10 ms·
Italy consumer association sues Apple for planned iPhone obsolescence
- asutekku 6y agoI wonder why all of these associations go against apple, when most android phones stop getting updates much earlier than any iPhone or other Apple device.
- wincy 6y agoYeah it’s bizarre to me. Then again governments aren’t known for being the most tech savvy.
- varispeed 6y agoI have not updated my phone in two years, because I know the update I am going to get will disable call recording functionality. Phone works fine except that I cannot disable the notification about the update that pops up randomly in hope that I'll click to accept by mistake. Also maybe that's why my phone works well as there are no updates that would slow things down.
- dfxm12 6y agoAt least in the US, Apple has biggest market share by vendor at almost 50%. Samsung is a somewhat distant 2nd [0]. I would assume Italy is similar. You go against the biggest company to have the biggest impact, get the biggest settlement and set the biggest precedent. 0 - https://www.statista.com/statistics/620805/smartphone-sales-market-share-in-the-us-by-vendo https://www.statista.com/statistics/620805/smartphone-sales-...
- ashtonkem 6y agoGoing against Apple on this case also makes it more likely that they’ll lose, and make the opposite precedent. For all of its faults, Apple is very good at supporting old phones; they’re probably the hardest manufacturer to sue on this dimension.
- salsadip 6y agoIn Europe, iPhones are less common than the US. Italy has between 23-27% market share [0], in Germany it is at about 20% [1]. Just FYI [0] https://www.statista.com/statistics/622758/apple-ios-market-share-in-italy/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/622758/apple-ios-market-... [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/462009/iphone-sales-market-share-germany/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/462009/iphone-sales-mark...
- kergonath 6y agoSamsung is dominant in the EU (around 40%, followed by Apple and Huawei around 20% each): https://www.statista.com/statistics/632599/smartphone-market-share-by-vendor-in-europe/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/632599/smartphone-market... I can’t seem to get numbers for Italy (without a pay wall), but I’d expect Huawei and Samsung to be stronger than in the EU overall because of their phones’ lower average price.
- notsureaboutpg 6y agoBut Android phones can run other software if the consumer chooses. I also think the consumer isn't buying "Android" the software. They are buying Samsung's phone or Google's phone the hardware and it comes preinstalled with Android but that's not part of what you are paying for. Whereas, with Apple they are throttling the performance of the phone you paid for with software you cannot remove or swap out or opt out of (since you didn't know the software update comes with degraded performance). I also think this way of thinking is shortsighted and missing the big picture, but it's probably the thought process here.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoTime-limited updates and support is not a problem. It does not prevent you from using the product for as long as you want. From the article it seems that they allege that Apple is shortening the life of its products by degrading the user experience over time.
- JeanMarcS 6y agoI guess it's because with iOS you only have one company in front of you, when with Android, there are several phone making companies. I don't know if Google can be held responsible if a company decide to stop upgrades on their own devices.
- mvanbaak 6y ago'Apple has a lot of money, we want money, lets sue Apple and maybe we get money'
- fulafel 6y agoThey are claiming damages, probably the bounty is much higher since a typical Android phone costs 200€ vs Apple's 1200€. Plus a lot of consumer protection legislation and precedents signal that high end products have to last longer.
- foxyv 6y agoMy bet would be that it's because the people who are in powerful positions own iPhones. You are a lot more likely to go after someone you have negative experiences with. When your original $800 iPad gets soft bricked by the appstore and your $3000 touch bar Macbook starts falling apart you aren't going to sue Samsung too, just because they have similar issues. Then again it may just be because they are Apple, the company with enough cash to start-up a small country.
- wincy 6y agoApple has planned obsolescence? I’m amazed that I got a software update for my iPhone 6S last year. And it worked pretty well. So well that when I upgraded and the trade in value was $100, rather than the $200 I had expected, it gave me pause and I decided the device was still worth $100 to me, and kept it. My daughter sometimes watches Cocomelon or does Khan Academy Kids with it, on the original battery. What exactly is Italy expecting from Apple here? The device doesn’t stop working, or anything like that.
- Izkata 6y agoMost likely this is about CPU throttling when the battery's health degrades, not software updates.
- flatiron 6y agoyou can turn that off now
- SwiftyBug 6y agoWait, really? How?
- menugarit 6y agoSettings -> Battery -> Battery Health -> Peak Performance Capability. There should be a small link to disable this.
- InvaderFizz 6y agoHere is an article describing everything: https://www.macrumors.com/guide/disable-performance-management-in-ios-11-3/ https://www.macrumors.com/guide/disable-performance-manageme...
