14 ms·
For any non-Brits, the SWP is the main left of Labour party in Britain. As a student in the 80s I remember them as an earnest, way too serious bunch of ideologi
by simonh 6y ago
For any non-Brits, the SWP is the main left of Labour party in Britain. As a student in the 80s I remember them as an earnest, way too serious bunch of ideological zombies ranting into microphones at the Student's Union about the latest crimes against humanity perpetrated by 'Thatcher'. They're the kind of people that come up to you in the street with leaflets about some atrocity in Africa and shout "Would you murder children" at you. I'm not entirely sure they'd recognise what an actual 'Worker' was if they met one. I always found them quite comical.
However they are a serious party, they're a highly motivated and active movement with significant influence in the Labour Party grass roots. They're sort of our equivalent of Antifa in that they are a significant organising presence in lefty street protests, but much more politically active and spend a lot of time in conferences and action committees wondering what Capitalism ever did for us.
Importantly, they are in no way shape or form a terrorist or criminal organisation. I would not be at all surprised if some ultra-violent or would-be Red Army Faction types joined or associated with them, but that's not at all who the SWP are as an organisation. They're the well meaning, impressionable white middle class girl next door with a class guilt complex and a side shave that's been going to BLM protests.
If they are getting banned by Facebook something has gone horribly wrong. Quite possibly some of them got a bit excited and posted things they shouldn't, so I'm not saying this is for sure Facebook's fault, but they're not about to murder any bobbies in Parliament Square.
- Emma_Goldman 6y agoYou are over-stating the significance of the SWP. Maybe what you say is true of the 80s, but it isn't today. They are not the main party to the left of Labour, the greens are. The greens have 50,000 members and received 850,000 votes in the 2019 election, the SWP has a few thousand members and does not even field candidates. In my experience they have little influence on the Labour grassroots. The SWP's standing among young, idealistic socialists exploded after it emerged that its central committee covered up a series of rape cases in the party. That was in 2013. I have not met anyone who takes them seriously since. After Corbyn was elected many who would have joined the SWP in the past joined Momentum instead. I am shocked that Facebook have banned the SWP. Their faults are something more like a religion - centralised, deluded, outdated. They have no criminal or terroristic aspirations. What kind of precedent does this set?
- simonh 6y agoI'm sure you're right. I'm well on the way to being outdated myself.
- kjjw 6y agoYeah it really sounds like it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Veen 6y agoGiven your username, I'm curious. Are there many left anarchist activists in the UK at the moment? I had some tenuous contact with the ACF in the late-90s, but it doesn't seem a very active or impactful part of the political landscape.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoMany? No. There was a very concerted and covert anti-left push during the 80s and 90s. Anti-establishment groups of all kinds - anti-nuclear protesters, greens, animal rights activists, and official far left groups like the SWP - were infiltrated by undercover police and sometimes subverted. It's an ongoing scandal, although it's been lost in the noise from other events over the last year or two. Undercover police with fake identities had relationships with activists and sometimes fathered children with them. In some cases they worked internationally and were responsible for criminal acts (i.e. terrorism) which discredited the organisations and movements they infiltrated. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UK_undercover_policing_relationships_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UK_undercover_policing_relatio... It's hard not to suspect the apologies are disingenuous. The plan was to subvert, marginalise, and discredit left wing views, and to destroy left wing organisations of all kinds. And it seems to have been very successful.
- KaiserPro 6y ago> Undercover police with fake identities had relationships with activists and sometimes fathered children with them. whilst I suspect this happened in the 80s as well, the actual case that was prosecuted was from the early 2000s > were responsible for criminal acts (i.e. terrorism) which discredited the organisations and movements they infiltrated. Our dealings with the unionists in NI are a particular dark stain. Now sadly legalised by this new intelligence bill. (simplification, but its not a good bill.) > destroy left wing organisations of all kinds. Much as this is nice to believe, having worked in a number of left wing organisations, they are perfectly capable of imploding by them selves. It appears that they attract a certain kind of idiot, who is exceptionally well adapted at persuading other middle-class idiots that black is blue. Right-wing organisations also implode, but in a different way. Ironically they tend to have more "real" working class people in them too.
- cm2187 6y agoAntifa isn’t exactly a peaceful movement, I am not sure it is the best comparison.
- CalChris 6y agoAntifa does exactly what it says on the tin.
