5 ms·
> The problem is that it's not totally clear whether Giuliani believed any of his crazy-talk. It may actually be the case that Giuliani is just off his rocker.
by tshaddox 6y ago
> The problem is that it's not totally clear whether Giuliani believed any of his crazy-talk. It may actually be the case that Giuliani is just off his rocker. If he himself was sold by the (false) facts he received from others, he is a more difficult defamation target.
That part seems bizarre. Surely he ought to still be culpable is he said false things with the intention to damage Dominion, even if he can convince the court that he believed the things he said. Unless, of course, you're talking about an insanity defense or a claim of provocation, but those a very different matter, and I highly doubt that's a viable route.
- um_ya 6y agoThere is still meaningful court cases going on, in relation to this election. If you're curious to see all the evidence Giuliani and other lawsuits brought forward, here's a compilation of the evidence brought forward, sorted by significance: https://airtable.com/shrhYBx2cboqsKv14/tbl0at4AkLpdBFOzp?backgroundColor=gray&viewControls=on https://airtable.com/shrhYBx2cboqsKv14/tbl0at4AkLpdBFOzp?bac...
- tptacek 6y agoIs the idea here that by putting assertions that were discredited and that failed in court cases heard by Republican and, in some cases, Trump-appointed judges in Airtable, they somehow gain credibility? I think the funniest part of this is that there are columns here that contain "[number] [sentence]" formats, as if the person who built it doesn't quite get the idea of a spreadsheet.
- um_ya 6y agoThe court system moves slower than the news. Many of these lawsuits are still ongoing. Simply stating "they were discredited" doesn't make the evidence presented less true. If you look at what is presented, you'll find much of it is quite compelling.
- jliptzin 6y agoCan’t possibly be the case that a President who never won the popular vote and never polled above 50% approval during his entire term lost an election in which almost every poll leading up to it predicted his loss.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoI'd love to see these so called patriots champion installing Gore for a bonus term since he was actually shafted by a mismanaged election. Nobody went looney bin insane over that.
- newacct583 6y agoTo be fair: plenty of people went a little bit insane in 2000. But the elected leaders of both parties behaved like the adults in the room and the democracy survived just fine. For two more decades, anyway. Honestly the jury is still out on where we go from here.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y agoDid 2000 insanity have anything on 2020? IDK, tough call. Agreed on adults that somehow are now missing or more concerned with their Twitter feeds than their responsibilities.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> I’d love to see these so called patriots champion installing Gore for a bonus term since he was actually shafted by a mismanaged election. Nobody went looney bin insane over that. Actually the same people, or at least political faction, did. Over the idea of looking into and correcting the mistakes, of course, not over the idea of letting a potentially mismanaged election stand without further review. Google “Brooks Brothers riot” for one example.
- briandear 6y agoFalse: https://thehill.com/hilltv/what-americas-thinking/497435-poll-trump-approval-ticks-up-to-51-percent https://thehill.com/hilltv/what-americas-thinking/497435-pol...
- knowaveragejoe 6y ago> Is the idea here that by putting assertions that were discredited and that failed in court cases heard by Republican and, in some cases, Trump-appointed judges in Airtable, they somehow gain credibility? Yes. This is airtable is used on a number of websites that claim to show Biden cheated. It's a form of gish galloping - look closer at any of these, there's a reason why no court seriously entertained them. But when presented with so many items, it seems like there is something to it(of course, there's not).
- briandear 6y ago> why no court seriously entertained them The courts didn’t “entertain” them because of standing. Cases weren’t thrown out on merits. No court has actually heard evidence.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The courts didn’t “entertain” them because of standing. Cases weren’t thrown out on merits. No court has actually heard evidence. This is false on several levels. One, several cases went through trial to a verdict. Second, of those that did not, several were thrown out on grounds that while perhaps “procedural”, include as part of their standards review of the actual and proferred evidence in the light most favorable to the party to be ruled against. For instance, where cases were dismissed for “failure to state a claim”, this was not usually a finding that the Trump (or allied) party failed to enumerate the legal elements of an offense, but that they failed at the step beyond that which is required, to enumerate specific more detailed facts that actually would satisfy each of those elements, and proffer evidence which would make a prima facie case for each required point. (That is, which would suffice to prove the case in the absence of any counterevidence from the other side.) When cases are, as many of the Trump & allied cases were, thrown out for this reason, the court is making a finding on the merits: it is finding that the party being ruled against would lose on the merits if the case went to trial, all the evidence the moving party has offered were accepted at face value, and the other party just chose not to present anything at all to counter it. (Now, its true that in many cases the same lawsuits dismissed on this grounds were also dismissed on a other grounds – standing and laches, particularly – but it is misleading to say that the merits of the claims and the value of the evidence the plaintiff’s had was not considered.)
- jariel 6y agoThis is such an interesting point that it really throws the era of 'fake news' a judicial curveball. The same question came up with Trump's phone calls to the Georgia AG when the President was essentially threatening the AG to 'do something'. There is apparently a lot of materiality to the notion of how much the President actually believed the issue of fraud. Which is an altogether amazing new line of defence: "If you believe the lie thoroughly, you're literally less culpable!"
- throwawaygh 6y agoThis line of defense -- in both law and politics -- needs to end. Truth precedes morality, not the other way around. Our laws should recognize this.
- edgyquant 6y agoI didn’t know it was a crime isn’t a proper legal defense
- jariel 6y agoThat's not the defence though. The defence is 'I legitimately believed the election was stolen in Georgia, therefore, pressuring state officials to investigate said issues' doesn't itself constitute a crime. It's entirely plausible that people 'get things wrong' in the real world. But once you have a guy who will believe everything that's to his benefit, and claim that everything not to his credit is a lie ... well then you have a problem. It's really, really worrisome how many intelligent people do not see quite obviously the game he is playing. It's one thing for people who watch Judge Judy every day to maybe have difficulty with a lie so forcefully presented, but most people should know better. It's also interesting how it's viewed from outside the bubble of the US where the ration of 'believers' is vastly lower, and yet, at the same time there are even die-hard cohorts of them outside the border as well. There was a 'Stop The Steal' min-march in Montreal Canada of all places.
- mr_toad 6y agoI don’t know that either insanity or ‘I really believed it’ are defences in a defamation lawsuit. In any case I think it’s unlikely that Rudi will be claiming insanity.