5 ms·
Our infrastructure is being built based on past climate data
- gumby 6y agoI posted this not only because of the topic of the article itself but because it makes my think about systems planning (e.g. are we overprovisioning our back end for demand that may never occur?) and business plans.
- thrill 6y agoWell, there is no future climate data.
- mathgeek 6y agoActually there is. If you view all data as statistical probability, data from the past is simply a 1.0 possibility of occurring, and future data is less than 1.0. We can easily see this by looking at weather forecasting, as a common example which both exemplifies the possibility and serves as an example of why it’s not perfect.
- graeme 6y agoThe gist of this is that everything gets more expensive. Our environment was basically tailored to us. Moving away from that, and losing stability to boot adds costs. It’s another short run vs long run tradeoff. Fossil fuels brought and bring us immense short term benefits. But increasingly the benefits now will lead to larger costs in the future, both in adaptation and also in attempting to reverse the costs by taking co2 out of the air. The best solution would be to bring future costs into the present and charge for co2 emissions. That way the truly valuable uses could still happen and the more optional uses of co2 would be discouraged. This article is talking about building for the next few decades, but the non-stationarity problem will only grow if we keep emitting.
- EcoMonkey 6y ago> The best solution would be to bring future costs into the present and charge for co2 emissions. That way the truly valuable uses could still happen and the more optional uses of co2 would be discouraged. Yep. A price on carbon is actually the most powerful lever we have to bring down emissions. Very nice visualization when you move the carbon price slider here: https://en-roads.climateinteractive.org/scenario.html?v=2.7.35 https://en-roads.climateinteractive.org/scenario.html?v=2.7.... And you can make it both equitable and politically viable if you use the money from the carbon fee to provide direct payments to households, then combine with a border adjustment to maintain trade competitiveness. https://econstatement.org/ https://econstatement.org/ Ultimately we just need something in place that corrects this obvious market failure with as few side effects as possible, and carbon fee and dividend does that. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_fee_and_dividend https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_fee_and_dividend
- cortesoft 6y agoYep, carbon taxes that are split evenly amongst everyone is ideal. If you use less carbon than the average person, you will make money. It acts as both an incentive to use less carbon and an easy way to even out the wealth gap.
- syshum 6y agoIn theory I agree with the idea of charging for Co2 emissions, the problem always comes down to the execution, which in general means some kind of "carbon tax" system The problem with the carbon tax systems I have seen most of them are setup in a way not to actually change climate or anything to do with climate change but instead set up to fund unrelated agenda's and often end up being counter productive to the actual goal of reducing carbon emissions / other population.
- meowkit 6y agoPlease share said tax systems. Everything I’ve seen is an upstream tax on each ton of emissions. Its not about funding things, its about disincentivizing emissions by forcing the cost of externalities onto the production itself.
- syshum 6y agoWell those systems that do not have alternative funding goals also end up being very regressive, if my Power or Nat. Gas bill increased by 30% well I will complain online, and be frustrated every-time I have to pay it, but I will not have to choose between paying the utility or buying food. Nor will it modify my consumption of it, it just means more expenses. I use the amount of energy I need today, no more, no less. Charging me more for it will not change my consumption. That can not be said for others. Carbon Tax's on power generation and home heating have the nasty impact of being very regressive impacting the poorest among us disproportionately We need to improve Alt. Energy to make it cost competitive with Fossil Fuels, and not by artificially raising the prices on Fossil fuels which harms the poor. Carbon Tax systems also end up not actually reducing carbon, but instead allow "trading" of carbon heavily producers with monopoly lock in can simply gouge their customers with higher prices to pay for "offsets", it is akin to wealth redistribution but rather with carbon
- EcoMonkey 6y agoCarbon dividends offset the regressive nature of a carbon tax. In fact, even if you exclude the benefits of cleaner air and just look at how the carbon dividend offsets the carbon fee, folks at the lowest incomes tend to come out way ahead, at least under the Energy Innovation and Carbon Dividend Act: https://citizensclimatelobby.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/HIS2-Working-Paper-v1.1.pdf https://citizensclimatelobby.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/... > Carbon Tax systems also end up not actually reducing carbon, but instead allow "trading" of carbon heavily producers with monopoly lock in can simply gouge their customers with higher prices to pay for "offsets", it is akin to wealth redistribution but rather with carbon You're confusing carbon taxes with cap and trade and carbon credits. There are no pollution permits to trade under a typical carbon tax regime. Please check your facts before sharing inaccurate information.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- huhnmonster 6y agoWhile I agree with the gist of this, the ones to finally call the shots on such projects are always in a bad spot. They underprovision and an anomaly happens. Now they are the ones who did everything wrong and should be blamed. The overprovision and nothing ever comes close to the theoretical limit of the structure. Now they have wasted huge amounts of money and again, should obviously be blamed. The easiest way out: Plan exactly to what is considered standard. No one will blame you in either case, even if you know that it is insufficient or stupid. This is something that will probably hold true in many different industries, the consequences for dams are just a little worse..
- nine_k 6y agoI think this is similar to what happened in Fukushima, where the original architects of the Daiichi plant suggested building a much higher protective wall against tsunamis, but were forced to build a lower wall because such a catastrophic tsunami was deemed too improbable. (Then it came, of course.)