- pjc50 6y ago"Antifa" is more of a self applied label; you can certainly see antifa logos at demos. The SWP are Trotskyist, in the sense of "March through the institutions". If you're doing anything left wing they will turn up and try to make it about them, take over organization positions, etc. The SWP are mostly your boring old lefty uncle, with a side of institutional rape apologia: https://www.gender-agenda.org.uk/not-my-comrades-on-dealing-with-the-swp/ https://www.gender-agenda.org.uk/not-my-comrades-on-dealing-... (this is not only their problem, it can happen in any organization that doesn't take active steps to avoid it) I suppose the canary for partisan moderation should be Sinn Fein; they were banned from television in the 90s.
- multjoy 6y agoSinn Fein had literal terrorists as members and were proscribed by government. This is the exact opposite of what has been seen in relation to the deplatforming on social media sites.
- jjgreen 6y agoSinn Fein were never proscribed, they were the political wing of the Provisional IRA (which very-much was proscribed), but were never illegal themselves. This makes sense for both sides, to keep lines of communication open.
- angry_octet 6y agoThe UK Govt at one point passed legislation that meant Sinn Fein voices could not be broadcast. This was circumvented by having the words repeated exactly in sync with the vision by a voice actor. You have to wonder if the current BBC would have the gumption to circumvent it. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1988%E2%80%931994_British_broadcasting_voice_restrictions https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1988%E2%80%931994_British_br...
- rgblambda 6y agoGerry Adams claimed he was first arrested for selling the party newspaper. There was a strange, not illegal but harassed anyway, sort of relationship between Sinn Fein and the authorities.
- im3w1l 6y agoAntifa shows up to other groups' protests to start fights and engage in political violence, sometimes with deadly consequences. Is that what SWP does too?
- senorjazz 6y agoNo. OP made a bad analogy. Antifa will meet violence with violence and don't mind a bit of direct action. SWP are a legitimate socialist party
- dpwm 6y agoMy first encounter with the SWP was at a stall outside a university building. They didn't seem shouty, but I remember asking questions and getting vague, half-thought-out answers. Then about ten years later, I met a couple who were ex SWP but switched to labour once Corbyn became leader. I was reminded slightly of that stall by Corbyn's speeches. It's worth noting that the harder left Communist Party of Great Britain (Marxist-Leninist) can only really talk of imperialism, bourgeois democracy, the labour aristocracy and overproduction — at least in relation to the UK. No serious leftist group in the UK is even hoping for the conditions in which a revolution might be possible, because in those conditions they believe that the counterrevolutionaries would be the darlings of the UK media, would have near full police backing, and would likely target leftists as an enemy to deal with.
- angry_octet 6y agoThe sudden increase in Labour membership and Corbyn coming to power suddenly makes more sense.
- konjin 6y agoYou could just look at policy support. People like far left policies far more than anyone would expect.
- jlokier 6y agoThe increase in Labour membership was significantly higher than the number of SWP members, and I would guess the number of ex-SWP members as well. So I don't think ex-SWP people were driving that. I saw a lot of pro-Corbyn comments on my Facebook feed a few years ago and they were from comfortably middle-class people. Lefty and green tendencies, centre-left (not hard-left) types. Some of them previously Lib Dem supporters. The gist was "at last an honest politician!" and "for the first time in a long time, we have a chance at real socially progressive policies, this one is worth voting for". In other words Corbyn seemed different somehow, and in a good way. Corbyn gave many people a feeling of hope for a few years, especially young people but including all ages, against an establishment regarded as cruel. That hopefulness grew into a mass movement to join Labour specifically tied to Corbyn and his policies. Labour's manifesto policies under Corbyn were generally popular, even though it fell apart in 2019 over Brexit and painting Corbyn as a terrorist sympathiser. Now that Corbyn is out of the picture, Labour looks like Tory-lite again, and there's not much enthusiasm for current Labour from those who enthusiastically switched to it a few years ago. It's not surprising after the landslide loss in 2019 that the party would change to accommodate what it thinks the electorate will vote for (on balance), and the swell of membership under Corbyn would not like the changed party.
- coolestuk 6y ago"in no way shape or form a terrorist or criminal organisation". Says you. The SWP are followers of Leon Trotsky. https://socialistworker.co.uk/event/view/10735 https://socialistworker.co.uk/event/view/10735 Trotsky literally wrote a book advocating terrorism, a rebuke to socialists who deplored terrorism. https://www.marxists.org/archive/trotsky/1920/terrcomm/ https://www.marxists.org/archive/trotsky/1920/terrcomm/
- mjburgess 6y agoA "criminal or terrorist organisation" is one which commits crimes or acts of terror. Your own reasoning, ie., guilt by ideological association, no doubt implicates everyone -- including you.
