4 ms·
>there's basically "meritocratic" caste system in this country: if you go to the right school, get into the right industry, and make enough money you are [ ...
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
>there's basically "meritocratic" caste system in this country: if you go to the right school, get into the right industry, and make enough money you are [ ... ]
This is a description of the absolute opposite of what "meritocratic" means.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> This is a description of the absolute opposite of what “meritocratic” means. Well, its actually exactly what the use that brought “meritocracy” into the common lexicon was referring to, though that use was satirical.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoNo, "meritocracy" was brought into the common lexicon in the 1960s, specifically as an alternative to existing forms of social structure. A system where it did not matter which school you went to, in particular. I do not read the GP as being satirical in their use, although the use of quotes makes it somewhat unclear.
- mrwh 6y agoWell, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rise_of_the_Meritocracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rise_of_the_Meritocracy absolutely is satire (or rather, satire used to serious effect). But it's true that this was very quickly forgotten.
- robocat 6y agoNo. dragonwriter is referencing the original history of the word. The author Michael Young who coined the word in 1958 was using it in his book to show everything wrong with a “merit” based system, as he explains here: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2001/jun/29/comment https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2001/jun/29/comment This gives a good background: https://kottke.org/17/03/the-satirical-origins-of-the-meritocracy https://kottke.org/17/03/the-satirical-origins-of-the-merito...
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago"Michael Young popularised but did not coin the term “meritocracy”. That came in 1956, two years before his book, when in the magazine Socialist Commentary (to which Young contributed) the industrial sociologist Alan Fox put the word in quotation marks and defined it as “the society in which the gifted, the smart, the energetic, the ambitious and the ruthless are carefully sifted out and helped towards their destined positions of dominance, where they proceed not only to enjoy the fulfilment of exercising their natural endowments but also to receive a fat bonus thrown in for good measure”. https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/oct/21/michael-young-and-the-perils-of-meritocracy https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/oct/21/michael-youn...
- robocat 6y ago“Michael Young adapted his 1955 Ph.D. thesis into a dystopian novel” - https://discoversociety.org/2018/10/02/the-birth-of-meritocracy-michael-young-the-rise-of-the-meritocracy-and-post-war-british-politics/ https://discoversociety.org/2018/10/02/the-birth-of-meritocr... “When the word meritocracy made its first recorded appearance, in 1956 in the obscure British journal Socialist Commentary, it was a term of abuse, describing a ludicrously unequal state that surely no one would want to live in. Why, mused the industrial sociologist Alan Fox, would you want to give more prizes to the already prodigiously gifted? Instead, he argued, we should think about “cross-grading”: how to give those doing difficult or unattractive jobs more leisure time, and share out wealth more equitably so we all have a better quality of life and a happier society.” - https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/mar/20/meritocracy-inequality-theresa-may-donald-trump https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/mar/20/merito... “Jean Floud, Alan Fox, and Michael Young had a number of commonalities. Jean Floud taught at the London School of Economics while Michael Young was pursuing his PhD. Alan Fox was a member of that 1950s circle of left-leaning thinkers that included Jean Froud and Michael Young. Since all three are now dead, it's tough to say which amongst those three coined the word "meritocracy". Michael Young had already been evincing thoughts along the lines that led to his publication of The Rise of the Meritocracy since 1951. Most references go with Michael Young as the originator of the word. One last thing is certain: The term as coined by one of those three was anything but complimentary. It was instead quite derogatory.” - https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/34390/did-the-term-meritocracy-originate-in-a-dystopian-satire#34399 https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/34390/did-the-t... “the magazine Socialist Commentary (to which Young contributed) the industrial sociologist Alan Fox put the word in quotation marks and defined it as ‘the society in which the gifted, the smart, the energetic, the ambitious and the ruthless are carefully sifted out and helped towards their destined positions of dominance, where they proceed not only to enjoy the fulfilment of exercising their natural endowments but also to receive a fat bonus thrown in for good measure’.”. 1. Young says he created the word, and we have no reason to doubt that (as per Guardian link). 2. It was used in a negative sense in 1956 I think you are cherry-picking. If you wish to disagree with the generally held beliefs, then I think you should pick a better reference than one comment on an Internet page.
- jdbernard 6y agoIt's weird. You're right, but those are still seen as "meritocratic", and one could argue were meritocratic historically, at least in some degree, because in theory you get into the right school by scholastic merit, you get into the right industry by merit of your learned and demonstrated skillset and willingness to work in that industry, and you have money by merit of having created value from your hard work in industry. In practice you get into the right schools because you belong to the right social circles, you get into the right industry because you come from the right schools, or are in the right social circles, and you make enough money because you got into the right schools and industry or inherited by virtue of being born into the right social circles...
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoWhen meritocracy was being pushed as a social goal in the 1960s, it related more to the question of who end up in positions of power, positions where they could make decisions that would affect society. It was not necessarily about who was going to get rich. It was about no longer picking decision makers from the children of the existing decision makers. It ran into two problems. The first was that we didn't really think through how we were going to establish merit in the first place. What's happened there is that we've adopted a bunch of stupid shorthand ("they graduated Harvard") that essentially is undifferentiated from what we were doing before we tried to build a meritocracy. We never found (maybe never tried to find) any way of establishing that a kid with a degree from a public university in Kansas was actually going to be better at national infrastructure planning than the one from Harvard (or not, for that matter). The second problem is that the people who benefited from the meritocratic goal (I am one of them) have worked quite hard to pull up the ladders behind them (us). We've erected all sorts of barriers (but mostly cost) to ensure that only our descendants and direct beneficiaries get access to the social institutions that are now used to define "merit".
- spamizbad 6y agoIt's in air quotes for a reason - we label it meritocracy but there are clearly structural issues in place that preventing our society from being such a thing.