3 ms·
I do use master for branches. I use also master and slave. But, outside of tech, the meaning of slave did not changed one big. I did not seen "master" anywhere
by watwut 6y ago
I do use master for branches. I use also master and slave.
But, outside of tech, the meaning of slave did not changed one big. I did not seen "master" anywhere except master slave relationship (whether history or bdsm).
So I find theory that calling these two master and slave is unrelated to historical slavery implausible. People who use it first time being inspired by that seems most plausible origin of that name.
- lr4444lr 6y agoThe etymology of "master" goes back at least to the Latin "magister" meaning "teacher", and is used in a multitude of contexts where one person is recognized as having some kind of revered knowledge or authority about some topic. While I don't agree with the position that the word "slave" be expunged from tech for some putative role in trivializing historical slavery either, at least the argument does have a plausible premise. The anti "master" crowd though is laughably ignorant of language.
- JohnStrangeII 6y agoWell, if you start arguing this way, then you can also go all the way back and muse about what the word meant in Proto-Indoeuropean. It's still obvious that the modern use of the master/slave combo comes from centuries of slavery, not from any prior meanings. As OP said, that can be shown by studying their meanings outside the technical context. The original meaning was retained in Academia but merely as jargon. Magister artium is a "master degree." There is no "slave degree", though. There is also "mastery", master/apprentice, and so on. In other words, the offensive component of the combo is "slave", not "master." You can safely continue to use the master/apprentice combo.
- umanwizard 6y agoThere is no “slave branch” in git either.
- umanwizard 6y agoMaster is used in many contexts in English that have nothing to do with slavery. The first definition given by the OED is “a person or thing having control or authority”. An arbitrarily chosen quotation: “ M. le Comte Benedetti, French Ambassador at Berlin..sped to Vienna with the latest proposal of his master.” Certainly, this ambassador Count Benedetti was not a slave.