7 ms·
People have odd expectations that their new neighborhoods should fit them and not the other way around. I’m reminded of a situation in New York City where a cou
by bobthepanda 6y ago
People have odd expectations that their new neighborhoods should fit them and not the other way around. I’m reminded of a situation in New York City where a couple moved into a fancy new apartment building next to an active train yard and then proceeded to sue for noise because the train yard was 24/7.
Do due diligence before picking a place to live, folks.
- kayodelycaon 6y ago> then proceeded to sue for noise Oh that’s going to go over well. Some people in my neighborhood tried suing and now we have every train blowing their horns through this entire section of the city. A dozen times a day and many of those at night. It’s hard for me to not laugh at my neighbors every time it happens.
- lisper 6y agoUnfortunately, the same thing also happens around small airports, and there the NIMBYs-come-lately often prevail. https://www.bjtonline.com/business-jet-news/runway-removal-to-commence-in-santa-monica https://www.bjtonline.com/business-jet-news/runway-removal-t...
- Symbiote 6y agoThe opposite also happens: the approach to London Heathrow gives wonderful views over London, but at least a million people suffer from more-or-less constant aircraft noise and pollution, except for a few hours overnight. Further expansion was approved in 2018, when one of the local MPs — Boris Johnson, who had promised to "lie down in front of bulldozers" to prevent expansion — was conveniently on a trip abroad during the vote it Parliament. (The areas of London overflown are a mix of wealthy, average and poor-ish, left-voting and right-voting, it's far too large an area to wave away as X group of people complaining.)
- JJMcJ 6y agoIn Bay Area, every time approaches to our three busy airports are changed there is a lot of bellyaching, mostly from rich areas like Saratoga and Woodside. Usually summarized by "Why don't you fly over those places were poor people live?" Made worse because well off areas tend to be in the hills, and so planes are lower over the ground.
- dmckeon 6y agoMuch of the recent complaining is due to concentration of near-ground routes as a side-effect of the NextGen routing system. http://soseastbay.org/jet-noise-in-a-nutshell-nexgen/ http://soseastbay.org/jet-noise-in-a-nutshell-nexgen/ https://www.faa.gov/nextgen/faqs/ https://www.faa.gov/nextgen/faqs/
- therockspush 6y agoThe sad part is NextGen was supposed to allow planes to approach at higher altitudes and descend with engines idled to reduce noise.
- Veen 6y agoThe Government won that vote with a majority of nearly 300. Johnson’s absence didn’t make the slightest difference to the outcome.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoI have a commuter line next to me with a station 1000 ft. away. The early morning trains mute their horns and it's not very noticeable. With freight, I wouldn't expect them to bother but the FRA does allow for quiet trains.
- kayodelycaon 6y agoI'm 240 ft from a freight line. :)
- recursive 6y agoReminds me of the slow downfall of the Laguna Seca race track. https://jalopnik.com/the-absurd-community-fight-that-could-cripple-one-of-am-1736668909 https://jalopnik.com/the-absurd-community-fight-that-could-c... Short version: People move in next to an established race track and learn they don't like the sound of race tracks. You'll be shocked at what happens next!
- randompwd 6y agoAre you being purposefully misleading? People moved in and then the race track tried to get noise restrictions from the 1950s changed to benefit them.(increasing no-muffler days(wtf?) and opening race course on sunday) From your linked propaganda piece: > restrictions on use set in the 1950s. I'd be heavily on side of people wanting a peaceful place to live than to cater to ignorant arseholes who don't want to use mufflers cos they like the sound it makes.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoUnfortunately, this often a necessity strategy in the US legal system, where you have to exercise your rights to maintain them. This could’ve been advised directly from their legal team. If you build a raceway with the expectation of being able to scale usage based on demand and need,End it appears that this is coming into jeopardy, they need to scale up sooner to establish president as more people move in. There is a similar problem with farm water usage where farmers are incentivized to waste water due to a use it or lose it legal situation
- JJMcJ 6y agoBig difference between race tracks, which are entertainment, and farming, which is where our food comes from.
- recursive 6y agoIf your definition of a peaceful place to live includes not hearing a race track, I can think of a few better strategies than moving in next to a race track.
- 6y ago
- vmception 6y agoHudson Yards? Because I was always wondering how that would go
- bobthepanda 6y agoSunnyside. Hudson Yards completely caps the yard over with buildings so I don’t think you can hear it at all.
- vmception 6y agoAnother exhibit in the irresistible allure of Manhattan
- gambiting 6y agoTbf, what also sometimes happens is that you move somewhere, discover that a local business is breaking noise pollution regulations, but when you complain you are met with aggression because "it has always been like this, you should have done your research". And maybe that's true, but we have laws about some of this stuff for a reason - if they are being broken then I don't see problem with complaining.
- bobthepanda 6y agoThat would imply the regulations are right, correct, and made with diverse public input to represent all views.
- gambiting 6y agoBut I mean, what kind of the start to discussion is this. Should I not report a burglary either, since maybe the laws dealing with burglars fail to take into account someone's difficult life situation and don't reflect the diverse views of our citizens on the subject of non violent crime and punishments associated with it? Like, if I move somewhere where I know that the noise regulations mandate low noise after 10pm and there's a pub making a racket at midnight, of course I'm going to report it, the fact that it's been there for 200 years is literally completely irrelevant.
- bobthepanda 6y agoOr, at least in the parent article, the regulations were found to be nonsense, and so a law was passed to revise them. Lots of well meaning laws have unintended consequences. A large contributing factor to out-of-control Californian wildfires was that prescribed fires to thin the amount of combustible material were often stopped by the air quality board.
