5 ms·
“Our Marketing Is Up Fog Creek” And What We Did About It
- jonknee 15y agoResults coming soon I hope?
- patio11 15y agoThere are a couple of specific results mentioned in that post. If you're wondering about specific "Did it make them money and, if so, how much?", the answers are "Yes" and "Fog Creek is owned by the Creekers, and like most privately held companies they don't share revenue numbers." But if you're trying to guess how sore the marketing team's hands are from high-fives at the moment, here's an easy math exercise: make a guess as to how many digits of sales FogBugz makes in a year. Pick a number for a single successful A/B test -- I suggest 5% for this one. Multiply.
- jonknee 15y agoWasn't looking for revenue, but relative figures. Converting 2x over previous site, 30% longer sessions, 50% less bounce visits etc.
- patio11 15y agoLonger sessions and less bounces don't really matter to us. (They strike me as easy to measure but of limited business utility. I can do a lot of things to make your session longer -- re-bork navigation, for example. That won't make folks terribly happy, either our customers or other Creekers.) Conversions are much more interesting. Unfortunately, that gets into the sensitive territory. There's at least three levels, right: how many more trials are we getting? How many more trials are we converting into paying customers at the end of day 45? How many users do those customers add (FB is priced on a per-user basis, so an account with 50 users is worth 10 accounts with 5)? Then of course there is the churn/LTV question. We're obviously quite interested in these numbers. I don't know how much I can tell you about them specifically. How's about this: I wanted to increase trials by 90%. FC would have been happy with 10%. Actual results as of now are somewhere between those two numbers. Please don't binary search me in that range. The subsequent actions are also up, and we won't know about LTV/churn for quite a while yet, but early indications are good.
- jonknee 15y agoI am interested in lesser popular stats like session time and bounces because it sheds some light on conversion differences. If you increase conversion and decrease session time that means you have succeeded in getting out of the way of people who want to give you money. If you increase conversion and increase session time it's for a different reason (maybe you weren't providing enough info before). Same for bounces--is the new higher conversion figure due to enticing people who previously bounced or are you doing a better job at hooking in people who were already more interested? I could go on, but I'm already rambling. Regardless, great write up. I found it interesting and useful.
- patio11 15y agoHideho everybody. I hope you like it. If you have any questions, I'm happy to answer anything that doesn't breach a confidence with them. We're also going to be publishing a lot of good stuff in the coming months, so if there is a particular topic you'd love to see covered, we'd love your feedback.
- spydez 15y agoToday I learned patio11 does design consulting, and is not just the bingo card guy. Interesting article. Thanks (to both you and Fog Creek) for writing it up!
- acangiano 15y agoI respect patio11, but his bingo card earnings are far from impressive. What's impressive is the process he developed to optimize his earnings in a relatively small B2C market. That knowledge and expertise, along with the fame he earned by sharing them, is his most valuable asset. It just makes sense to capitalize on it with consulting gigs.
- JonnieCache 15y ago>I respect patio11, but his bingo card earnings are far from impressive. That depends where you're standing.
- jng 15y agoWith regards to selling software online, they are on the low end of the scale. His methods and communication are definitely top of the scale though.
- rockncode 15y agoIf you can earn 25k a year from a simple bingo app, put together a few more similar apps, then you have a decent salary. And so what if you think if his bingo earnings are far from impressive. That first sentence was unnecessary.
- tptacek 15y agoDo you generally think --- gut take --- that a video of the founder on the front page (kind of costly to make, timewise) will perform well? Or is Spolsky just that kind of magnetic?
- jonknee 15y ago"It ROFLstomps everything else we’ve tried there. We tried short videos, we tried screencasts, we tried images — in A/B test after A/B test, our users said Give Us More Joel."
- patio11 15y agoGut take? If you had told me "We're an enterprise software company and a 3 minute video on our front page did really well, outperforming text and static images.", I'd say "I'll buy that." The hour long video killing it? That surprises me. This was one of a couple results where data said everything I know is wrong. We'll iterate further on it. One of the challenges is that you can swap out text as quickly as I can write it and you can get an image crafted in a day, but doing a new video is a Project with a capital P.
