3 ms·
You have to wonder whether a guy who says this sort of shit has ever read or watched any dystopian fiction. 1984, Brave New World, THX-1138, Fahrenheit 451, Br
by knowtheory 15y ago
You have to wonder whether a guy who says this sort of shit has ever read or watched any dystopian fiction.
1984, Brave New World, THX-1138, Fahrenheit 451, Brazil, all of these are premised on societies where the majority of people are getting by, and are only passively inconvenienced. The problem is that the minority of people who object or deviate from society are crushed by the mechanism of the state (whatever that happens to be).
Privacy anxiety is an ephemeral screen on deeper fundamental issues about fairness and justice in society. Zuckerberg may be right that incorporating further privacy eroding features into society will be easy, but that doesn't make it right.
Regardless of what you think of Google, i at least give them credit that they recognize that the tech they build has scary implications, and that there are lines that they are not supposed to cross (at least, Eric Schmitt has said this a number of times). Zuckerberg does not seem to have any such compunction.
- joebadmo 15y agoRelates to an earlier discussion on the role of liberal arts, I think: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2580176 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2580176 And, now that I think about, as Z is a college drop-out, maybe the role of higher education in general. The ideas presented in all of the works you cite are ones someone focused on an engineering degree or a tech business to the exclusion of all else might have been exposed to in a broad education. And not just that, but the kind of training that teaches you to think more broadly, in terms other than the metrics that Z seems to restrict himself to.