4 ms·
You know what I'm missing? The almost realtime map from ucte.org which updated every 3 to 5 seconds on my Pentium3 933 with only 512MB Ram in the browser. I th
by LargoLasskhyfv 6y ago
You know what I'm missing? The almost realtime map from ucte.org which updated every 3 to 5 seconds on my Pentium3 933 with only 512MB Ram in the browser.
I think it needed some plugin, either Java or Flash, but you could zoom in or out, either to the whole of Europe, or down to the substations in the cities and towns.
It was like google maps or similar. AND it had all the transmission lines, power plants, and substations.
And color coded lines, with KW/MW/GW and arrows indicating the direction of energy flow on them.
Anybody could view it without having an account there. At least I did, from time to time.
This way of viewing it in realtime is now gone, or at least not accessible to the general public anymore.
Does anybody know some equivalent?
Sites with bargraphs and charts need not apply.
- Reason077 6y agoENTSO-E is the successor organisation to UCTE [1], with its functions transferred to ENTSO-E in 2009. So if anyone has the data, it would be them. Interesting that the ucte.org website still seems to be online and frozen in time! [1] https://www.entsoe.eu/news-events/former-associations/#union-for-the-coordination-of-the-transmission-of-electricity-ucte https://www.entsoe.eu/news-events/former-associations/#union...
- andreasley 6y agoWhile ENTSO-E does have a map [1], it's not as nice as the one described above. [1] https://www.entsoe.eu/data/map/ https://www.entsoe.eu/data/map/
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoYes, does not compare, unfortunately.
- noobermin 6y agoI hate to commit red-herring but this is another example of how computing is worse today in some ways.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoYeah, I noticed that some years ago. They don't have that offer anymore. Interestingly, looking at the article, the cutouts are in the exact style of that former realtime map. But static. Not living. That was once there, and available to the general public. Personally, I view that as artificial scarcity of information, regarding energy politics. 'Smokescreening' so to speak.
- EE84M3i 6y agoIs it possible it's no longer available for security reasons?
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoI don't know. I've thought about that. OTOH if some terrorist would like to know the choke points of the grid, he could deduce that from openstreetmaps also, where the transmission lines and substations are available for viewing.
- javajosh 6y agoYes, and honestly someone determined to do damage like that would be the sort to be patient and methodical enough to find targets with or without the map. But I do understand the instinct to want to at least increase the barrier to destruction, the problem is that it ALSO increases the barrier to understanding (and so protection and enhancement). So, an understandable but bad trade off, IMHO.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoI didn't see it from that point of view. It was just interesting to watch for me, out of the corner of my eyes, while doing other stuff on other systems and screens. I did that somewhere between 2005 and 2008, whenever I felt like it :-) With a focus on Germany in general, and my town especially. So I had it mostly zoomed just so that Germany was in view, with small parts of neighbouring countries visible. We didn't have that much solar and wind at the times. But sometimes one could see the direction of flow switch. From/to France for instance, or Denmark. And I think I've seen that to/from Poland and Czech also. Anyway, you could get a feeling for how things were depending on time of year/day, weather, and so on. Intuitevely, because presented spatially and realtime. And you don't get that spatial intuitiveness from the substitutes with (often delayed) charts & graphs. Which makes it impossible to counter bullshit by politicians or other parties with vested interests when they are saying this and that, and you could have said: Ahem, that is not entirely correct, because there and then it was like so, and not what you say! And the loss of that ability is making me angry! edit: Regarding the 'intuitiveness' of spatial vs. bars & charts. Even when the possibility to filter for im/export between countries exists, it does not show over which lines it went. Which could be useful in discussions about extending/upgrading lines, or building new ones. It's just not there.
- theandrewbailey 6y agoThat's a lost art nowadays, doing all that on a Pentium 3. Today, you'd need about 512 GB of RAM and a supercomputer to do the same. \s
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoHrrm. I did that under some Linux and KDE 3.x, maybe even with the KDE Browser called Konqeror. That was usable at the times :-) 2005 to 2008 that must have been.
- rkangel 6y agoIs it possible that not making that level of data available is purposeful from a security point of view? Western European countries (among others) worry about threats to their "Critical National Infrastructure", whether in person (terrorist with a bomb) or as a cyber attack. Providing a big map with all transmission lines, power plants and substations seems like it would be a big help to an unsophisticated terrorist, showing them what to blow up.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoI don't think so, because you can see that on openstreetmap. I mean the transmission lines and substations.
- Havoc 6y agoLike this: https://www.electricitymap.org/map https://www.electricitymap.org/map
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoWhile that is looking nice, (and I don't know how 'realtime' it is) it lacks the structure of the transmission nets, and the zoomability down to substation level in the towns/cities. I can't remember exactly anymore, it didn't show every transformer in town, but the places where the high voltage overland transmission lines entered into town, and were transformed down to more managable levels were there. I think down to 10.000/50.000 Volts. That was different regionally. For instance Portugal vs. Germany.
- layoutIfNeeded 6y agoSomeday someone will reimplement it in React, and you will only need an i9-9900k with 64Gb to run it somewhat smoothly.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoWhere would someone get the realtime data? Technically it has to exist, otherwise frequency regulation wouldn't work. The fact that they don't show it in the way I described, shows that they don't want to anymore, because they don't need to because of different organizational structure, or the structure has been made that way for ideologicel reasons by politics, i.e. 'smokescreening'.
- filmor 6y agoDirect frequency regulation (primary reserve or FCR) acts directly on the measured frequency at the power plant. But yes, for secondary reserve (aFRR), every grid has to know all its flows, but I don't know of any European grid operator that was transparent about this information. You can deduct some of the cross-border flows from observing the energy markets.
- pmayrgundter 6y agoDid it look like this? https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Energy-trade-change-in-the-UCTE-system-in-2008-source-wwwucteorg_fig3_224266016 https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Energy-trade-change-in-t... Seems like they're referring to it but also the comments suggest the data was from simulation of optimal market exchange, not actual electrical flows
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoNope. That is abstract. It looked exactly like the 2 blurred cutouts from the Entsoe article, where they put in the probable causes textmarker style. Interestingly it is hard to find screenshots of good quality or at all. Seems to have been a very special interest of mine?
- pmayrgundter 6y agoI used to work on fine-grained internet mapping like on opte.org, so I understand the bug :) If you ever do find something similar I'd love to know. I have a friend at Kevala, doing this privately in the US. But otherwise, yeah, seems to be a dark art.