4 ms·
I assume this is a mistake, although I think they're mad I don't think the SWP are malicious a la some political sects
by mhh__ 6y ago
I assume this is a mistake, although I think they're mad I don't think the SWP are malicious a la some political sects
- Veen 6y agoYes, it seems unlikely this is deliberate. The SWP is about as likely to forment a revolution or incite violence as Judi Dench. They're a bunch of harmless eccentrics.
- fao_ 6y agoQuite literally. The only vaguely-'revolutionary' thing the SWP have done in the last 10 years is provide protest signs for movements that other, more influencial groups of people started.
- wilsonrocks 6y agoIf I see any pictures of UK footage I can usually identify the signs the SWP have given out by the font.
- im3w1l 6y agoAccording to the article, it was not just the page that was removed. That could have been a mistake, I suppose. But Facebook also banned "dozens of leading SWP activists". That sounds like a very deliberate action to me.
- notahacker 6y agoTo me that sounds even more like an algorithm at work, and quite possibly one more concerned with identifying possible fake accounts than identifying political violence (Relevant context: the SWP is tiny and inconsequential, but very active in coordinating its [unlikely to be violent] messaging and inflating its importance. Nobody would know who its "dozens of leading activists" were to target them. And its local group pages are still up and easily discoverable by searching, so if it was a deliberate action to silence the party it would be a very sloppy one)
- dathinab 6y ago> that sounds even more like an algorithm at work It doesn't matters. You are as much responsible for decisions done by your algorithms as you are for decisions done by people. If you can not guarantee that algorithms work in the parameters of moral and law you can not use them. It is that simple.
- chroem- 6y agoFacebook is a private platform: they're free to block any content they want, malicious or not.
- mhh__ 6y agoThey are also mainly motivated by money, which allows us to make at least educated guesses as to what happened in matters like these
- chroem- 6y agoThat's irrelevant, because a private company can't be compelled to support someone else's speech against their will. If you don't like it, then take political action. Edit: For those unaware, this is the devil's advocate take. HN has been remarkably pro-corporate censorship lately, and only a matter of weeks later its coming back to bite pro-censorship advocates.
- r00fus 6y agoExactly. This was what Facebook wanted, for whatever reasons. Unless they say otherwise.
- 23B1 6y agoI'm mostly tired of this take, especially by technologists. First off: you're right. You can't compel a private company to support speech. But the entirety of political discourse happens online now. There's a clear and prevailing interest that free speech can happen online, at scale.
- maxwell 6y agoHonestly, the market will take care of it: who's comfortable hosting their content on the platform any more? They've alienated the right and the left. At the end of the day/century, FB is just a random internet site/app. Discourse is online, yes, but the zeitgeist left FB years ago. Zuck's fate will catch up with him fast, now that their network effect has broken, or is close to doing so. It's already over. FB/IG/WhatsApp are all clearly dead, in the Grahamian sense.
- steffandroid 6y agoMight want to read up on Comrade Delta.
- mike_d 6y ago> The SWP Facebook page regularly posts [...] against Boris Johnson’s Covid policies. I can't find any specifics on the position they hold, but the UK is pretty much in line with the US on mask mandates and lockdowns in hotspots.
- rvz 6y ago> I assume this is a mistake... This isn't their first 'mistake' to shut them down. Unless of course Facebook believes that this group has broken their rules which resulted them on getting shut down. Regardless, Facebook is a private platform and can shut down whoever they want. Mistake or not.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoNewspapers are peivate, but they have to follow some rules. And pay taxes
- dathinab 6y ago> Regardless, Facebook is a private platform and can shut down whoever they want. Mistake or not. No.. I mean yes in the US but not necessary in other countries. Not all countries free speech and anti discreminatory laws which are as weak as in the US (the US free speech law is just about government interference in free speech but not free speech itself). In Germany this would have been in violation with multiple laws as far as I know.