6 ms·
You're being downvoted because HN loves electric car, but for the layman, that's their thought process: 1. Does the EV cost as much as a regular car? Most of t
by oblio 6y ago
You're being downvoted because HN loves electric car, but for the layman, that's their thought process:
1. Does the EV cost as much as a regular car? Most of them are very expensive, comparatively, especially for cheap family cars.
2. Is the range comparable to regular cars? It's not, at similar prices it's 60%.
3. Is it trivial to recharge it, especially quickly? Not true for most of the world.
4. Can the car be bought today? Nope, most are just announced and even for those that are "available" delivery is many months from now.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoIt's not hard to see the trajectory however. I heard the same types of arguments against digital cameras. Ten years later film cameras barely exist.
- oblio 6y agoTrue, but timing is everything. 2021 still seems to early for mass EV adoption, 2022 might see a proper ramp up and we will have to wait until 2025 or so, for better battery tech and cheaper batteries, to have EVs truly on an equal footing to internal combustion engine cars. After that things will probably pick up and we'll get the hockey stick that leads to what you're saying.
- theshrike79 6y ago1. True, EVs are more expensive and do need government subsidies to make up the difference 2. If you're measuring range as "don't stop at all, I'll pee in a bottle" range, then yes. A better measurement would be "is the range enough for my normal daily use", then the answer is yes for a large number of people. Not everyone of course, some people actually _need_ to drive long distances daily without the ability to recharge. For those people an ICE car is the only valid option for at least a good 5 years. 3. The first thing you should forget is the "gas station" mentality, there shouldn't be any need to drive to a specific "charging station" and wait for 45 minutes doing nothing for the car to charge. Recharging should always be done at home overnight (10+ hours of charge time, low power requirement), or during normal daily activities (work, shopping). Quick recharges should only be needed if you're driving more in a day than the car's maximum range is. Road trips and traveling long distances mostly. 4. True, electric cars are sold as fast as they can be churned off the production line. The most popular ones have long queues.
- oblio 6y ago> Recharging should always be done at home overnight (10+ hours of charge time, low power requirement), or during normal daily activities (work, shopping). A big chunk of the world's population lives in dense cities without access to private parking. A big chunk of that big chunk lives in developing countries where new infrastructure roll out is very slow, so readily available street charging is probably more than 5 years into the future. My prediction: for the next 5 years EVs will be the domain of upper middle classes and for the next 10 years EVs will be the domain of middle classes. Poor people will keep using ICE cars until at least 2035, maybe more. And they will still account for probably half the cars on the road.
- theshrike79 6y agoPrivate parking won't be an issue if you can charge the car during grocery runs, but yes, it's an issue. Rolling out charging isn't much more complicated than rolling out streetlights. But it depends on what kind of "developing countries" we are talking about. I agree with your prediction wholeheartedly, new car sales will slowly move to EV or PHEV during the next 10 years. After that they'll start to trickle down to the used car market with more affordable prices. It will be a while before you can grab a $1k beater EV though.
- thinkcontext 6y ago> Does the EV cost as much as a regular car? Most of them are very expensive, comparatively, especially for cheap family cars. The average price paid for new US cars was $40K [0]. There are now plenty of models below that without subsidy, including Chevy Bolt, Nissan Leaf, VW ID4, Kia Niro, Hyundai Kona and even the low end of the Tesla 3. That's just the upfront price, of course TCO is lower than a same price ICE car because fuel and maintenance are lower. [0] https://www.carscoops.com/2021/01/average-new-car-prices-in-the-u-s-surpass-40000-for-the-first-time/ https://www.carscoops.com/2021/01/average-new-car-prices-in-...
- oblio 6y agoThat $40k price is just for the US. For the rest of the world prices are much lower, even in developed countries (the average EU car price is about $35k: https://www.statista.com/statistics/425095/eu-car-sales-average-prices-in-by-country/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/425095/eu-car-sales-aver...). And let's not get started with developing countries, where it's a lot more likely that the price is around $15k. On top of that, a lot of people buy used cars. Even in the rich US, used car sales dwarf sales of new cars: https://www.statista.com/statistics/183713/value-of-us-passenger-cas-sales-and-leases-since-1990/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/183713/value-of-us-passe... And as cars are a quickly depreciating asset, used cars are much cheaper on average: > In 2019, the average selling price of used vehicles came to around 21,000 U.S. dollars https://www.statista.com/statistics/274928/used-vehicle-average-selling-price-in-the-united-states/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/274928/used-vehicle-aver... This is what EVs are fighting against. Not just against other new cars, but against used cars too. Plus personally I've rarely convinced anyone to buy anything with TCO calculations. Maybe you've had more luck :-) I think EVs are still a few years ago from real mass adoption. 2025 sounds a bit more realistic. I'd say that the second gen ones are the ones that will make it through (Tesla Model 3 2027 facelift, or whatever they'll call it, ID3/ID4 2028 facelift, etc.). Those will probably have access to well developed super charging networks and to 90-100k MWh batteries at a 25% lower price.
- thinkcontext 6y agoYou've moved the goalposts from where you originally said EV's are "very expensive". "Very expensive" cannot mean less than the average price for a new car. You can argue more expensive than comparable quality or something but "very expensive" is wrong. As for used cars, I don't think there's enough data yet but I recall seeing an article where Teslas depreciated less than comparable ICE vehicles. On the developing world front, in the last few months of the year the best selling EV in China cost $4,200. > Plus personally I've rarely convinced anyone to buy anything with TCO calculations. Maybe you've had more luck :-) The fuel costs ways less per mile, what don't you believe about that? > I think EVs are still a few years ago from real mass adoption. 2025 sounds a bit more realistic. This is what the projections I've read say as well, and battery prices will continue to decline, though not as steeply. That will be when the steepening of the adoption S curve happens.