socialists", they're called "social-democrats". There seems to be an internal controversy between the SPD's left and right wing about the term "democratic socialism" though, which once was a stated future goal of the party.
- alentist 6y ago> The "Sozialdemokratische Partei Deutschlands" (SPD) literally has "socialist" in its name. It literally does not.
- detaro 6y ago"Sozialdemokratisch" isn't the same as "sozialistisch"="socialist" in German usage.
- lm28469 6y ago
- me_me_me 6y agoIts a catch all term abuse. We have terms for all those things US call socialism. Communism, stalinims, totalitarianism. Socialism suppose encapsulate ideas where you invest into people (social) so·cial relating to society or its organization. Investing into ideas that protect and support the very fabric of society, families, healthcare, education, consumer protection - anything that makes it easier for people to prosper and not be abused. It makes people healthy, educated and protected and they will prosper thus creating more wealth. There was an article here recently that growing up in stable home make you far more successful (avg 75k per year earnings). Its common sense. There will be no next apple created in tent cities of LA.
- marcusverus 6y ago> Just the fact that Biden is called a "socialist" or part of the "radical left" (or even close to the left) by a non negligible portion of Americans tells you all you have to know. America/Biden's socialism is the equivalent of progressive conservatism in Europe. Observations about the left/right alignment of American politicians are, naturally, made in the context of American politics. It makes little sense to compare Joe Biden's politics to European candidates. He is compared to Bill Clinton, George Bush, Barack Obama, and Donald Trump. Compared to them (even compared to Clinton and Obama), he is significantly farther left. Imagine how well the converse of the argument would track for a European. "You know that candidate on the Right who wants to abolish your state-run healthcare system? You can tell that's not a radical position--just look at how many Americans prefer a private system!"
- alentist 6y ago> Most people in Europe associate socialism with things like healthcare, paid vacations, &c. Absolutely false. Are you American yourself? As the Danish PM put it, "I know that some people in the US associate the Nordic model with some sort of socialism. Therefore, I would like to make one thing clear. Denmark is far from a socialist planned economy. Denmark is a market economy."