4 ms·
> Having developed only one small iOS app with Objective-C code, I was mostly turned off by its overall verbosity in the context of NS prefixes. This is actual
by astrange 6y ago
> Having developed only one small iOS app with Objective-C code, I was mostly turned off by its overall verbosity in the context of NS prefixes.
This is actually a blessing because NS-/name prefixes are a simple approach to naming that keeps you humble. If you let programmers have namespacing they will invent enterprise software frameworks where every class is six layers deep in a namespace of random tech buzzwords they thought up.
> Hence, I ask the question on behalf myself and others who did not appreciate the language and did not give it a proper chance... what did I miss and what are its top appeals?
It implements message-based programming, which is "real" OOP and more powerful than something like C++, where OOP just means function calls where the first parameter goes to the left of the function name instead of the right.
In particular it implements this pattern: https://wiki.c2.com/?AlternateHardAndSoftLayers https://wiki.c2.com/?AlternateHardAndSoftLayers
which is great for UI programming and lets you define the UI in data rather than code. Although iOS programmers seem to like doing it in code anyway.
- jonhohle 6y agoThis plague of object wiring in code is pervasive in the Java world as well. The joy of declarative late binding and decoupled objects at compile time seems to be very lost on the vast majority of programmers.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago> It implements message-based programming, which is "real" OOP No, it's message-based programming, which is a very powerful and useful tool. It's not the one true inheritor of the fundamental OOP concept. OOP wasn't defined by "you send messages to objects", it was defined by the idea that objects had their own semantics which in turn constrained/defined the things you could do with them. Some OOP languages implemented "doing something to an object" as "send it a message"; some didn't. ObjC is in the former group; C++ is in the latter.
- mpweiher 6y agoWell, considering that Alan Kay coined the term...
- zepto 6y agoAbsolutely incorrect: http://wiki.c2.com/?AlanKayOnMessaging http://wiki.c2.com/?AlanKayOnMessaging
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoAlan Kay didn't invent object oriented programming though he was instrumental in expanding its scope and usage. Simula 67 was a big influence on Kay's work, and as he has noted, the "revelation" that "it's all messages" was a huge one. But Smalltalk is just one OOP language, not the only one and not even the original one (though we could argue about how much Simula was or was not OOP, and I'd rather not). The message from Kay you cite about is strictly about Smalltalk & Squeak: > The big idea is "messaging" - that is what the kernal of Smalltalk/Squeak is all about He doesn't say "what OOP is all about".
- zepto 6y agoActually he did invent Object Oriented programming. Simula was an inspiration, but was never considered as object oriented. After Kay came up with the concept, Simula was identified as part of the historical background. “I invented the term object oriented, and I can tell you that C++ wasn't what I had in mind.” —Alan Kay.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoDahl & Nygard would not agree with you: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0890540113000795 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S089054011... http://kristennygaard.org/FORSKNINGSDOK_MAPPE/F_OO_start.html http://kristennygaard.org/FORSKNINGSDOK_MAPPE/F_OO_start.htm... Kay came up with the term "object oriented programming", but he has made it very clear that what he had in mind has little relationship to what most people mean by that term today. If you want to give Kay veto power over the correct application of the term, be my guest but please be consistent across all other cases where a word or phrase changes its meaning over time. Contemporary OOP pays only lip service to Kay's ideas (something he would be the first to say), and is only tangentially influenced by Smalltalk at this point (Objective C probably being one of the few widely used counterpoints to that).