3 ms·
> If we go down or worse that’s not some lost ad revenue but bilious to trillions on the line. What products are exclusively traded on your exchange? If NASDAQ
by kortilla 6y ago
> If we go down or worse that’s not some lost ad revenue but bilious to trillions on the line.
What products are exclusively traded on your exchange? If NASDAQ or NYSE goes down for half a day it’s just an article on WSJ at best. They shut down every night and for entire days on holidays. What financial exchange truly has a meaningful impact when it goes down?
- dogma1138 6y agoDerivatives and futures a lot of them are exclusive contracts not available on other exchanges, if we go down during trading hours we take the market with us.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 6y agoEquities aren’t a real economy choke point. They are also, as you observe, federated. A more critical and delicate financial artery is the tri-party repo marker. If BoNY Mellon or JPMorgan’s repo desks went offline, it would almost certainly shut down large swathes of the American economy, prompt a credit crisis and merit urgent Federal Reserve and possibly Congressional intervention.
- kortilla 6y agoBut what is the timeline here? If JPM goes down for 2 hours it will cause a congressional intervention? That’s honestly really hard to believe and it borders in delusions of grandeur. Congress intervenes after days at a minimum of an ongoing crisis. My point is that your strange Internet dick measuring contest of micros to match up an order book is only one tiny aspect of engineering. Your uptime numbers have lax requirements, your geographic distribution is severely limited, and your client counts (as in clients directly accessing your software) are orders of magnitude smaller than the Twitter/Uber you compare yourself to. Operating a financial exchange it not trivial by any means, but to compare your challenges to a massive public-facing service is apples to oranges. There are likely more adversarial clients connected to twitter’s services at any given time than the peak concurrent connections to any given exchange.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> * If JPM goes down for 2 hours it will cause a congressional intervention?* It will create a crisis meriting Congressional intervention. A hiccup in the tri-party repo market automatically sends, within twenty minutes, a large fraction of the American financial system into default within twelve hours from almost anywhere on the clock. > That’s honestly really hard to believe and it borders in delusions of grandeur Lovely.
- dogma1138 6y agoYep, repo and swaps are huge, our euro repo market alone is in around quarter of trillion a day.. People don’t understand what happens when some things go down, and how it would affect them. Futures are critical to you being able to buy milk eggs and bread at the store day after day and not having the price fluctuating on you by 100’s of % or worse those items simply being unavailable because the price either spiked too high or completely crashed so the supply is nonexistent. Same goes for many other commodities. A cock up in the futures market can and will send ripples through the entire commodities market which will have a direct impact on the world’s supply chain.
- kortilla 6y agoAre you saying JPM going down means there is no alternate provider and everyone defaults in 12 hours or if the entire tri-party repo market fails? Those are not even remotely the same thing. I would be shocked to learn that Exxon mobile will go bankrupt in half a day because one bank has an outage. It would speak volumes to how piss-poor financial networks are architected. More realistically, JPM goes down and within an hour all of its large repo clients have already called BNY or whatever and are ready to go. Billion dollar businesses have contingency plans for headquarters being taken out by a bomb, you better believe they have a plan for their repo provider taking a shit. > Lovely Do you not see how ridiculous it is to suggest that the entire functioning US economy hinges on a single service run by a single company being available 24/7? If it were true, it would be a bigger terrorist target than the Whitehouse. Apparently the entire US economy is dependent on the uptime of the work of a few engineers at one company. Better hope that information doesn’t become public or else they will be prime targets for coercion, bribes, nation state level manipulation, etc. These engineers are literally more important than Congress to keep alive and working.