2 ms·
There’s some element of fear as embodied in the aviation regulations. There’s not as much fear in the owner/pilot population, in large part because of those re
by sokoloff 6y ago
There’s some element of fear as embodied in the aviation regulations.
There’s not as much fear in the owner/pilot population, in large part because of those regulations. If any of the 100UL candidates pass certification, it’s a fair bet that they’ll be safe and I’ll have no concern with flying on them.
The real issue is that while you can suffer a 10% power or energy-density reduction (such as from alcohol displacing gasoline in the fuel) in an automotive application without any appreciable loss of safety and minimal loss of functionality, the same is not true for aircraft. Piston aircraft takeoffs are always* done at maximum available power and a 10% loss of power is cause for an abort.
So it’s unlikely that a fuel with materially worse performance would be certified.
* - There were some extremely old multi-engine transports which had tables for reduced power takeoffs and some pilots mistakenly do them today, but the overwhelming practice is 100% of available.
- labawi 6y agoMaximum power takeoff seems reasonable, and unexpected 10% power loss would be a very good reason to abort, but I don't see why you couldn't trade (stable and safe) 10% power for 10% runway and clearance, maybe some weight, altitude .. You would need to reassess and update your tables, so regulations and certification are a big issue, but I don't understand why would it be technically unrealisable. Half a century after we know it's harmful seems a long time to stop spewing lead all over the place.
- sokoloff 6y agoLegally, you would have to do certification tests on every airplane type again. A 10% loss of power would require much more than 10% increase in runway for a given weight. Further, a 10% loss of energy density would require heavier takeoff weights for any given trip, meaning the penalty is further increased. I’m already weight-limited (either by certification limits or runway performance) on some flights. I carry about equal mass of fuel and people on trips with the whole family aboard. I’m not crying about it and I hope to see a viable 100UL emerge, but a 10% loss on two variables in the fuel would result in a lot more than “just use an extra 300 feet of takeoff roll and she’ll be a’ight”.
- jdashg 6y agoTakeoff is done at max power as best practice, not because it's physically strictly required power for lift-off. Yes you'd need to reduce weight tables and friends, but a certified detuning is totally possible, even if an in-the-field loss of power is cause for grounding.
- sokoloff 6y agoA certified detuning is indeed theoretically possible, at the expense of having to re-flight test the airplane to determine and prove the new performance tables as part of the STC for that fuel, which any new fuel vendor will likely find to be a prohibitive barrier to sell the fuel to the public. The "all models STC" approach with a "no degradation in performance" judgment is much more desirable for the fuel vendor seeking to sell the fuel, for the FBO who only wants to sell one version of avgas and one mix of Jet fuel, and for the owners of heavy piston-powered airplanes and therefore more likely to succeed (IMO).