- jjgreen 6y agoTrotskists oppose terrorism (generally called "individual terrorism") not on moral grounds but due to efficacy. The book you're linking to is Trotsky's argument against individual terrorism and in favour of mass workers' action.
- stiray 6y ago> way too serious bunch of ideological zombies ranting into microphones at the Student's Union about the latest crimes against humanity perpetrated by 'Thatcher' Just to inform you. Reagan and Thatcher have literally f* up the world by allowing banks to devaluate currency and forming a situation where my bank will charge me for having money deposited with them (instead of paying interests) while giving credits with money they dont have or in another words - they print the money instead of the state. Yes, you might think that they are bunch of weird people but the history proven fact is that the weird people was everyone else. Bottom line, they were right. And be very sorry they weren't laud enough as R&T brought the world in neverending crysis cycle that directly impacts you and me. And it has nothing to do with socialism but rather with pure greed, while the only issue is people not having enough of sane thought to figure it out on their own. > To all down-voting me, please DO CHECK what the R&T reforms are about. And no, it has nothing to do with gold backing up currency. It is just crazy how little are people aware of history that directly impacts them. R&T literally gave "carte blanche" to the banks.
- aww_dang 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Volcker#Chairman_of_the_Federal_Reserve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Volcker#Chairman_of_the_F...
- overscore 6y agoMore directly, Thatcher was also responsible for a litany of crimes, including murder and torture, and human rights abuses against her own citizens in Northern Ireland. Although Thatcher is hated by swaths of UK society (which turns out to exist after all), there is in Great Britain in general an ignorance or blindness to crimes committed by the State against their own citizenry.
- antihero 6y agoThey're pretty much loathed in the left. They're more like PETA than antifa, they cover up internal sexual assaults, have a bunch of cranks, and other groups have to put up with and try to prevent their continuous entryism, hijacking protests and other actions to self-promote. Lots of cranks (though probably less so than CPGB-ML who are full on tankies), and a giant pain in the backside. Nevertheless, whilst I chuckle at this, it is a dangerous thing and yet another reason Facebook should not be trusted as any sort of impartial platform and probably dismantled.
- pjc50 6y ago> CPGB-ML who are full on tankies It remains astonishing that a number of these people did a full 180 turn to right-libertarians and from there to Brexiteers, eventually leading to Claire Fox, apologist for the bombing of Manchester, becoming a member of the House of Lords. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claire_Fox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claire_Fox
- antihero 6y agoThey're cranks. The "left-wing brexit" I think was in part inspired by anti-globalism and not wanting to see financial migrants as more readily and cheaply exploitable labour but it was weird.
- dpwm 6y ago> > CPGB-ML who are full on tankies > It remains astonishing that a number of these people did a full 180 turn to right-libertarians and from there to Brexiteers, eventually leading to Claire Fox, apologist for the bombing of Manchester, becoming a member of the House of Lords. Claire fox was never CPGB-ML, but the “Revolutionary Communist Party.” From what I can understand, the RCP was always a primarily contrarian entity and always more libertarian than Marxist. To quote their journal, Living Marxism: > We live in an age of caution and conformism, when critical opinions can be outlawed as 'extremism' and anything new can be rubbished as 'too risky'. Ours is an age of low expectations, when we are always being told what is bad for us, and life seems limited on all sides by restrictions, guidelines and regulations. The spirit of LM is to go against the grain: to oppose all censorship, bans and codes of conduct; to stand up for social and scientific experimentation; to insist that we have the right to live as autonomous adults who take responsibility for our own affairs. These are basic human values that cannot be compromised if we are ever going to create a world fit for people. [0] This seems to have more in common with the libertarian right than Marxist, particularly “to insist that we have the right to live as autonomous adults who take responsibility for our own affairs,” which is almost the antithesis of Marxism. > Fox stayed with her ex-RCP members when the group transformed itself in the early 2000s into a network around the web magazine Spiked Online and the Institute of Ideas, both based in the former RCP offices and promoting libertarianism. [1] Given their apparent funding, contrarian headline-generating antics and subsequent banding together, some may question whether they were a model for what would come later: an opaquely funded right-libertarian outlet. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Living_Marxism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Living_Marxism [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claire_Fox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claire_Fox
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoThe main FB page is now back but they claim other local pages are not: https://swp.org.uk/1049-2/ https://swp.org.uk/1049-2/ I'm not sure how they SWP got banned - I guess some pro palestinian posts may have strayed into the antisemitic territory?
