4 ms·
Reasons Apple won't build a car: (1) low margin industry, (2) diverse, well-capitalized, experienced legacy players, (3) fundamentally different business model,
by ethbr0 6y ago
Reasons Apple won't build a car: (1) low margin industry, (2) diverse, well-capitalized, experienced legacy players, (3) fundamentally different business model, (4) limited technical ability to differentiate (that integration doesn't already provide), etc.
Reasons Apple will build a car: (1) it's one of the few industries big enough to move their revenue needle, (2) it's one of the few greenfield physical platforms that their cloud competitors (Facebook, Amazon, Google, Microsoft) don't own a major stake in (from this perspective, think of it as XBox-for-Apple).
With the Biden win, the only way I see Apple going into cars in a big way is if it's fully electric, speaks to an environmentalist company ethos, and is a low-volume, high-margin product (e.g. Tesla Roadster) that's effectively subsidized PR & marketing spend and lets them make presentations about it for the next 5+ years.
Which seems like an awful lot of R&D and product polish dollars and hours to spend, and I think would say more about their alternate options (or lack thereof) than how attractive building a car is.
- onethought 6y agoYour reasons apply equally well to the phone industry before the iPhone came out. Apple could easily do this...
- ethbr0 6y agoSubstantially different circumstances. Existing phones vs iPhone Existing cars vs iCar I can't construct a plausible scenario where Apple vs Hyundai + VW + BMW + Mercedes + Ferrari + Porsche + Tesla looks anything like Apple vs Palm. There's just not that much difference between (hypothetically optimal and technically possible driving experience) and (current driving experience). Apple has historically excelled in areas where they're able to offer an improved (usually by integration of existent technologies, at scale) hardware platform coupled with a well-integrated software interface. Cars, ain't that.
- onethought 6y agoApple vs Palm??? What about: Sony, Ericson, Nokia, Motorola, LG, Samsung, HTC? Palm were like the Tesla of the day in phone land.
- nicoburns 6y ago> and is a low-volume, high-margin product If past Apple is anything to go by they'll be aiming for a high-volume, high-margin product. Very few people were willing to pay £600+ for a phone pre-iphone, but plenty of people do now.
- FireBeyond 6y ago> Very few people were willing to pay £600+ for a phone pre-iphone, but plenty of people do now. That doesn't really translate. Most people are "willing" to pay that because most carriers offer 24 month financing. A high end luxury car is going to be, at the low end $50K. Probably more towards $100K. You don't get interest free installment plans for $100K cars, and most people simply cannot afford them. There's plenty of appeal to current high end luxury cars but how are the sales of Model S P85s or higher (picking it as the most "hyped"), even compared to the 3.
- ethbr0 6y agoThe only feasible route to this is if Apple sold a car that allowed for increased utilization. (E.g. person-in-car 95% of the time vs 5% of the time) If it were providing value more of the time, it could cost more and still be worth the increase in price. But I don't see any path that gets there without a self-driving singularity to allow for humanless valet movement between "users." Maybe remotely operated human valet service, but that seems like an ugly rabbit hole? And that still leaves the fact that luxury users aren't going to be okay with ketchup stains and odors from the last user... iTaxi as a social platform starts to get more plausible. But that's more along the lines of a bus-van-social network hybrid. "Travel only with other vetted, high-net-worth Apple users" is an interesting twist, as well as a direct stab at Facebook and Microsoft (LinkedIn).
- nicoburns 6y ago> But I don't see any path that gets there without a self-driving singularity to allow for humanless valet movement between "users." Is self-driving really that unlikely? It probably won't be ready for another 10 years, but Apple probably won't be looking to launch this until then either.