- Blikkentrekker 6y agoIt is more so that if a country have maximum sound regulations, then either the law should define exceptions for certain animals, and if it do not, it should be treated the same. I would assume there are certain maximum sound volume regulations in France as they exist in many places. “tradition” is all too commonly used as an argument to break the law. I do not believe it should play a factor at all whether something happened in the past, merely whether it violate the law. If France have nationwide rules about sound levels and the rooster exceeded them, then that is all the diligence a man needs to have done. One may certainly expect that the government upholds the law uniformly throughout one's country.
- bobthepanda 6y agoThat would imply a law is always absolutely correct. A legal system is ultimately made by humans who are fallible. And laws, particularly in the US, are usually created by one wealth/social class of people, and historically not made without diverse public input. I don't really care for holding such strict interpretations of law in high regard. It's not as if France doesn't have issues with perceived political elitism, given the existence of the yellow vests.
- Blikkentrekker 6y agoCertainly the power to decide whether laws are “correct” in a specific, rather than general sense is far too much power for any one party to have? If laws could be so easily ignored, we might as well do away with them.
- polishdude20 6y agoThere's another aide of this coin which is also important. There's that whole urbanism movement which is all about making our town and cities more suited to humans. Making the streets more walkable, reducing traffic, increasing bike infrastructure, increasing green spaces. These are all things that people have the right to request in a big city because it makes living there better for everyone.
- bobthepanda 6y agoAnd where does the freight in a big city come from? It doesn't just teleport in. Freight trains are probably the least bad way for freight to enter a city, given their efficiency and relative greenness. But they do need to be unloaded, maintained, and turned around somewhere, and wherever that is going to happen is going to be noisy.
- dbspin 6y agoThis is an argument against zoning residential properties near freight yards, airports etc. Not a criticism of making cities more livable. No one should have to tolerate that level of noise pollution. It's actively hazardous to mental health.
- bobthepanda 6y agoOne could also do due diligence when looking for residential property to live in. The neighborhood in question has 1 bedrooms starting at $2.6k a month, even after COVID depressed rental prices. People are by no means being forced to live there because they have no place left to go.
- xvedejas 6y agoWell, because of NIMBYism, most US cities can only legally build urban housing in industrial or formerly industrial areas that lack mobilized neighborhood associations. So we're going in the opposite direction, thanks in part to zoning.
- jrockway 6y ago
- jariel 6y agoNoise pollution is a real thing. All of our industrial equipment should be designed with this in mind. Back up beepers are considerably louder than they need to be. Weirdly, the police sirens in Germany towns like Frankfurt are incessant - it's a very piercing sound, they use them often, all day long, and the sound bounces through the walls of the town which is 5 stories everywhere and narrow streets. In a North American city you rarely actually hear sirens - maybe for firetrucks. The low hum of gasonline engines really adds up, the electrics are so much nicer that way but I fear accidents.
- zip1234 6y agoNoise from vehicles in North America is incessant and pretty much not regulated/enforced whatsoever. Even electric vehicles are just as loud at speeds greater than about ~30 mph. You can hear it all hours of the day if you are within several miles of an interstate.
- bobthepanda 6y agoAbove a certain speed the main sounds you're hearing are tires against the road surface. At low speeds engine noise and braking are predominant, and the former for electric is actually a problem because people are used to hearing the sound of ICE cars when judging to cross the street. The worst bit is that sound walls, at least the ones deployed in America, do not even really fix the problem, because they can reflect sound (so they may reduce immediate area noise but increase it farther away). You would probably want something pretty much like a tunnel.
- chrisbolt 6y ago> Back up beepers are considerably louder than they need to be. Tom Scott has a fascinating video that describes how this is changing: https://youtu.be/fa28lIGuxq8 https://youtu.be/fa28lIGuxq8
- ABCLAW 6y agoThe law of nuisance isn't about 'people fitting each other'. It's about securing the rights of property holders. If someone is running a train yard and hasn't obtained encumbrances on surrounding properties to allow for permitted noise, that's on them. Do your due diligence when developing industrial properties, folks.
- rektide 6y ago> Do due diligence before picking a place to live, folks. Frankly houses for sale & rent should come with a sound recording of the last two weeks of use Dilligence is hard as heck; who knows if there's som neighbor that habitually does carpentry at 2AM or whose dog goes apeshit a couple times a week or a delivery service va blasting it's noisemaker at 5AM. I agree about doing due diligence but a lot is hard to account for. We are so much at the mercy of the outside world. Maybe the neighbors AC sucks & reverbs something wicked. How would a winter home buyer find that out? Or maybe it's the heater that's a problem. And it just doesn't feel like we're in a world where people tend to be open to working together to improve things.
- crazygringo 6y ago> Do due diligence before picking a place to live, folks. Honestly, aside from a few obvious things, "due diligence" is often pretty much impossible. If you move into an apartment in the winter, there's zero way of knowing that teens like to blare window-shakingly loud music in the park across the street every other day in the summer. Or that the seemingly innocuous speed bump in front of your building will cause the 10's of garbage trucks that race by at maximum speed at 2 am each night to rattle and bump with such a force that each one wakes you up. Or that a month after you move in, you get a new neighbor next door who blares bass-thumping music all day long while you're trying to work. Or that the building next door starts to undergo gut renovation and welcome to jackhammering all day long. Except for super-obvious stuff like is this a street with noisy bars/clubs, or yeah an active train yard -- which isn't even "due diligence" it's just keeping your eyes open -- there really isn't much you can do ahead of time. You just have to accept it'll always be a gamble.