3 ms·
> It seems that as systems scale (in size) they tend to become inherently lower-trust. I think the commodity markets (grains, coal, oil, steel, etc) are a sign
by gumby 6y ago
> It seems that as systems scale (in size) they tend to become inherently lower-trust.
I think the commodity markets (grains, coal, oil, steel, etc) are a significant counterexample: they do use spot checks but by and large run pretty lean on mechanism and rely on trust.
Another one is customs enforcement.
- AnHonestComment 6y agoIsn’t broken trust due to low quality Chinese steel and Chinese counterfeits eroding the international order? Those seem like a weird example to hold up as a success — that high trust spot checking system is failing in the face of trying to integrate with a low trust actor and is tearing down international trade with it.
- i_am_proteus 6y agoI'll agree, but also note that commodities are fungible.
- gumby 6y agoSorry, that was precisely my point. Commodities depend on their fungibility: that wheat is all durum and has an impurity level below X; the sulphur level of that crude oil is between Y and Z, and so on. Plus that the seller will deliver per the contract There's a game theory argument that the system is somewhat self-managing; though you could defect in any single transaction your reputation would suffer and it wouldn't be worth it. Perhaps it's a good counterexample because of its size: everybody purchasing directly in the commodities market (i.e. people who take delivery) can afford to have one bad batch because their volume is so high. But still, that depends on some degree of gatekeeping on the input side.
- i_am_proteus 6y agoIndeed, and good food for thought. The fungibility is a feature both of these products being commodities in general, and of their quality being measurable. When measuring quality is cheap and easy, the risks for a defector are high. When measuring quality is expensive and/or difficult, the risks for a defector are lower, and the defector's incentives may therefore be comparably greater.
- dcx 6y agoI've spent a few years in a couple of bulk commodities, and I'm sorry, but your thought about commodity markets is simply not true in my experience. There are entire webs of institutions and mechanisms that make sure people do not defraud each other. Some keywords - look into Letters of Credit, Bills of Lading, Certificates of Origin, INCOTERMS, and the requirements to make these work (such as inspection certificates from independent third-party organisations like SGS or CIQ). Bulk commodities can be sampled, tested and certified as many as 4-8 times in between buyer and seller, on a dozen different criteria. Bulk commodity trading happens in an intrinsically low trust environment - it is frequently arms-length, cross-border, multiparty, for millions of dollars per transaction, and with a crazy number of different risks that have to be mitigated. The incentives to defect and come away millions richer are huge. And much of the system was developed for a time before the Internet. While this is a noble sentiment, the structure and transaction costs are absolutely essential for the whole thing to work.
- gumby 6y agoThanks for the info based on actual experience!