4 ms·
Call me surprised on that one. The banks were pissed to say the least about the interchange fee cap since it was introduced in 2015 - estimates run on a yearly
by mschuster91 6y ago
Call me surprised on that one. The banks were pissed to say the least about the interchange fee cap since it was introduced in 2015 - estimates run on a yearly loss (aka more money in the hands of the consumers) of 1-2 billion € a year (per https://www.euractiv.com/section/economy-jobs/news/europeans-save-up-to-e2-billion-thanks-to-caps-on-bank-cards-fees/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/economy-jobs/news/europeans...). I would not be surprised if the other card networks follow MasterCard here, even if it's just British consumers affected it's still a lot of money that they're leaving on the table.
The "downside" (from an US point of view) on this cap is that European credit cards don't have ridiculous card bonus programs that are in reality subsidized by all people not paying by credit cards.
- yuribro 6y agoI thought that the card bonus programs on US credit cards were subsidized not by the transaction fees, but by the monthly interest payments. So actually payed by the non-responsible credit card users.
- mschuster91 6y agoNope, they're (also) paid by the individual sellers. It's utter madness. https://www.helcim.com/us/pricing/mastercard-interchange-rates/ https://www.helcim.com/us/pricing/mastercard-interchange-rat...
- felixfbecker 6y agoI wonder how Amex is able to make money in Europe? They still have a quite generous rewards program (not as generous as the US, but not bad) and I thought they always charged high tx fees (which is also why not all merchants chose to accept it). But the argument being that they also have the high earners = high spenders in their network, and merchants can attract more of those customers by accepting Amex. If the cap was at 0.3%, how can they be any different than MasterCard/Visa cards, which usually don't have reward programs here?
- maccard 6y ago> I thought they always charged high tx fees (which is also why not all merchants chose to accept it). I used to work in a PC retail/repair shop and the reason we didn't take amex wasn't because of the fees, it was because they held the balances for longer than Visa/MC, and occasionally we had bills to pay in that time period too!
- avianlyric 6y agoThe cap only applies to transactions that have three or more entities involved. For Mastercard/Visa you will have at lease three entities involved: 1. The retailer 2. The card network Mastercard/Visa 3. The card issuer (the customers bank) Amex dodge this by being both the card network and the issuer. So there are only two parties involved in their transactions. 1. The retailer 2. Amex So they charge a much higher interchange than Mastercard/Visa can. Which is also the reason why there will never be an Amex competitor in Europe. No merchant would ever sign up to anew card network that charged more and had no customers. Equally no customer would signup for card they couldn’t use anywhere.
- martinald 6y agoStripe etc don't charge more for Amex in Europe than Visa/MC though. Any ideas how they do that? I assumed they would pass on the higher prices.
- avianlyric 6y agoStripe’s pricing is quite a bit higher than many of their competitors. They roll up what is quite a complex pricing structure (there are pages and pages of network fees to consider) into a single number. For most people not having to deal with the details makes Stripe worth it. But once to get to a certain scale it becomes much cheaper to use a competitor, and just have people working full time on understanding and managing the fees involved.
- martinald 6y ago
- esperent 6y ago> The "downside" (from an US point of view) on this cap is that European credit cards don't have ridiculous card bonus programs I've never even had a credit card. I just have a debit card that allows me to spend the money in my account (plus a limited overdraft of about €1000). I've never seen the point of anything else and I'd be suspicious as hell if a bank offered me a credit card with a reward program.
- Hamuko 6y agoEven European credit cards usually have much better buyer protections than debit cards. Like if your flight gets cancelled or if the shop you bought from goes under between your order and delivery.
- amaccuish 6y agoI was surprised moving to Germany, the default Visa card you get is a 30 day rolling credit card, aka charge card. Visa Debit and Mastercard's equivalent don't seem to be popular. And even less popular is a full-on credit card. A much healthier attitude there I believe.
- martinald 6y agoIn the UK (and I think most other EU states), if you purchase on credit card you get a lot of additional protection if the product/service is not as described, the company goes out of business, etc for purchases over £100. It's actually pretty reckless using debit cards for larger purchases for this reason, especially given the current economic climate. You should (IMO) always pay with a credit card then pay the full balance off via direct debit every month.