3 ms·
Interesting, I am Czech and I only hear about it here on HN. But it is plausible, Czechs reeeeally like dogs and love to train them. I wonder if an artificial
by inglor_cz 6y ago
Interesting, I am Czech and I only hear about it here on HN. But it is plausible, Czechs reeeeally like dogs and love to train them.
I wonder if an artificial nose could be constructed doing the same thing. Smell is a potential diagnostic tool.
For example, it seems that certain people can smell Parkinson's disease and that the biomarkers have actually been identified:
https://www.acs.org/content/acs/en/pressroom/presspacs/2019/acs-presspac-march-20-2019/sniffing-out-parkinsons-disease.html https://www.acs.org/content/acs/en/pressroom/presspacs/2019/...
We are not very good, as a civilization, in artificial smelling. Being humans, we develop machines that try to 'see' and 'hear'. A canine civilization would probably develop a smell-distinguishing AI first.
- megous 6y agoI'm also Czech, and I don't trust any of this. Methodology is suspect, and barely described. And as someone already pointed in the comments, this needs to be double blind, to avoid suggestions from the dog trainer. I'd also like to see control samples from people with other respiratory illnesses, etc.
- inglor_cz 6y agoI definitely concur that strict verification is necessary. That is one of the reason why I would prefer an electronic nose. For all their problems, machines do not want to please their handlers.
- alexpotato 6y agoI remember there being a project during the Iraq War that sought to duplicate the effectiveness of bomb sniffing dogs with some kind of chemical device. Long story short: millions spent and it was concluded that dogs are still both the best and most cost effective method for sniffing explosives.
- petre 6y agoToo bad the dogs sometimes get injured and are put to sleep. I've read about rats trained to sniff landmines. Probably their training is more expensive?