- jamiequint 15y agoI'd be interested in hearing what you mean here by the video performed better, in terms of conversion to clicking the trial button, conversion to signup for the trial, conversion to becoming a paid user? Are you tracking results all the way down the funnel or just to the next step you have chosen?
- patio11 15y agoTypically the team either tracks clicking the trial or actually starting the trial. We track stuff all the way through. Over the last couple of months of A/B testing, they've noted that the conversion rate of the trial page is not extraordinarily sensitive to A/B tests in progress before that page, so often we use "opened the page" as a proxy for "started a trial" because it gets results weeks faster. (BCC uses trials and not sales as the conversion of interest for much the same reason.)
- wccrawford 15y ago"You can also see that the See Pricing link attracts more people than the free trial button, possibly because the free trial isn’t identified as being free." Or possibly because the free trial is pointless if you can't afford to pay for the real thing after it ends. I absolutely will not start a free trial for a product I don't know the price of.
- tptacek 15y agoI'll add the data point that I think this way too; the pricing is more important than the free trial, to me, as part of the process for acquiring software. This may be one of those things though where normal people see the word "free", go "oooh lollipops!" and click.
- p4as 15y agoThis is so true, software sites that invite you to call, just so you can get some idiot to tell you about their "value proposition" and discuss your "licensing estate" really get my goat.
- tptacek 15y agoWell. Goat or no goat, for many software companies, this is the right decision; a salesperson will do a better job of closing an enterprise sale than a web page will, especially when the web page invites prospects to disqualify themselves because of their immediate reaction to pricing.
- gjm11 15y agoPeople investigating bug-tracking software may well not be "normal people" in the relevant sense. (Count me into the "will not try until I know the cost of saying yes" pigeonhole, too.)
- kayhi 15y agoGood point, perhaps combine the free trial with the pricing page like Skype does http://www.skype.com/intl/en-us/prices/ http://www.skype.com/intl/en-us/prices/
- pitdesi 15y agoIt's amazing that a one hour video performed best. I get that people want to click on it more, and it IS obvious that putting a big play button would lead to more views... but how far do they get and how does it impact conversion etc?
- mhp 15y agoHere's the hotspot info. It's kind of interesting. It is above average for longer than I thought it would be: http://i.imgur.com/KGPg0.png http://i.imgur.com/KGPg0.png
- euroclydon 15y agoI saw that same graph on Khan's FAQ today. He was explaining that if there's a lull in the video, then he works to make it more interesting at that point, until the lull goes away. How do you get that data?
- mhp 15y agoYoutube gives it to you for free but you have to have enough views. It's under "Insights" on the video and then "Hotspots".
- michaelrlitt 15y agoWe're working on a product that will be able to give you this data regardless of number of views. Ping me if you'd like more info or an early access account!
- jsdalton 15y agoIs that Balsamiq you're using for mockups?
- mhp 15y agoYep: http://balsamiq.com/products/mockups/fogbugz http://balsamiq.com/products/mockups/fogbugz
- mashmac2 15y ago"Our Page Load Speed Is Up Fog Creek" And How HN Has A Slashdot Effect
- mhp 15y agoYup, looks like Wordpress just fell over. Restarting...
- mkr-hn 15y agoWhat caching plugin do you use?
- mhp 15y agoI think its WP Super Cache
- mkr-hn 15y agoHave you looked into W3 Total Cache? I've heard it's quite a bit better at handling heavy traffic. I've never gotten enough hits to see, but it's worth testing.
- mhp 15y agoWe believe the problem is actually Keep-Alives on Apache plus the cache. Keep-alives are now off. Cache on. Everything seems peachy.
