7 ms·
I'm in the US. I was homeless as a teenager (not by choice). I live adjacent to a major homeless community (not by design). My ex left our family to join the ho
by WarOnPrivacy 6y ago
I'm in the US. I was homeless as a teenager (not by choice). I live adjacent to a major homeless community (not by design). My ex left our family to join the homeless community (she struggles with mh issues). I have some observations.
We could sharply reduce homeless numbers here if we had in-patient mental health facilities (for non-wealthy), comprehensive housing aid and politically powerful job placement programs.
I just looked up our jail budget and inmate population; we pay ~$25k/inmate/year (excluding court & police costs). That money gets us a pretty solid guarantee that arrested mentally ill people will reoffend, given how many entrenched systems there are to make sure that convicted people are locked out of most jobs and housing.
- e40 6y agoIn-patient services for mental health were decimated in the 80's. Reagan cut the funding and cities were flooded with homeless + mentally ill people. I was at UC Berkeley at the time this happened. There were so many seriously mentally ill folks on the street. It was sad.
- jandrese 6y agoIt worked out great for Republicans. The spike in crime rates made their "tough on crime" message resonate. When you're homeless and mentally ill it's basically guaranteed that you're going to have fights with the police.
- HNfriend234 6y agoTough on crime isn't purely a republican stance though. Democrats worked hand-in-hand with republicans in the late 1980s to push through many tough on crime policies. This was due to crime skyrocketing in the 1980s due to cheap and abundant crack cocaine flooding America's streets.
- r00fus 6y agoIf you replace Republican with Conservative it works. Hell, our current President is debt-hating Conservative if you view it by the bills he's authored/supported as Senator in the past 30 years.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoThe new POTUS and VP were tough on crime icons up until that recently became unpopular. https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2019/09/joe-biden-crime-bill-and-americans-short-memory/597547/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2019/09/joe-bid... https://www.latimes.com/local/political/la-me-ff-federal-judges-order-state-to-release-more-prisoners-20141114-story.html https://www.latimes.com/local/political/la-me-ff-federal-jud...
- refurb 6y agoThis is about as inaccurate a take as one could possibly imagine and is a great example of seeing the world through political bias. Reagan did not lead the charge. The ACLU was actively involved in shutting down inpatient psychiatric facilities because of the abuse that was occurring.[1] With the advent of antipsychotics, our-patient treatment became an option and was regarded as more humane. [1] https://www.aclu.org/other/aclu-history-mental-institutions https://www.aclu.org/other/aclu-history-mental-institutions
- e40 6y agoThe news media, at the time, said it was due to federal funding being cut, and Reagan was in charge. I don't doubt there are liberty issues with institutions, though. EDIT: Here's a good summary: https://www.kqed.org/news/11209729/did-the-emptying-of-mental-hospitals-contribute-to-homelessness-here https://www.kqed.org/news/11209729/did-the-emptying-of-menta... Now I remember: pushed the funding from federal to state responsibility, which caused many states to empty out the institutions. And where do you think many of those people ended up? Berkeley, CA. Because they were sometimes put on buses there, and sometimes it was just the most friendly place to be.
- refurb 6y agoThe institutions were being emptied out because organizations like the ACLU brought cases to court to have them emptied. People were being held against their will in conditions that were causing a stir in the media. It was regarded as a human rights issue that they not be confined unless there was no other option. Hence the shift to outpatient care in the community. Pining it all on Reagan’s cuts is grossly inaccurate.
- e40 6y agoYou seem to have an axe to grind. What you say is not supported by the evidence. It's definitely true in some cases, but not the main reason for the changes. See the NPR article I link to, and many others.
- 6y ago
- dragonwriter 6y ago> In-patient services for mental health were decimated in the 80's. Reagan cut the funding and cities were flooded with homeless Deinstitutionalization was a broadly supported policy, especially by advocates of the mentally ill; conditions of the widespread institutionalization were horrible. The failure to create substitute systems to address the easily forseeable consequences of deinstitutionalization was obviously a problem, but not a uniquely Republican one (though certainly Republicans were more opposed to fixing the problems once they materialized.)
