3 ms·
So does this mean that a sock has ZERO holes, or HALF a hole? Because if you were to cut the sock to flatten it, your cut would only have to go from the top to
by hammock 6y ago
So does this mean that a sock has ZERO holes, or HALF a hole? Because if you were to cut the sock to flatten it, your cut would only have to go from the top to the bottom of the sock, but not back up again - it's not a "complete cut."
Note: If you are having trouble visualizing this cut with a sock, replace it with a paper cone.
- drdeca 6y agoA cone surface is topologically equivalent to a disk. You don't have to cut it at all in order to flatten it, if you allow as much stretching and bending as you want. So, 0 holes. If you want to consider a more restrictive collection of modifications, like, say you want to preserve angles or something inside the shape, then that would be a different question. Uh, I guess if you had a surface which was generally smooth but possibly has some boundaries and/or corner edge things, and/or corner point things (e.g. sticking two cones together), you could also ask about how many cuts combined with conformal maps [edit : I think conformal maps isn't the thing I'm looking for. Yeah, I think I'm looking for something related to developable surfaces maybe] would be needed to flatten such a thing out? (so this could maybe produce a similar question for which the one or half or whatever cut between the edge of the cone and the center, could be an answer?)
- hammock 6y agoThat makes sense, I didn't realize we were allowed to stretch and bend however we want. Seems weird to be allowed to take a 3D object and contort it into 2D.
- Koshkin 6y ago> cut the sock to flatten it From the topological standpoint, you do not need to cut the sock for this - it is already “the same as” (homeomorphic to) a piece of the plane surface.
- coffexx 6y agoImagine its made of putty instead of fiber. See if you can squish and stretch its surface in your mind into a sphere or flat shape without tearing it. You'll see the sock is homeomorphic with those shapes and there are 0 holes. Likewise see if you can imagine squishing and stretching a putty coffee mug or a straw into a torus. They both have 1 hole. Like this: https://i.ytimg.com/vi/9NlqYr6-TpA/maxresdefault.jpg https://i.ytimg.com/vi/9NlqYr6-TpA/maxresdefault.jpg
- hammock 6y agoWhoa that coffee mug image is great and blew my mind