4 ms·
Bitcoin was created by people who were so peeved at the regulator's interventions in the '08 crisis that they decided that bypassing the entire financial system
by roenxi 6y ago
Bitcoin was created by people who were so peeved at the regulator's interventions in the '08 crisis that they decided that bypassing the entire financial system was the best option. Forever immortalising "The Times 03/Jan/2009 Chancellor on brink of second bailout for banks" just as a reminder of why they were doing what they did [0].
We don't need better regulation. We need, when financial firms muck up on a global scale, to replace the people who run those firms with different people. There is an easy way to do that, let them go broke.
The biggest problem in the room is that the regulators have bought in to the idea that some companies are "too big to fail". That is a stupid idea, fundamentally unfair, completely throwing out the best part of capitalism which is that recognised idiots aren't allowed to be in charge. That problem will certainly not be solved by giving the regulators more power.
[0] https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Genesis_block https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Genesis_block
- arcticbull 6y agoBitcoin was most likely created by Paul Le Roux to launder money for his questionable business empire. The rest was just a flag to wrap around.
- ogogmad 6y agoWTF? Do you actually understand Bitcoin? BTC solved the problem of having concensus in a decentralised, distributed system without deferring to a dictator... Finding a way to do that was an open problem for decades. I used to think you had something intelligent to say about Bitcoin, but you've opened my eyes now.
- arcticbull 6y agoRight, yeah, just very incredibly super duper inefficiently. I don't disagree that wasting an entire country's worth of electricity is a novel and unique way of solving the byzantine generals problem up to 7 transactions per second. I just don't think it should be used in the real world, certainly not as a currency. I think it's worth separating my appreciation for Bitcoin in the strictest, most technical sense. I get it, it's neat, it's got that allure of being challenging and having many perceived potential use cases. It solved a legitimate hard problem. I think the tool is fascinating. I think the use cases though, just aren't. Apologies to have disappointed, though!
- petre 6y agoTrue that. Residents of Abkhazia (breakaway Georgian province on the Black Sea coast) were recently left in the dark because of bitcoin mining. https://www.rferl.org/a/bitcoin-blackouts-russian-cryptocurrency-miners-minting-millions-sucking-abkhazia-electricity-grid-dry/30968307.html https://www.rferl.org/a/bitcoin-blackouts-russian-cryptocurr...
- arcticbull 6y agoThe Iranians too, I think. [1] https://apnews.com/article/iran-media-social-media-bitcoin-coronavirus-pandemic-6d1c703a7faa1f85b0f94011259ec63e https://apnews.com/article/iran-media-social-media-bitcoin-c...
- alentist 6y ago> Although Bitcoin mining strains the power grid, experts say it’s not the real reason behind Iran’s electricity outages and dangerous air pollution. The telecommunications ministry estimates that Bitcoin consumes less than 2% of Iran’s total energy production.
- petre 6y agoYup, we totally trust government sources from Iran. It's usually decades of mismanagement + bitcoin + UH6 centrifuges used to create weapons grade uranium in their case. I've lived in the Eastern block, used to do homework at candle light so the regime could export goods under market price and earn hard currency. It's from the same playbook.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y ago"We need, when financial firms muck up on a global scale, to replace the people who run those firms with different people." I don't really disagree, but he with gold makes the rules. Attempting to limit their power will result in a backlash. Yellen's testimony can be seen as that, but in truth, it is not a new stance. Crypto was merely tolerated until now.
- FabHK 6y ago> "too big to fail" [...] is a stupid idea It's not that simple. When the government let Lehmann Brothers fail, all hell broke loose. That is the fundamental difficulty of financial regulation, moral hazard: You have to convincingly say that you won't bail out anyone, and then when things go awry, you have to bail them out. And that makes regulation and monitoring imperative. Well understood and studied.
- jl2718 6y agoWell if we had a stable store of value then we wouldn’t really care about the investment assets crashing. Force people into 401k and yeah, now we’re a helpless part of the machine.
- westurner 6y agoBitcoin was created in context to "Transparency and Accountability": a campaign motto not coincidentally found in the title of the "Federal Funding Accountability and Transparency Act of 2006". > The Federal Funding Accountability and Transparency Act of 2006 (S. 2590)[2] is an Act of Congress that requires the full disclosure to the public of all entities or organizations receiving federal funds beginning in fiscal year (FY) 2007. The website USAspending.gov opened in December 2007 as a result of the act Sen. Obama's office is the origin of this bill; which was fronted by Sens Coburn and McCain, who had the clout. https://usaspending.gov/ https://usaspending.gov/ creates a mandatory database with budgetary line item metadata. Where money actually goes is something that is far more transparent and accountable with bitcoin and other public ledgers than any existing ledger covered by bank secrecy laws. For context, in 2008-09, global financial systems were failing as a result of the American economy: housing bubble burst, HFT "flash crash" that we didn't have CAT or big data tools to determine the cause of, DDOS attacks and cyber security losses increasing YoY, credit default swaps had been rated as AAA securities (they sold bundled bad debt like it was worth something, and then wrote down losses), Enron energy speculation amidst rolling blackouts that were leaving hospitals in the dark, on gas generators, government investments in renewables had been paltry since the Carter administration had put solar panels on the roof of the White House before the whole oil price shock, and oil commodity speculation had driven the price of oil to like 2-4x the 2000 price (with resultant price effects on most CPI inflation/PPP basket goods); but electricity consumption was down in 2008 and renewables hadn't reached production volumes necessary to reach the competitive price point that renewables now present: cheaper than nonrenewables. Who would have thought that the speculative price would continue to exceed the production cost. incentives or penalties? Externalities per dollar returned per kWh is one way to assess the total costs of electricity production methods. "Buy Gold" was the refrain of the day: TV commercials, signs out in front of piano stores (a somewhat-arbitrary commodity, sales of which are observed to be a leading indicator of economic health), signs on the road. And the message was "take your money out the market and put it in gold" which drives up the prices for chips and boards and medical equipment that rely upon that commodity as a material input. Gold is necessary for tropical spec components in high-humidity environments: gold hinges are prized, for example. But, "look, there's water flowing from the chocolate fountain; so you can go ahead and go" and "you know you want to put it back in there, in that market" we're the appropriate messages given our revenue at the time.