- patio11 15y agoThe cause was... wait for it... Apache KeepAlive. For more details, searchyc.com for [patio11 keepalive]. It kills more blogs than cancer. I should start a How To Make Sure Your Blog Does Not Die Horribly consulting business. And it will consist of disabling Apache KeepAlive, and then chanting arcane incantations in Latin about caching for the next hour to make people feel like they were really getting their money's worth.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- portman 15y agoI'll be interested to see a longitudinal study in 6-12 months. FogBugz is a complex B2B product fueled by recurring revenue (either subscriptions or maintenance). It's not diet pills or a self-help book. Most (all?) companies find that the long-form, "Tim-Ferris-style" landing page converts better for impulse sales. But does that work well for non-consumer products? My fear would be that if you 2x or 3x the top of the funnel with landing page optimizations, you run the risk of attracting the wrong kind of customers. Customers who initially signup and pay, but don't become long-term repeat customers at the same ratio as those who converted on the old landing page. I would be curious, Patrick, if you're planning on looking at the lifetime value of these conversions, or if the scope of your project with Fog Creek was limited to lifting the number of initial installs. (Oh, and like everyone else said: great job, great writeup, and thanks for sharing!)
- ssharp 15y agoIt would seem pretty counterproductive for a web business that counts on repeat revenues--and even more so for a company with a monthly recurring revenue model--to not optimize CLV in favor of optimizing for short-term gains. Even if Patrick's work was a one-off deal, I'd hope FogCreek will be measuring lifetime value of these conversions vs. old customers.
- jkuria 15y agoaccording to the old school copywriters like Dan Kennedy who has also done lots of B2B work, "Tim-Ferris-Sytle" landing pages (also known as long form sales letters) work just as well in the B2B space (selling software, fax machines and high end office equiptment). The problem is that most companies selling who would benefit from the tried and true techniques from direct marketing are 'image conscious' and would rather have a feel good corporate speak landing page with a meaningless slogan like 'ideas for life' or some such!
- spenrose 15y agoFog Creek's marketing has always seemed to me to center on Joelonsoftware.com, and then Stack Overflow, and also posts like this one. Unless I'm missing something we are part of the target market. Now, I don't have a problem with that, but it makes me read posts like this one (and this one: http://www.joelonsoftware.com/items/2007/11/16.html http://www.joelonsoftware.com/items/2007/11/16.html) a bit differently.
- patio11 15y agoYou're missing something, but it's subtle. If you're reading this, you probably will never give FogCreek a dollar. That's the hard truth of the matter. We literally give the product away to startups (Student and Startup Edition, free forever for 2 users) because a) in aggregate startups demonstrably don't spend appreciable amounts of money on this, often preferring OSS or "we can totally duplicate that 100 man-years of development in a weekend" and b) dedicated effort at making sales to you doesn't make any sense relative to dedicated effort at selling 20 seats to an insurance company in Idaho. But do we care about the community liking us? Oh heck yes. The average reader of HN is very link rich relative to e.g. the project manager for the IT team at an insurance company in Idaho. Producing stuff which you like enough to link to gets us higher on the Googles and thus into the line of vision of people who can spend more money on bug tracking than many startups spend on everything. Similarly, if you feel good things about us, you might recommend us internally to someone who has ability to make decisions about which product to purchase.
- fmavituna 15y agoGiving it free to startups is not just "good faith" or "do good", "hire better" etc. it's getting user hooked up to the software, long term investment and almost free word-of-mouth marketing. FC knows that FB is a tool that will show itself after a long time (hence 45 day) trials. When we start using FB our company was only 2 people now we are 9 and also we are a paid customer of FB. For these reasons I don't want to believe that FC is not using channels like SO,Joel's blog as a marketing tool. That would be a waste of awesome free marketing.
- GFischer 15y ago
- m_myers 15y agoWow. So much practical advice in there. I'd heard much of it before, of course, but seeing it in action really helps cement it. I may have to read it again to make sure I caught everything.
- switch007 15y ago"Trusted by 20,000 organizations" - seriously? That is staggeringly amazing. Does that really mean 20,000 are using FogBugz daily? Edit: I guess it could also be 'trusted' in the past tense.
- ZoFreX 15y agoIt isn't really as compelling in the past tense - e.g. 'Sony: Trusted by 70,000,000 users'.