- huhnmonster 6y agoYeah, exactly. The thing is, where do you draw the line of what is statistically so unlikely that you can deem it improbable? If we run multiple different climate models through some sort of Monte Carlo simulation, I suppose each model would output a different probability of such an event occuring. In the case where all models predict a very low probability, it may be easy to say that it is unlikely. But what if two predict a very low and one predicts a low probability? Is this now applicable and should we build to be able to sustain such an event? These are hard questions and I currently do not see any way to get better data for the future as the different models still do not agree in many points
- layoutIfNeeded 6y agoThere are branches of probability theory that deal with these questions rigorously. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Large_deviations_theory https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Large_deviations_theory https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extreme_value_theory https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extreme_value_theory
- sathackr 6y agoI learned this the hard way when engineering microwave links to withstand rain rates based on historical data. Many of my links that the calculators said would have >99.999% availability saw a cumulative downtime in 2020 over 1hr due to much higher peak rain rates than historically measured. I now engineer the links to handle double the historically measured rain rates.
- huhnmonster 6y agoHow does this manifest in costs? Is it noticeable? And does rain rate mean the frequency of distinct rain events over hours/days or the intensity of a single rainfall? Just curious, maybe you can shed some light on this
- sathackr 6y agoSure -- It manifests in both cost and capability. For the same throughput you generally need more expensive equipment to obtain the same level of reliability. Where with the previous calculations it may cost X dollars for equipment, using the new calculations you may need to use a larger antenna or a more power transmitter, costing sometimes 2-3x, if it's even possible at all. Many times the link is just no longer viable at the required reliability. Rain rates are typically measured in mm/hr but it's an instantaneous rate, but what I've observed in 2020 is instantaneous peak rates easily 50% higher (indicated by signal attenuation levels) than 2019/2018. I'm not aware of any standard meteorological way to measure this as it seems most measurements are done as cumulative over minutes/hours/days, when the effects on microwave signals are in the seconds and minute scales. Certainly can't establish as causal relationship with climate change, especially since my observations are on the scale of just a few years, but it shows the danger in simply relying on low resolution historical 10/50/100yr data for infrastructure design.
- kbutler 6y agoWas that because the data was not actually peak _instantaneous_ rain rates, but rather rates averaged over a period of time (likely hours or longer)? Seems like microwave links would be most sensitive to instantaneous rate along specific paths, but any historical data would be measuring accumulated precipitation (averages over time) at specific locations.
- chiefalchemist 6y ago> "Our drain pipes, reservoirs, power lines, roads, sewage systems, and more are all designed based on past climate data." Not only past climate data, but traditional work arrangements. WFH shifts demands on infrastructure as well. Power, sewage, and so on. Mind you, WFH will eventually fade a bit. Non the less, it does change the lens of how past data / need should be interpreted.
- kbutler 6y ago"planners used historical climate data ...the water no longer flowed there." This article implies the water changes were driven by climate change, but it appears the changes were from overpumping the aquifer that fed the surface water. "The source of the Beaver River is the vast, underground Ogallala Aquifer, which reaches into eight western states. Agricultural and population growth in this part of the country meant more pressure on the aquifer, dropping its water level and reducing the river to little more than a trickle." -- https://stateimpact.npr.org/oklahoma/2013/03/28/the-lessons-of-history-no-longer-apply-when-it-comes-to-building-lakes/ https://stateimpact.npr.org/oklahoma/2013/03/28/the-lessons-... That doesn't mean climate change isn't concern, but this example is not caused by climate change, but rather by overuse of a limited water resource.
- woeirua 6y agoAt this point, we should be throwing our money at geoengineering and technology in order to try and deus ex machina our way out of the pending climate crisis. We've wasted so much time that now there really is almost no other option. No one is going to lead on this issue, so it's our only hope left. That said, I am optimistic that once the economic incentives align scientists/engineers will be able to save us from the worst effects of climate change, and down the road even reverse the effects.
- tejohnso 6y agoWe've been throwing our money at geoengineering our way into this for decades in the form of oil (and other) subsidies. We could start by eliminating those.
- s5300 6y agoSeems like quite a big hope when this is what we're dealing with. Ignore the Reddit comment section. Saw this video at least a year ago, likely more. Weird for it to pop up on Reddit today. https://old.reddit.com/r/PublicFreakout/comments/l43m5f/a_farmer_in_nebraska_asking_a_profracking/ https://old.reddit.com/r/PublicFreakout/comments/l43m5f/a_fa... Culture of don't give a fuck and swindling the non-maliciously ignorant. USA will be in for rough times
- berrynice 6y agoI'm realistic about the fact alot of the scientists and engineers will be long dead before they have a chance to save the majority of us.
- notabee 6y agoThere's a pretty good Kurzgesagt video about this.[1] Broadly speaking, there are no known existing plans that don't have massive unknowns or potential adverse consequences. 1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dSu5sXmsur4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dSu5sXmsur4
- peteradio 6y agoMy wild conspiracy theory is that this is a solved problem but admitting it has problematic geopolitical implications.
- williesleg 6y agoKnock down the interstates, they're polluted.