- dpwm 6y ago> I guess some pro palestinian posts may have strayed into the antisemitic territory? My understanding is that any pro-palestinian posts can be labeled antisemitic under the IHRA/EUMC working definition of antisemitism (as adopted into UK law) if it any way singles out Israel for the oppression in a way not done for other states. > “criticism of Israel similar to that levelled against any other country cannot be regarded as antisemitic” This to me seems vague and a point of likely disputed interpretations likely to have at the very least a chilling effect.
- _Understated_ 6y agoIf I had to guess, they were banned because of this: "The SWP Facebook page regularly posts in support of Palestine, Black Lives Matter and against Boris Johnson’s Covid policies" In particular, the COVID part is where I'd put my money.
- DonaldFisk 6y agoThe're in favour of a tighter lockdown to save more lives: https://socialistworker.co.uk/art/51093/Action+needed+now+to+stop+Tories+disastrous+Covid+19+policies https://socialistworker.co.uk/art/51093/Action+needed+now+to...
- GrantSolar 6y agoWhat makes you say that? People against Boris's policies are not to be conflated with anti-maskers. We are currently the worst performing nation per capita.
- senorjazz 6y ago> They're sort of our equivalent of Antifa in that they are a significant organising presence in lefty street protests I can see the point you are trying to make being familiar with both, but for those who are not, this analogy is just wrong and confusing to those who do not know SWP and will think you are saying SWP have no qualms about using violence. That is wrong
- simonh 6y agoI thought I explained my understanding of the SWP attitude to violence very clearly, so for what you say to be true someone would have to read just the Antifa comparison and not read the rest of my post, in which case I think that misunderstanding is on them.
- senorjazz 6y ago> They're sort of our equivalent of Antifa in that they are a significant organising presence in lefty street protests Are you trying to give a wrong opinion of SWP. No "ultra violent, red army faction types" are joining the SWP. Also your use of "ultra violent" / "red army" surely is used to incorrectly ascertain that there are parts of the left that are much more violent than they actually are.
- monopoledance 6y agoI think the "red army" is referring to RAF (Red Army Faction, "Baader-Meinhof complex" in Germany), Red Brigades (Italy) and so on, in 70s, 80s European history. Actual leftist terrorist organisations, unlike the "antifa" (lol, America...). Edit: I think OP meant, it's not unlikely, if there was a real left terrorist organization, they would align with SWP, but the SWP is not the terrorist organisation. Same as with Antifa, for that matter. That's what people mean when they say Antifa is an idea... seriously, it hurts it's necessary to even say this.
- simonh 6y agoYep, that's exactly what I meant.
- belorn 6y agoThere exist an important finding in social science when it comes to conflicts between groups. The Out-group homogeneity effect. When people of an in-group (and those who feel a slight relation to them) describe themselves, it one of complexity. In-groups are always a group of individuals with individual graces and faults. Out-groups however is not complex, but perceived as being more alike with their out-group stereotypes being the defining nature of them. The result of this is that people tend to marginalize extremist views of the in-group, while at the same time defining the out-group by their extremists. This makes it very difficult, if not impossible, to have discussions that relies on the distinction between a group having a small number individual impressionable young people that occasionally happen to do an obvious bad thing, and a other group where every member is evil and its obvious an evil group that need to be stopped at the core. On a more local note regarding the far left here in Sweden during the 90's and early 00, a major distinction between them and the social left were that they believed in a violent/forceful revolution against capitalism (take from the rich, give to the people). As a party they have since tried to put some distance to that view in order to be more respectable, but 20 years is not that long ago. The far right and far left is often debated as both being parties with extremists in them and with troubling pasts for which they try to distance themselves.
- collyw 6y agoYou will probably find that the SNP is more of a "main left of Labour" party in Britain.
- gadders 6y agoWhen I was at a left-wing university in the early 90's, it was mostly full of posh kids trying to upset their parents.
- tikiman163 6y agoAntifa isn't a real organization, it's just a bunch of disconnected groups that have recently been getting labeled as Antifa. Most don't even claim to be part of Antifa. Antifa is basically the boogeyman that Republicans made up to distract from the fact that a bunch of far right wing people were literally organizing armed pseudo-militias with the intent of overthrowing the US government. They knew these idiots stood no chance so they downplayed them and made up conspiracies about left wingers doing the same shit, and pretending like there was a serious threat from the left instead of the right.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- einpoklum 6y ago> I always found them quite comical. Sounds like you were fine with Thatcher taking an axe to organized labor, and weren't all that bothered about those children dying in Africa or what-not. After all, unlike them, you weren't "way too serious". > If they are getting banned by Facebook something has gone horribly wrong. Well, many things have gone horribly wrong. Among them, one thing that's wrong is: > Quite possibly some of them got a bit excited and posted things they shouldn't this outlook on things.