- pchivers 15y agoI think there is a spelling mistake in the article: "That worked very well for many years, but recently it hasn’t been the slam dunk it has been in the best." Should this be, "it hasn’t been the slam dunk it has been in the past"?
- dlevine 15y agoThe funny thing is that they just ripped off 37 signals' marketing page. Not to say that this strategy won't work - just that the "redesign" involved some heavy borrowing. I recognized it because I just used 37 signals' page as the basis for a marketing page on my own site.
- lhnn 15y agoAre there recommended books for web design? "Funnel" is a foreign concept to me.
- js2 15y agoFunnel refers to the http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sales_process http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sales_process
- jacques_chester 15y agoDrat, beaten to it. This is what I get for replying to 20-minute old copies of a page.
- jacques_chester 15y agoThe funnel here is the sales funnel. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sales_process http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sales_process
- 2mur 15y agoGreat write up Patrick! I know that you are a rails guy and they use an MS stack. Any friction there? Were they able to use your A/B framework or did they have something on their own stack? Edit: Nevermind: http://blog.fogcreek.com/how-to-do-ab-testing-using-google-website-optimizer/ http://blog.fogcreek.com/how-to-do-ab-testing-using-google-w...
- patio11 15y agoWe don't use Google Website Optimizer, which I won't recommend to anyone. We're using a .NET framework that I won't name because we're probably going to transition off of it. I enjoy Rails a lot more than I enjoy .NET, but give me some credit: looking at new languages doesn't cause my brain to throw a WTFCodeIsCamelCasedException. By the way, Fog Creek isn't strictly a MS shop. There is a lot of "best tool for the job" going on, including e.g. Python being used as utility glue.
- 2mur 15y agoThanks for the clarification.
- rorrr 15y agoLooking at the heatmap, "Pricing" and "Features" are your most clickable menu items. For some reason you completely ignored it and put "Pricing" all the way to the right, where 10% of the visitors can't even see it. You don't need a "home" link in the menu, that's what the logo is for. Your menu should look like this: Pricing | Features | Plugins | Support | other crap nobody ever sees Then your most important money-making link-button "Try FogBugs" is below the fold for at least 30% of your visitors. I think you really need to look at this and understand what it means: http://browsersize.googlelabs.com/ http://browsersize.googlelabs.com/ You might even want to display pricing right there on the main page.
- encoderer 15y agoA very quick, no-research, gut reaction I just had to your comment was that the numbers you throw out -- "30% of your visitors" -- assume that the demographics of their visitors are inline with the demographics of the internet as a whole. They're selling developer tools, that changes things. And all that is part of your suggestion of "understanding what it means."
- pbz 15y agoNot sure if know/care but the fonts you use look really bad when ClearType is not enabled: http://i.imgur.com/VmCR0.png http://i.imgur.com/VmCR0.png Looks OK in IE though.
- famousactress 15y agoI think Patrick is an amazing argument for bootstrapped entrepreneurship in a way that I haven't really heard mentioned enough... The freshness of perspective that comes from an incredibly bright person of one field (in this case development) thrust into other roles (marketing, sales, web production) seems awesome fuel for innovation and new thinking. Thrilled with the article, and I think like many on HN thrilled to see patio11 killing it. Cheers, Patrick.
- brown9-2 15y agoDoes anyone know in what capacity Microsoft is using FogBugz?
- spaznode 15y agoI've used fogbugz, can't say I was very impressed with the product. Maybe they need to spend more time on that and the product will market itself. Seriously, this is a great example of the wrong way to view a product.
- choxi 15y agoi thought this was a pretty mediocre post, it just had a few tips about how to improve your landing pages (pretty well-known ones too). I'm calling shenanigans on the 352 votes, but I'm all ears to anyone who can explain why i'm wrong and what I missed.
- StuffMaster 15y agoIn my opinion software homepages should look somewhat like wikipedia pages. Any software that tells me how awesome it is before explaining what it is quickly loses my interest. And using a grid with images in place of a list really annoys me.