3 ms·
> The 42 electrons are not distinguishable simply because we don't normally choose to input any way of differentiating them, because we don't think it's useful.
by gus_massa 6y ago
> The 42 electrons are not distinguishable simply because we don't normally choose to input any way of differentiating them, because we don't think it's useful.
No, the electrons are truly undistinguishable, more specifically, they are fermions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermion
(If you want to be super technical, the best model we have for electrons assume they are indistinguishable. This model has very accurate predictions for the experimental results. And all the models that we have tried that assume that electrons are distinguishable make some predictions that are wrong, so we have to send them to the trash can.)
(And there are some extensions that are useful for high energy experiments, but in these extensions the electrons are even more indistinguishable.)
The main discussion here is that in spite the nuclei of Sodium and Chloride are also undistinguishable quantum objects, I say that in these conditions the can be perfectly approximated as distinguishable and with a classic movement.
This is a good approximation, except in some specific weird experiments that measure the diffraction pattern when a crystal is used as a mirror for a beam of neutrons or helium or even bigger atoms.
- WClayFerguson 6y agoWell said. And furthermore: Any quantum mechanical system (i.e. all systems) is ultimately just a vibrational pattern, so trying to assign persistent identities to "things" is impossible because it's like trying to label the peaks and troughs in some standing wave oscillating on some medium. The wave is a pattern only, and the peaks/troughs are merely emergent phenomena with no actual identities, that have a history or a future, other than at the exact time of some observation. My favorite philosophical thought experiment to ask people is: "Do football stadium waves actually exist or is it merely people in two states (standing/sitting)?" The answer to that question is a superposition of both Yes and No. lol. It sounds like a silly question, but it actually gets to the heart of the deepest philosophical questions Physics.