3 ms·
Don't call a bunch of selfie taking hooligans insurretionists. That's not how insurrections happen. It's a media blown overreaction because it helps their nar
by mc32 6y ago
Don't call a bunch of selfie taking hooligans insurretionists. That's not how insurrections happen. It's a media blown overreaction because it helps their narrative. Look at how insurrections happen elsewhere. It's not done by selfie taking shamen.
I mean WTF do they think? Only "their" revolutionaries can use the app, but others can't?
It's like TOR. It can be used by dissidents but it can also be used by enemies of the state, yet the state believes on balance TOR does good.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Don't call a bunch of selfie taking hooligans insurretionists Just because it's a stupid insurrection doesn't mean it's not an insurrection.
- mc32 6y agoOk, so then so was Malheur and the siege of the Seattle police station.
- girvo 6y agoYou don’t see a difference between a local police station and your literal federal Capitol building filled with Senators?
- ekianjo 6y agoInsurrection is a very vague word, any kind of violent protest against authorities can be called an insurrection. Funny the summer insurrections don't get to have that label.
- Klonoar 6y agoMmmm, yes, let's compare: - A group storming the capitol of the US after being fed a steady stream of lies regarding an election result, with the President himself pushing them to go. versus - A group protesting after yet-another-person-of-color was murdered, pushing for equality and a check on police brutality. Totally checks out. ;P
- roenxi 6y agoYou're comparing the extremest fringe of one protest to the nonviolent core of the other. We have to compare fringe to fringe here. The extremest fringe of the summer protests was burning cop cars and and a courthouse in one instance. There was even an area that declared itself an Autonomous Zone. That is insurrection. Not going to achieve anything though so everyone ignored it at the time. It wasn't any more of a problem than the Capitol riots.
- Klonoar 6y ago>You're comparing the extremest fringe of one protest to the nonviolent core of the other. I am not; I'm comparing the movements that led to each situation. You want to compare extremists, but the extremists are not the point - they'll always be there. The intent of the movements that caused these actions to happen are what matters, and it's fairly clear which side each falls on. Many of those instances of violence in the summer protests were reactionary and driven by police exercising unnecessary force, which has been documented in troves of video. Those who participated in the DC incident on the 6th were driven by a stream of misinformation, which has _also_ been well documented at this point. One wanted to believe in conspiracy theories and support a failure of a President, going so far as to listen to him to attempt to overthrow the government. The other one just wants equality. >There was even an area that declared itself an Autonomous Zone. Yes, I live down the street from it. Having experienced it and lived around it, I would not classify it as anything remotely close to what was seen on January 6th in DC.
- roenxi 6y agoThe movement that led to the Capitol riot was a misguided but fundamentally patriotic belief that there needs to be more of a focus on ensuring free and fair elections. You can disagree that a protest was needed and you can impugn the motivations of the organisers, but that is what the bulk of the protesters thought they were protesting. A government installed by the people is a principle that compares on similar footing to equality.
- 6y ago
- Spivak 6y agoThe Black Lives Matter protests only get to be called insurrections if their goal was to supplant those authorities or forcefully override their will. Marching to put pressure on authorities to enact reforms is basically the opposite of an insurrection. Without the authorities the protests are pointless. And look I can only speak for my city since I was there but calling the protests violent is technically true but misleading in the way “there was a fight” is misleading in zero tolerance school policies. Being at the front of the protest was terrifying because the police were itching for any excuse to escalate and purposely obstructing people, grabbing and pushing the crowd daring someone to push back. Tensions are already high and the police acting like schoolyard bullies doesn’t help, and finally some guy finally breaks with a “get your hands off me” they get pulled down to the ground and start getting beaten, people step in to defend the guy and pull the cops off him, more cops rush in and boom — “violence.” The shit at the Capitol was absolutely moronic and they had basically zero chance of achieving their goal but the intent was there and that’s really what matters.
- travisoneill1 6y ago> The Black Lives Matter protests only get to be called insurrections if their goal was to supplant those authorities or forcefully override their will. So, you mean like hypothetically taking over 6 blocks of downtown Seattle and declaring it an autonomous zone?
- Spivak 6y agoLook I wasn't there and the information about it is extremely two sided. People who liked/supported it said that it was basically a large-scale sit-in like OccupyWallSt which seems to match the photos of it and I think lives firmly on the side of protest. Otherwise more usual protests like street marches, blocking access to government buildings, or occupying streets with cars also become insurrection which doesn't make much sense. Not even trying to play, if the Capitol shit was actually a sit-in a la #OccupyTheCapitol then I would be here defending their right to protest.
- Klonoar 6y ago
- flunhat 6y ago"That didn't happen. And if it did, it wasn't that bad. And if it was, that's not a big deal. And if it is, that's not my fault. And if it was, I didn't mean it. And if I did... You deserved it."
- na85 6y ago>Don't call a bunch of selfie taking hooligans insurretionists They had knives and zip ties and intended to take hostages. The fact that they are incompetent does not obviate their intent.
- ttt0 6y agohttps://www.insider.com/zip-tie-guy-capitol-riot-plastic-handcuffs-police-prosecutors-2021-1 https://www.insider.com/zip-tie-guy-capitol-riot-plastic-han...
- girvo 6y agoThey killed a police officer. Brutally assaulted others. Stole computers after breaking in.