4 ms·

"To me local timelines only make sense if the instance has a very clearly defined group with some kind of shared access, e.g, a company that has an instance for

"To me local timelines only make sense if the instance has a very clearly defined group with some kind of shared access, e.g, a company that has an instance for use by its employees, or a club or organization have some kind of membership" Wow yeah, this makes a lot of sense. It's too bad nodes became associated with niche hobbies or interests. E.g. a fraternity/sorority that hosts a node would make perfect sense for a local timeline. I guess the only issue is that these organizations aren't permanent. So people would have to migrate, which isn't a thing for twitter or facebook. I know mastodon has a feature for this specifically but I think people would still find it too confusing if people's handles kept on changing.

throwaway894345 6y ago
But even then, you can only pick one server per account, which seems asinine in this day and age. I should be able to browse any topic with one identity.
- rglullis 6y ago
  > I should be able to browse any topic with one identity. You can. Who said otherwise? Where did you get that idea? An account at Mastodon (or Pleroma/Misskey/Pixelfed/anything) lets you follow anyone you want. There is no restriction about server talking with each other at the protocol level. If the server is federating and its admin is not trigger-happy with federation, you are good to go.
  - throwaway894345 6y ago
    I think you're mistaken. I have permissions to access posts from any server (apart from those that the administrator has blocked, anyway), but that doesn't mean I can view another server's local feed in the Mastodon UI, which is the question at hand.
  - andrewzah 6y ago
    Not every mastodon instance lets you browse their local feed if you're not registered to that instance. Now, it would be interesting if one could subscribe to multiple "local" feeds...
rglullis 6y ago
> people would still find it too if people's handles kept on changing. Will they? Isn't it the same case with email? I used my University email when I was a student. I have a different company email for different jobs? Those that needed to communicate with me because of the job, I would give them my company email. When my work at company X ended, no one expected me to still message me at raphael@x. The same with addresses from "email providers". They change less often, but it is still possible. My first account was probably at yahoo, but when gmail came up, I migrated, started to tell people my new address and auto forwarded any message that went to the old email. "Well", that may be a lot of work to some people. To which the answer is "the only way to have absolute stability regarding your identity is if you own it". You can buy a domain a use a managed email service, you can have a domain and have a managed activitypub service provider. I really don't get people's confusion over federation. It's just like email.
- FalconSensei 6y ago
  But with work/university email, you only use it for work/university. It's not a social network. It's not like you are sharing a pic of your cat, and want to keep the replies after you move to another job. After starting a new job, I don't care about my old job's emails, but my twitter (which is my social network) is still the same
  - rglullis 6y ago
    Yes. But what is your confusion about it? Where are you objecting to what I said?

throwaway894345 6y ago

But even then, you can only pick one server per account, which seems asinine in this day and age. I should be able to browse any topic with one identity.

rglullis 6y ago
> I should be able to browse any topic with one identity. You can. Who said otherwise? Where did you get that idea? An account at Mastodon (or Pleroma/Misskey/Pixelfed/anything) lets you follow anyone you want. There is no restriction about server talking with each other at the protocol level. If the server is federating and its admin is not trigger-happy with federation, you are good to go.
- throwaway894345 6y ago
  I think you're mistaken. I have permissions to access posts from any server (apart from those that the administrator has blocked, anyway), but that doesn't mean I can view another server's local feed in the Mastodon UI, which is the question at hand.
- andrewzah 6y ago
  Not every mastodon instance lets you browse their local feed if you're not registered to that instance. Now, it would be interesting if one could subscribe to multiple "local" feeds...

rglullis 6y ago

> people would still find it too if people's handles kept on changing. Will they? Isn't it the same case with email? I used my University email when I was a student. I have a different company email for different jobs? Those that needed to communicate with me because of the job, I would give them my company email. When my work at company X ended, no one expected me to still message me at raphael@x. The same with addresses from "email providers". They change less often, but it is still possible. My first account was probably at yahoo, but when gmail came up, I migrated, started to tell people my new address and auto forwarded any message that went to the old email. "Well", that may be a lot of work to some people. To which the answer is "the only way to have absolute stability regarding your identity is if you own it". You can buy a domain a use a managed email service, you can have a domain and have a managed activitypub service provider. I really don't get people's confusion over federation. It's just like email.

FalconSensei 6y ago
But with work/university email, you only use it for work/university. It's not a social network. It's not like you are sharing a pic of your cat, and want to keep the replies after you move to another job. After starting a new job, I don't care about my old job's emails, but my twitter (which is my social network) is still the same
- rglullis 6y ago
  Yes. But what is your confusion about it? Where are you objecting to what I said?