4 ms·
And this is from a company that forgot to tell people that the flashy smart thermostat they bought last year has had a mic in it the whole time. They are a com
by pseudosavant 6y ago
And this is from a company that forgot to tell people that the flashy smart thermostat they bought last year has had a mic in it the whole time.
They are a company that will only pay attention to privacy when forced to by an existential threat. It just isn't in their company DNA to care about user privacy. They aren't the customers.
- hertzrat 6y agoWhat do you mean a microphone in a thermostat? You mean nest?
- deadmutex 6y agoI know Ecobee Thermostat has a mic built in... but not Nest Thermostat. So, OP is likely mistaken in their comment.
- deadmutex 6y ago> that the flashy smart thermostat they bought last year has had a mic in it the whole time. Note to readers: This is false. EDIT: If you're downvoting, please provide evidence. There is a lot of misinformation out there, and OPs post increases it. EDIT #2: Here is Rishi Chandra, GM of Nest: "Putting a microphone on a thermostat, I actually don't think makes any sense"
- tempest_ 6y agohttps://www.cnet.com/news/google-calls-nests-hidden-microphone-an-error/ https://www.cnet.com/news/google-calls-nests-hidden-micropho... It was in their security hub which is perhaps better or worse than the thermostat depending on your view.
- deadmutex 6y agoMy understanding is that security hub announced glass break detection from day 1. And that feature uses a microphone to listen to glass breaks... so I wasn't surprised. But, I guess that's not obvious to everyone, so they could've put it on the box. And, I just didn't HN readers to think there was a mic on the thermostat, so I was correcting that.
- frenchy 6y agoHaving a microphone to detect broken glass is very much not obvious. As someone completely unfamiliar with the problem space, I would have assumed the normal solsolution was something along the lines of: run a current throught the glass and check the voltage "drop".
- deadmutex 6y agoI could see this if you connected the device to the system that monitored this. But since you never do that in the install process, I am not sure why you'd assume that's how the system would work.