- klodolph 6y agoJust an observation. The mental health system doesn’t have much capacity to begin with. Even for middle-class folk with insurance it can be very hard to get treatment. There is a shortage of mental health professionals which is projected to get worse. Psychiatrists are mostly doing medication management because that’s where they’re most effective. Following the path of getting treatment—everything including diagnosis, therapy, medication, and accommodation requests—requires a shocking amount of initiative on the part of the patient. I would love to see the country dig itself out of the hole. I think the mental health crisis itself is huge. Both in-patient and out-patient. We need more psychiatrists and psychiatrist PAs.
- thebean11 6y ago> Psychiatrists are mostly doing medication management because that’s where they’re most effective. I think it's money: insurance will shell a lot more $/hour if they do 15 minute medication appointments instead of hour therapy + medication appointments.
- caturopath 6y agoIntegrating counselling and medical doctoring is a strange idea, and it's somewhat weird that it's even as much of a thing as it is. Drug-focused psychiatrists are certainly going to be a thing so long as med school is so costly and med schools conspire to keep the supply of doctors low.
- jacobr1 6y agoIncreased secularization is also probably a factor. I presume going to your clergy for assistance was previously more common. I'm sure that kind of care had mixed effectiveness, but suspect it less available and norms are bit different for initiating that kind of conversation.
- munificent 6y ago> Integrating counselling and medical doctoring is a strange idea Why? It doesn't seem any different to me than surgery + physical therapy for a non-brain-oriented medical problem.
- klondike_ 6y agoInpatient mental hospitals used to be in every state. They housed not only the mentally ill but also the chronically homeless and other outcasts. As the advent of antipsychotics and antidepressants reduced their population, these hospitals were an obvious target for budget cuts throughout the 80s and 90s. They money for the community health centers that were supposed to replace them never materialized, and thousands of patients were left without access to their medication. Some estimate that over 50% of the homeless population is mentally ill. Ironically prison systems now provide these services (and sometimes paying more for them!!), but in a much worse environment for the patients. https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/film/showsasylums/ https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/film/showsasylums/
- arrosenberg 6y agoI'll never forget this fact because there is a King of the Hill episode (10:13) where a mentally-ill, homeless man named Spongy exclaims "Ronald Reagan kicked me out of my mental hospital!" and Hank bashfully tries to justify it as part of winning the cold war.
- Sn0wCoder 6y agoI remember that episode, seen them all at least twice. I was just a kid when they all were closing but thinking back it seemed like a good thing. I do wonder now where people thought all those people in there would go. I think a lot of people believed they did not need to be there and were getting a free ride as strange as that sounds.
- jrumbut 6y agoHard to source this claim exactly but after many discussions on the topic, my view is that people across the political spectrum believed that there were adequate outpatient mental health resources for the newly released individuals. Either they imagined it was already available or that the money saved on running the institutions would instantly create it (with some left over). There was a massive underestimation of the scope of the problem.
- 6y ago
- bigmattystyles 6y agoNot to mention if a night in jail or fine (which itself is not warranted if the person is only mentally ill and not a danger to anyone or themselves), turns into a criminal charge that is then prosecuted and leads to a conviction, you've just made their path to rejoining society so much harder. Likely, their mental health predispositions will also be made much worse due to the strain of prison. The system keeps trotting along because there's money to be made by prisons. People reflexively want the homeless off the streets and will tolerate, even reward heavy handed prosecutors. I've fallen in that category of punitive nearby residents - I live in a place near what has become a runaway encampment. When I drive by it and think how close my place is, I get angry at the homeless, the blight and trash. I have to force myself to think of the humanity, the suffering and lack of options these folks have. But to be honest, other than try to support local action to help these people, I don't do much either. I take pride in not joining the rest of the NIMBYs but you wouldn't believe the shit fit people around here threw because mobile showers were coming to the encampment once a week. Some of the people who threw the biggest shit fit also have political yard signs supporting anti-poverty measures, but as they say, talk is cheap; yard sign, sure - build cheap community housing near me or allow people to camp - hold your horses...
