3 ms·
The Army Sergeant Major of the British Army is 'overweight', for example. The idea that he's unhealthy is an absolute joke. He's done an interview about this.
by chrisseaton 6y ago
The Army Sergeant Major of the British Army is 'overweight', for example. The idea that he's unhealthy is an absolute joke. He's done an interview about this.
- switchbak 6y agoThe BMI is radically oversimplified. I don't think any professional is surprised that well built athletic people fall outside the target audience for that metric. It really is just a ratio of weight to height, after all. Of course that's going to have its limitations.
- chrisseaton 6y agoSo why are we criticising 'overweight' people if we know it's a broken metric?
- ntsplnkv2 6y agoIt's confusing but let's be honest, we aren't talking about really fit body builders with muscle. We're talking about people with excess fat. Body fat % is a better metric, but you don't really need that if you're a doctor and can tell your patient has too much of it and the scale says so too.
- brongondwana 6y agoFor the same reason that people use Newtonian physics even though we all know it's a simplification which doesn't apply exactly to all situations. BMI is also obviously not going to work the same for an amputee, but it's an OK heuristic for most people.