4 ms·
A community of contributors backed by a diverse set of companies has to be seeded by an MVP. Where would that MVP come from? For complex software it's either an
by wmf 6y ago
A community of contributors backed by a diverse set of companies has to be seeded by an MVP. Where would that MVP come from? For complex software it's either an internal project spun out from a unicorn or a labor of love from a gentleman hacker. These are pretty limited routes; it's much easier to start an open source startup with the caveat that the community will probably never emerge later because the startup will be moving too fast for outsiders to jump in. Now startups feel they have to use "innovative" licenses to be successful but the powers that be are deriding these licenses as "fake open source". We're setting ourselves up for an OSS winter where sophisticated developer tools or installable infrastructure software just won't be created.
- nine_k 6y agoThe term "open source" has a well-known definition, and the "novel licenses", like Mongo's, do not match it. They are more like the "source available" licenses, as practiced by MS in 1990s, and by IBM, much earlier.
- IncRnd 6y agoThere are several definitions for Open Source that come from foundations and other groups, which push their own beliefs and standards. Opensource.org, for example, pushes their own definition that excludes all those who do not use the perferred license! However, dictionaries that mirror collective understandings, as used by millions of people, tell a different story. According to OxfordLanguages, Open Source denotes, "software for which the original source code is made freely available and may be redistributed and modified." If you look at Dictionary.com. you will see that Open-Source is defined as "pertaining to or denoting a product or system whose origins, formula, design, etc., are freely accessible to the public." So, no, open source doesn't have a single definition, except to groups who are pushing their own definitions.
- temac 6y agoFor software the overwhelming consensus is the OSI definition (extremely close to the FSF def, extremely close to what is applied as criteria by various distro, etc.) You may want to write "Open Source" to be sure it is not confused with something else, but even "open source" should be parsed as that definition by default. This is not even pushing a political agenda or a judgment of value. Just "everybody" calls that like that, so there is no point in overloading the term for other approaches. Using another term for other things is perfectly fine and there are plenty of them possible with a positive tone, in case they bring positive things to the table.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y ago> There are several definitions for Open Source that come from foundations and other groups ...and all of them do so because they really want to pretend that their software is "open source" without actually putting it under an open source license. Like, in the abstract I agree that it's weird having the OSI (or any one group) define "open source", but in this case I'm okay with it because every single "alternative definition" turns out to be someone just trying to pretend that their source-available software is "open source" for marketing reasons when it isn't.