3 ms·
> Really, really, really good. Are they though? This accident had 5 of it’s 6 safety switches arm during the accident. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1961_Go
by lostlogin 6y ago
> Really, really, really good.
Are they though? This accident had 5 of it’s 6 safety switches arm during the accident.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1961_Goldsboro_B-52_crash https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1961_Goldsboro_B-52_crash
- dmitriid 6y ago"A single switch out of four (not six) was unarmed". So, the failsafes worked as intended. And yes, they should be even more failsafe.
- lostlogin 6y agoHmm, the wiki says “ Former military analyst Daniel Ellsberg has claimed to have seen highly classified documents indicating that its safe/arm switch was the only one of the six arming devices on the bomb that prevented detonation.” The linked story says “ Robert McNamara, who’d been Secretary of Defense at the time of the incident, told reporters in 1983, "The bomb’s arming mechanism had six or seven steps to go through to detonate, and it went through all but one.”” Where is your quote from? I can’t find it in the Natgeo article.
- dmitriid 6y agoThat very same wiki. The very next sentence after Daniel Ellsberg quote: "In 2013, information released as a result of a Freedom of Information Act request confirmed that a single switch out of four (not six) prevented detonation."
- lostlogin 6y agoThanks - sorry I was looking in the National Geographic article.
- Teever 6y agoThat is a nuclear weapon that was Wikipedia says was in service from 1957-1966. Wiki also says that the first nuclear explosion occurred on July 16, 1945. This means that the development of the weapon in question occurred sometime in the first 12 years after the first nuclear weapons were tested. I think that it is safe to assume that this very old weapon design has only been approved on since the 1950s.
- sgt101 6y agoI wish I could agree. Here is why I am not sure. The nuclear weapons program is seen (in all good faith) by all those running it as vital to national security and national survival. Anyone who expresses the slightest skepticism or concern about any aspect of it is seen as undermining this vital national goal. It should be noted that the skeptics / concerned are on very difficult ground professionally, because there are so many layers of secrecy and the barriers to disclosure are so strong that asking questions is actually nasty and rude. The people who are being questioned cannot disclose their true position or hint at why an arguement or line of questioning is silly and so they have to sit there (decent and honourable as they may be) sharply aware that they look shifty and silly. This is bloody unfair and unpleasant, it's never going to build bridges or relationships. It is an "unprofessional" line to follow. So, these people (the skeptics) are then excluded from the program and anything that connects to it. The exclusion happens professionally (that guy is not honest or straightforward - don't trust his judgement), commercially/employment/youarefired & socially (you are a heretic, abhorrent, communist, idiot, greenie). And that is ok - as far as it goes - I understand, I get it, there are many other roles and interests in life to pursue. But what it has created is the most profound bubble around the development, control and management of nuclear weapons within which everyone involves genuinely believes that they are safe, effective and necessary. There is no doubt. And without doubt there is complacency and ignorance. I hope to god that this doesn't lead to a major accident, but right now I am pretty sure that it will.