3 ms·
If I was discussing the idea of "wonderfull IP protections" and I claimed that it's evil, because Bill, an evil person, holds it. Then it would be at hominem.
by scotty79 6y ago
If I was discussing the idea of "wonderfull IP protections" and I claimed that it's evil, because Bill, an evil person, holds it. Then it would be at hominem.
It's not because I'm just judging Bill on the basis of the actions he (reportedly) performed and (imo evil) ideas (he supposedly holds).
By your definiton of 'ad hominem' many court judgements are just 'ad hominem'.