- crb002 6y agoI was taken political prisoner three times in the Broadlawns facility ran by Polk County Iowa - currently helping Federal Medicaid claw back the fraudulent $20k hospital bill. Lynchpins of the rampant political corruption is nepotism between Chief Justice Susan Larson Christensen/ brother 4th District Chief Judge Jeff Larson and Hon Mary Tabor/brother Chief Deputy Attorney General Eric Tabor. What you speak of does exist, it's Medicaid - the issue is only in states like Iowa do you have such due process free statutes like Iowa Code 125/229 that magistrates can lock you up without solid evidence that the person is a true threat to themselves or others.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y ago> What you speak of does exist, it's Medicaid I can't say that in-patient mental health care (for non-wealthy) is available nowhere in the US. But it is scarce enough that you may have the only example. I am excluding 72hour-hold facilities because they are more like an extended Dr.s visit, than any sort of rehabilitation.
- crb002 6y agoNo questions asked monastic living without any Jesus down your throat is rare. Only the homeless and wealthy can afford to walk from their apartment/mortgage for weeks without income. I saw several women that were domestic abuse victims - their family labeled them as crazy because Iowa doesn't really have any emergency shelters to speak of.
- zdragnar 6y agoAn ex of mine worked with the homeless through a training program attached to a shelter. Maybe 2 or 3 out of 10 took the training seriously and were stable enough to actually put it to any use. The rest were just there for free bus passes and meals, or were too unstable to hold even an unskilled job for a month. The hardest part was that those who needed help the most could have gotten it through the program, but were so untrusting of seeing a doctor that they flat out refused- most thought they would be locked up in a ward or some similar conspiracy fear. Winter around here is no joke, and it is hard to see them and not want to help, but the truth is that the visibly homeless don't want it enough to change. The invisible homeless- the people who don't look like a living stereotype- usually make it out because they still have hope.
- DenisM 6y agoPeople who are seriously helped by the program will not return, but those who were not helped will come back. Over the long run the program will be full of people who cannot be helped and a small number who will do well. So seeing 2 out of 10 doing well does not shed light on the program's success.
- ditonal 6y agoAs someone who had the unfortunate experience of being locked in a psych ward, there’s nothing “conspiracy” related about the fear of being involuntary committed, where you get stripped of all basic rights with no trial.
- Aerroon 6y agoAnd there's usually no legal recourse either. It has to be some extreme abuse for the possibility to sue successfully.
- Aerroon 6y ago>most thought they would be locked up in a ward or some similar conspiracy fear. This fear is quite legitimate though. Search around online forums for involuntary commitment and you'll see lots of horror stories. There are even news articles about it.[0] If a homeless person can get back on their feet, then they are a full member of society with all the same rights as everyone else. If they get institutionalized, whether voluntarily or involuntarily, then that'll be a mark that follows them around. They will be denied some rights.[1] A patient at such a facility often has fewer rights than even people in prison. At least in prison if your time is up then you'll be released. The problems don't stop there either. Misdiagnoses are common. Even when they aren't, it's likely that the treatment they offer has no or minimal effect. It's also possible that the trauma of being in such a facility causes issues of its own. I can completely understand why people would prefer to struggle with their problems as homeless, but free, rather than go to such a facility. [0] https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/times-watchdog/public-crisis-private-toll-free-to-check-in-but-not-to-leave-washington-mental-health-care/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/times-watchdog/pub... [1] https://reason.com/volokh/2020/09/10/the-second-amendment-and-people-who-had-been-involuntarily-committed-20-years-ago/ https://reason.com/volokh/2020/09/10/the-second-amendment-an...
- cabalamat 6y ago> politically powerful job placement programs What do you mean here?
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoFrom what I have seen, job placement programs flounder due to lack of strong, consistent interest from elected officials. Without sticks or carrots from local Govs, area employers ignore employer services in favor of whatever hiring practices they're already using. source: Five years as employment service specialist and another five years trying to help my kids get jobs in spite of first-time hires being algorithmically blackballed by default.