5 ms·
Is there any reason to believe the emissions are in fact lower? Passengers have to eat, wash, live and sleep for 7 days so you're carrying food and a lot of li
by rwmj 6y ago
Is there any reason to believe the emissions are in fact lower? Passengers have to eat, wash, live and sleep for 7 days so you're carrying food and a lot of living space / entertainment stuff on each trip.
- rainingmonkey 6y agoThe excellent lowtechmagazine does a deep dive on this: https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2008/06/ocean-liners.html https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2008/06/ocean-liners.html > to transport one passenger across the Atlantic, a plane needs 4 times more engine power than a ship. Energy output does not say all there is to say about fuel consumption however, since it does not take into account the duration of the trip (see comments) and the fuel efficiency of the engines. It says even less about the emissions of toxic fumes and CO2, because marine engines burn much dirtier fuel than aeroplanes. > If we would stuff people in the Queen Mary 2 like we fold passengers in airplane seats, the ship could transport more than 500,000 people ... [This] would boil down to a power output of 0.18 kilowatts per passenger – comparable to the output of a well-trained cyclist and 700 times more efficient than the engine power per passenger of an airplane. Taking into account the duration of the voyages, the ship scores 70 times better than the plane. > Transporting 30,000 people on the QM2 is far from unrealistic or uncomfortable ... Every one of those 30,000 passengers on the Queen Mary 2 would have 20 times as much space than a passenger on a plane, while at the same time consuming 43 times less engine power (taking the view that both engines has similar efficiency). Taking into account the duration of the trip, the ship is 4 times more energy efficient than the plane.Now this looks like an option that could be useful in a peak oil world. > Replacing planes by ocean liners would be an ecologically sound idea, but only if marine engines become cleaner. Most ships make use of very dirty (unrefined) diesel oil that needlessly poisons the air and heats up the atmosphere. This is not a technological but a political problem.