3 ms·
When I see this kind of bounty for open source projects, I immediately think of this psychology anecdote: when you tip people to give their blood or sperm, the
by littlestymaar 6y ago
When I see this kind of bounty for open source projects, I immediately think of this psychology anecdote: when you tip people to give their blood or sperm, the number of donor goes down, not up. Why? Because you don't really pay them, it's too low to matter and never covers the time spent anyway (even at the minimum wage). Yet, now people are not giving it, it became part of a transaction and it completely changes how the reward mechanism in the brain is stimulated: when giving, you're proud of yourself for giving, when in a transaction, the amount matters.
In order to have a net positive effect, such a program would need to be able to generate an income, not necessarily a engineer market-level one (because you could have students working on this) but at least something above the minimum wage[1], not just tips.
[1]: and at this level, you'd still not attract more affluent kids who don't need a job.
- m12k 6y agoThe book Predictably Irrational has a great section about this. Basically we have a "market" way of thinking and a "social/gift" way of thinking about goods. When something is free we think of it in the latter way, when it's not, we use the market mindset. And the transition can be jarring - say you're selling cookies. If you lower the price, people buy more cookies. Lower it a lot to, say $.01 per cookie and people will buy all of them. Then lower it all the way to free and people will suddenly take fewer again. Why? Because when you buy all the cookies at $.01 you're a shrewd merchant, but when you take all the free cookies, you're the asshole who took all the free cookies, so there's none left for everyone else. It's two different mindsets, leading to a discontinuity in the supply and demand graph.
- bambax 6y agoYes, there are also related examples of this in some of Ariely's books. If you introduce a fine for showing up late at daycare the number of late people and the average lateness goes up, not down, because then people are "buying" the right to be late for example.
- faeyanpiraat 6y agoOr maybe if you do not have a specified fine, then in the heads of people there is still a “virtual fine” associated with being late, but it is not an exact number, but a wide range, and people tend to predict all kinds of bad things that would happen (but 99% of times it wont happen), so the fear of an unknown punishment is higher than a known one.
- bambax 6y agoIntuitively the present value of punishment is amount of punishment x probability of getting it, and if the second term is nil then so is the punishment; but according to many studies I believe the amount of punishment is much less important and being caught is what matters.
- dash2 6y agoThere were some issues with the paper you're citing ("A fine is a price"). I believe a grad student wanted to replicate their analyses and they told him the data had been lost, which is pretty weird. I wonder if anyone has replicated the experiment.
- azhenley 6y ago> they told him the data had been lost, which is pretty weird I don't think that is weird at all. After the lead student on a project leaves, the faculty, especially non-technical or not so organized ones, may not even know how to access the data anymore. Who knows what arcane scripts or processes are needed to get it in a shareable form. There can also be hoops with the IRB to jump through and a lot of effort in general to give someone access to data. I had an IRB insist that all raw data be deleted after 2 years of collection anyway, so by the time the paper got published the raw data had to be deleted forever. I wish it were easier to release data and replication kits, but sadly the incentives aren't there.
- dash2 6y agoFor big names in a field not to know to keep their data - certainly today, that would be shocking. I think it was quite shocking even back then. I still have my data for my work from my PhD in the 2000s. It isn't a job you'd leave to a student. IRB hoops are a different matter - but this wasn't that, as I recall.
- xeromal 6y agoIs the book worth reading?
- m12k 6y agoI'd say so - it's a very accessible introduction to behavioral economics. Similarly, "Stumbling on Happiness" is an easy introduction to the psychology of happiness, but also tells you a lot about perception, memory and decision-making, and the illusions and biases we have. And finally "Thinking, Fast and Slow" is a slightly deeper and longer but still accessible book that digs into the details about how many of the biases we have (that the other books talk about) arise due to the interplay between the conscious and unconscious parts of our brains - it felt like a deeper explanation, but I'm glad I read after reading about most of the biases before in the "lighter" books.
- xeromal 6y agoThank you so much for the reply. I'm gonna check all these out but I'll start with Predictably Irrational. Have a good one!
- zaphirplane 6y agoInteresting because if the supermarket/grocery store has a 0.01 steaks and someone placed the whole lot in their trolley I am very sure people will posting about the asshole on social media
- plif 6y ago> In order to have a net positive effect, such a program would need to be able to generate an income, not necessarily a engineer market-level one (because you could have students working on this) but at least something above the minimum wage[1], not just tips. The pay scale is going to be tough. Looking quickly through the top bounties, none of them are really student level. Issues that are truly good for beginners or someone unfamiliar with the codebase in any moderately popular open source project usually get scooped up immediately for resume building. I can see this as being useful for abandoned projects, or as a way to promote something new. It's a much better signal that the ticket is actually meaningful and impactful than a GitHub tag. Whether that is enough to get past psychological barriers behind transactions, I don't know. I do like the "buy the author a coffee or two" mentality of support, which I think does remove some of the transaction aspect of it. Not sure if this is what Rysolv was going for -- it feels a bit more formal.
- themanmaran 6y ago> students I have funded a couple issues at like $25 that were marked "Good First Issue". And I had a couple people reach out saying they were excited to have done their first pull request. So I think that even with small bounties, rysolv can have the positive affect of introducing more people into OS contributing. And if the site ends up making money, I think there should always be a list of "First Time Only" issues.
- xwdv 6y agoPaying bounties for people to fix issues removes the altruistic aspect of being a generous open source contributor. Instead it makes you seem like a money grubbing bastard that’s hard up for cash.
- z3t4 6y agoThen we get the "problem" that many people want to do the job and you have to choose which one does it.
- billfruit 6y agoThe amount might make a decent difference esp, if you come from a 3rd world country.
- themanmaran 6y ago> Spend a week working on this issue for free? No problem! I love to contribute to software I use. > Spend a week working on this issue for $50? No way! I'd never work for so little. I can certainly see it having this affect. And hopefully there will be ways to mitigate it. But I don't see any harm in trying to bring some additional funding into OSS development. Also I feel like it would be nice supplemental income for sole maintainers, who would likely be tackling these issues anyway.