4 ms·
How come Turkey is considered a country worthy of pondering about if and when to invite for EU-membership, while the same idea and attitude towards Russia Turk
by tokenadult 15y ago
How come Turkey is considered a country worthy of pondering about if and when to invite for EU-membership, while the same idea and attitude towards Russia
Turkey has been much more successful in maintaining multiparty democracy internally and peaceful cooperation externally with EU countries than Russia has been in the relevant time period. Turkey has its problems, and Turkey has yet to gain EU membership, but the distinction is meaningful to me (as an American who knows people here in the United States from both Russia and Turkey).
After edit: This may result, over the last century, from Kemal Atatürk being a much better statesman than Vladimir Lenin. It appears that Atatürk did a much better job of leading his country through the tough fall from having an imperialist system before World War I than Lenin did.
- asciilifeform 15y agoTurkey has been much more successful in maintaining multiparty democracy internally and peaceful cooperation externally with EU countries than Russia has been Translation: Turkey has been an obedient muppet state.
- kds 15y agoI might slightly agree with you to a certain extent, but with the strong exception that it is not meaningful to draw opinions on multi-million nations based on individual immigrants or expats. I'm from Bulgaria and, for example, one of the most incapable senior manager-expatriate I've ever saw in my country is British. I guess somebody in UK might have been really happy to have him overseas. But I don't hold this against the Brits ;) They are truly a great nation. On Turkey and EU - I can't say they deserve more or less the EU-membership. It's really a complex topic and AFAIK both France and Germany, have huge reservations. (BTW I don't think slogans about multiparty democracy really mean anything in the real geopolitical play between the world powers. Your own American experience shows that just two parties are enough and they are both at the mercy of the Federal Reserve - a private banking money-printing institution! - internally, and do more or less the same thing as international state policy, externally). It even might amuse you that Russia and Turkey currently are in very good international economic and political relations (despite some rethorics). Russia is building several! nuclear power reactors in Turkey and they enjoy also huge mutual benefitial trade in other sectors - construction industry, tourism, gas, agriculture, etc. However strange it might seem to you, actually Russia plays a certain interesting role in the modern economic development of Turkey. Things are just not black-and-white and defy simplistic explanations.
- kds 15y agoOn your Lenin-vs-Ataturk remark (in the after-edit): It's really an interesting line of thought to compare both leaders and draw some analogies - same historic time, post-imperial after-war revival and consolidation of the states, including massive social change, setting new economic policies, etc. But I find it dubious that there is a direct link between some comparatively superior statesmanship back then - even if there really was such, I don't know, to be frank - and Turkey's relatively recent economic upturn and regional political aspirations. (It is yet to be seen if Turkey's growth and development won't be just a temporary miracle - just like Ireland's or some other proclaimed "tiger"-economies.) And especially dubious it is in the perspective of the whole 20-th century. In those decades Russia gained such high points which Turkey can only dream about - just think the space/rocket sector as one example (back in the Gagarin's times, and also nowadays). The really state-wise thing Turkey did in the 20-th century is that they stayed out of the World War II that devastated the main rivals in continental Europe. Russia didn't have such a chance - they were invaded. After WWII Turkey was a strict American/US satellite, not so European-centric in its international politics, and, until recently, the US/NATO-backed Turkish chief-of-staff generals were the real guarantors for a seeming democracy. P.S. BTW, you can check the wikipedia page on Lenin's NEP (New Economic Policy) at en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Economic_Policy. From it is clear that originally socialism/communism wasn't entirely hostile to private businesses and entrepreneurship - this had its fine economic policy results at the time when Lenin was still in charge.