4 ms·
> But if the last year has taught us anything, it is that any government action is likely to be met with equal and opposite reaction (in the west), a reaction t
by sneak 6y ago
> But if the last year has taught us anything, it is that any government action is likely to be met with equal and opposite reaction (in the west), a reaction that seems to stem in large part and primarily from a section of society that lives by the adage "Après moi, le déluge", and secondarily from the section of the populace that has been spoon-fed conspiracy theories (by the former?) about the government and its nefarious nature.
I think this is perhaps a vast oversimplification, driven by a desire to attribute to nilhilism and idiocy/impressionability what may actually be deeper philosophical differences, held sincerely by intelligent people.
It seems pretty common these days to ascribe people's differing philosophical viewpoints to misinformation, conspiracy theories, foreign influence, or whatever.
It's possible that reasonable, intelligent people, just like you, simply disagree on the best ways to address these problems, and that it's not as simple as that they've been "spoon-fed conspiracy theories".
(Source: I'm one of the people in that camp. Government regulation is one tool in the drawer, but it's not a very good one for causing sweeping societal change, IMO. Tesla, for example, did vastly more for the move to automotive electrification than all of the previous US government attempts up to that point.)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- stareatgoats 6y ago> Government regulation is one tool in the drawer, but it's not a very good one for causing sweeping societal change So you at least acknowledge a role for the government in this. Just as I acknowledge that private companies can have a positive impact. Maybe what we both need to do is to isolate the hardline extremists in each camp (people that can only see government solutions in one, and people that can only see private solutions in the other), and find rational solutions to the problem. Which is sort of what I want to accomplish with this thread, sorry if it was over the top provocative.
- sneak 6y ago> So you at least acknowledge a role for the government in this. No. I mean, "attempt to kill everyone who doesn't agree precisely with me, and take over the whole world and run it precisely the way I see fit" is also a tool in the drawer. Acknowledging the fact that some people choose to take that path, and that it is a tool that this tool-using species uses sometimes, does not in any way signal my acceptance or endorsement of such a choice. I don't think that everyone that is entirely opposed to government-based solutions to the problem (or even entirely opposed to the concept of a government or a state in general) is a "hardline extremist".
- stareatgoats 6y agoAha, I see. Well, extremism is a relative term, depending on environment. In certain cryptocurrency circles I'm sure your stance is normal, in society at large it's rather extreme though, as is equating "kill everyone who doesn't agree with me" with government action in any way. The problem with this line of argument from my point of view is you oppose and obstruct highly needed government action on principle, without providing an alternative solution. The plan to offer billionaires a new start on other planets doesn't count as an alternative, sorry. But as mentioned before, if you have an alternative solution to the problem of the constantly accumulating toxins in the environment that subtracts government action from the equation up your sleeve, I'm all ears.
- EarthLaunch 6y agoI really appreciate that you’re open to a conversation, it made for an interesting thread. I can offer an alternate solution to accumulating toxins, which may or may not be comprehensive: Property rights. Pollution is a tragedy of the commons situation. If people owned, not just land, but whatever encompasses the pollution, there would be incentive not to pollute their own property. So my proposed solution would require defining property in a way that includes ownership of the pollution. Government enforces property rights, so this does rely partly on government.
- Joeri 6y ago
- simion314 6y agoTesla and Apple did everything /s This giants are building on the back of research done in Universities all over the world and Tesla benefited by government money (so how the f** Tesla gets the praises and the government gets the reverse m the exact funcking thing with God, you get ill blame it on the Devil or yourself, you get saved by doctors and science then go thank God because of the miracle he did)
- paulsutter 6y agoAll companies had the incentives, only Tesla delivered so completely. Government, and Elon, and our whole system were needed to make it happen. Seems like “both” arguments are mostly right, but overlook key information
- simion314 6y agoProbably both are needed, just makes no sense that Tesla fanboys would try to spin a governments are bad while Tesla is sucking a lot of money from many governments programs around the world and the green electricity was made possible by the green programs and taxes on polution.
- paulsutter 6y agoGood point. And perhaps government could learn from this that taxes and incentives are their most powerful tools to fight global warming. A carbon tax (which starts small but over the years becomes punitive) would be the most powerful move of all
- AlgorithmicTime 6y agoThe user you were replying to did not say government are bad.
- oblio 6y agoGovernment regulation is precisely the thing that accelerates societal change. It's maybe the sharpest tool for that. Remember CFCs and the ozone layer? If you manage to point a government in the right direction it's a juggernaut. The problem is that by design it's hard to steer.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> Tesla, for example, did vastly more for the move to automotive electrification than all of the previous US government attempts up to that point. A tax on fossil fuels raising the price multiple fold would quickly align everyone’s incentives to create less pollution. The parameters of the world don’t necessarily allow for the time required for market participants to come up with solutions or care about future generations. The difference is a tax on fossil fuels reduces quality of life for sufficient people that exist now. Therefore it’s unpopular, and not even possible to enact unless in a dictatorship or the populace accepts the idea that they need to reduce their consumption to benefit future generations.
- coding123 6y agoCA has the most expensive gas. It's extremely unpopular, yet everyone in the state pays it.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoWhat does that have to do with anything? Unless consumption is curbed to the levels required to affect environmental change, the tax is too low.
- prox 6y agoPlease tell me when in history it was companies leading the way into better working conditions, equal access to healthcare, better representation in government? I am also interested how you propose that sweeping societal change can come from something different than a elected representative government by the people, for the people?
- ABeeSea 6y agoTesla got a large amount of government subsidies and tax incentives, both federally and at the state level. Tesla would have gone bankrupt many years ago without the government. https://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-hy-musk-subsidies-20150531-story.html https://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-hy-musk-subsidies-201...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]