2 ms·
I doubt it. The only place where I see blockchains in significant practical use is in very low-trust cases. But supply-chain relationships already involve a fai
by wpietri 6y ago
I doubt it. The only place where I see blockchains in significant practical use is in very low-trust cases. But supply-chain relationships already involve a fair bit of trust. Cryptocurrencies are also attempts to solve problems of financial interaction, but these people already have financial relationships.
Moreover, I think one of the big problems with "blockchain [jazz hands]" is what you're doing here: a solution looking for a problem. The right way to build something is to start with actual problems actual people have and then find the most economically efficient technology that best fits the solution. When approached from that perspective, I still haven't heard of a case where a blockchain turned out to be the right answer.
- coderintherye 6y agoWilliam, while I agree the problem at hand is mainly an organizational one, you ignore that even with a trusted environment you still need safeguards for internal fraud. A distributed ledger can ensure that protection and easily verifiable audits. The distributed ledger solves this real problem, but with the caveat that as you noted that is a fairly small part of the overall picture.
- wpietri 6y agoYou're also doing it. I agree that a distributed ledger could under very specific circumstances protect against some very specific types of internal fraud. But again, that's the wrong way to look at it. The way to do it is to look at actual fraud problems that businesses are actually having and then see what measures, technological and otherwise, best mitigate the problem. Even if the fraud in question was of the very specific type where somebody fiddles records after the initial write (as opposed to fiddling them before, or on output, or making offsetting transactions, or any of the many other ways to hide internal fraud) I still wouldn't try to set up some sort of multi-organizational distributed blockchain ledger. I'd just write a regular ledger to some immutable medium. E.g., AWS's WORM solution. [1] That would not only be simpler, clearer, cheaper, and more thoroughly vetted, it would also be very easy to prove compliance with the sorts of standards used to prevent fraud. [1] https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/storage/protecting-data-with-amazon-s3-object-lock/ https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/storage/protecting-data-with-am...