- MagnumOpus 6y agoApple added that very quickly after the scandal came to light. A clear sign that they knew it was wrong to artificially slow down customers' phones without notifying them.
- jihadjihad 6y agoSince this "article" is a mere six sentences long, it's hard to determine what the specific practices are which "tricked" consumers. I recently recycled my 6 Plus in Oct for the new SE, and still had the original battery for all those years. Seems very strange they included the 6S on their list, since at least it's possible to install the latest iOS on it. With my 6 Plus I was stuck on iOS 12.
- DangerousPie 6y agoRidiculous to target Apple here. They have been way better than any other mobile phone manufacturer about this. How many Android devices released over 5 years ago still have access to the latest OS version and security updates?
- theodric 6y agoThey have a plan, but it's a less evil plan than other mfrs. My Pixel 2 XL, which is FINE, is now out of software support. I bought it in August 2018, when it was the latest Pixel. Meanwhile my wife's 6S, from Sept 2015, is still supported. Go sue Google!
- reaperducer 6y agoSame experience here. I have an iPhone which got a security update a few months ago. I think the phone is seven years old now. Meanwhile, the Android supplied by my job is done with security updates after a little under two years.
- travellingprog 6y agoIt's not guaranteed to get software updates, but Pixel 2 is able to run Android 11, and so I believe it will continue to get security updates so long as Android 11 receives them. But it won't get access to Android 12 whenever that comes out and I agree overall that the support period for smartphone software is way too short nowadays.
- organsnyder 6y agoI finally switched to iPhone after my perfectly functional Pixel XL was effectively made useless by Google discontinuing security updates. Perhaps I could have flashed a custom ROM on the Pixel, but I want a device that works with minimal fuss (I'd rather tinker on other things).
- thayne 6y agoAnd google is praised for having 3 years of support when most other Android phones have 2 or less. I get not giving full OS updates for longer, but it seem like security updates for an expensive, important device that most people rely heavily on should be for 10 years at least.
- sixdimensional 6y agoI worked in obsolescence in a previous job - it was a small department, with a very specialized knowledgebase, and tricky purpose. People don't realize that it is a very difficult balancing act to keep electronics working over the long term due to the ever advancing pace of technology (hardware and software), complexity of manufacturing, materials availability, customer demand, etc. One part of that could include rapid design refreshes planned on a schedule to avoid obsolescence issues, for example. When viewed a certain way, pumping out new products rapidly and not supporting old products for long periods of time could be perceived as planned obsolescence, but is possibly a reaction to customer demands.. I am not defending planned obsolescence here (perhaps pointing out a different concept entirely given its current negative definition), but there is a point of view that planning for and addressing obsolescence in a controlled and transparent manner, proactively, may actually be a good thing, not a bad thing. But it could be quite hard to see that perspective as a consumer. Also, certainly, when done behind the scenes for reasons that only serve the best interests of a private organization and not the customer and/or environment - that is an entirely different story and not acceptable.
- kitsunesoba 6y agoIn a subset of electronics that had not yet “plateaued” until recently like smartphones, managing obsolescence has to be even more tricky. In terms of sheer power, the difference between even and iPhone 4 or 5 and 11 or 12 is staggering and so huge that the speed difference can be felt even with pedestrian tasks. Earlier models like the original/3G/3GS are so much slower they’re practically on a different plane of existence. It’s almost like the difference between an early-90s 68k Mac and and early 2000s PowerMac G3/G4 towers. The gulf between the two was so wide that continuing to support even the most powerful 68k models just wasn’t practical.
- mariusmg 6y agoMy phone runs Android 4, which was probably supported for ~ 2 years. This title makes me laugh ...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- foxyv 6y agoWeird, I would think they would go after them for the laptops. Then again, the iPhones seem okay except for their weird "security" stuff where if you swap a screen it bricks the phone after an update a few months later. https://www.techtimes.com/articles/224769/20180410/if-you-ve-had-an-iphone-screen-replacement-the-new-ios-update-will-brick-your-device.htm https://www.techtimes.com/articles/224769/20180410/if-you-ve... https://www.ifixit.com/News/9917/11-3-update-breaking-iphone-screens https://www.ifixit.com/News/9917/11-3-update-breaking-iphone...
- floppiplopp 6y agoWe really need to focus more on the software when talking planned obsolescence of mobile devices. There's phones out there that won't get any security fixes even when they're new, making them obsolete instantly. Why do people keep ignoring that?